Wikipedia:New pages patrol/Backlog drives/October 2023/Re-reviews

To re-review articles, list your name below followed by a numbered list of the articles you have re-reviewed. To find articles to re-review, go to Wikipedia:Database reports/Top new article reviewers, pick any editor, and visit the log to find articles that they have reviewed since the start of the drive. Make sure to note the original reviewer and whether the original review was correct. If you found problems with the original review, please discuss it with the original reviewer on the backlog drive talk page. Redirects do not count towards re-reviewing totals.

Schminnte edit

  1. On My LoveUser:ULPS — article was patrolled: no copyvio concerns, meets GNG and point one of NSONG. Good patrol.
  2. VelleppamUser:Illusion Flame — article was patrolled as it is currently at AfD. In the meantime, no serious content problems found. Good patrol.
  3. Thothapuri: Chapter 2User:Idoghor Melody — article meets NFILM. Some minor problems that were not fixed but good review.
  4. Wild Man (film)User:JackFromWisconsin — meets NFILM, no copyright issues, good review.
  5. Maro KontouUser:Significa liberdade — marked for deletion by BLPPROD: since it's a politician, there was a reference for her being in parliament. I have removed the BLPPROD tag. Review needed a better before check.
  6. List of awards and honors received by Gloria RomeroUser:Tails Wx — Good patrol, article is well sourced and meets NLIST.
  7. Juice (TV series)User:Tails Wx — Good patrol, article meets GNG clearly, no copyright concerns.
  8. List of awards and nominations received by Justine TrietUser:ULPS — no copyright concerns, meets NLIST, good patrol.
  9. Saint Ann's FortUser:Clovermoss — meets WP:GEOLAND as a recognised heritage site. No problems, good patrol
  10. KusumdesarUser:DreamRimmer — meets GEOLAND as a legally recognized populated village, thank you for adding the census data! No issues, good patrol.
  11. Badis limaakumiUser:Pichpich — meets species notability pseudoguideline. No other problems.
  12. Pokémon and pornographyUser:DreamRimmer — article is at AfD, no serious concerns in the meantime. Good patrol.
  13. Untitled Series (with Sean Kalish)User:ClydeFranklin — good patrol, no copyright issues.
  14. Norwich Northern Distributor RoadUser:Pichpich — good patrol after redirect vandalism.
  15. Miriama Rauhihi-NessUser:GMH Melbourne — no copyvio, meets ANYBIO. Good patrol.
  16. Tropico, CaliforniaUser:GMH Melbourne — meets GNG clearly, no copyvio or other visible problems.
  17. Manoj MittaUser:Sohom Datta — meets WP:NCREATIVE as the creator of a well known notable work, shown by various book reviews from reliable sources. Good review.
  18. Wash, DerbyshireJeBonSer — meets GEOLAND, no other concerns
  19. Wendelin StambachJeBonSer — meets NPROF#6, not much else to comment on. Good patrol
  20. The Carrier (film)User:DreamRimmer — meets NFILM, page was tagged previously. Good patrol
  21. Jacksons on GeorgeUser:Simon Peter Hughes— meets GNG, no copyvio or other problems. Good patrol
  22. ParadigmesUser:Simon Peter Hughes— meets GNG by merit of reviews, no copyvio. Good
  23. Brijesh Singh (Indian Politician)User:Sohom Datta — in my opinion, does not meet NPOL or GNG. Good AfD tag and patrol.
  24. Injuries in netballUser:Stuartyeates — meets GNG, was flagged by copypatrol but no action was needed. Good patrol.
  25. Border ModelUser:Wikishovel — I'm AGFing the before search, but this rationale seems well in line with NCORP. Good AfD.
  26. María Francisca BelloUser:Kj cheetham — meets NPOL, good patrol.
  27. Dry shipperUser:Clovermoss — meets GNG, no cv problems, good patrol

Coordinator’s comments edit

Chris Troutman edit

  1. Version 5.0User:ULPS — patrolled; no copyvio, no puffery, clear claim to notability which is cited.
  2. Ora and Theo CosterUser:ULPS — I'll raise issue on the talk page.
  3. Carin BryggmanUser:ULPS — Subject passes ANYBIO though the award the subject won should have been wikilinked; claim is cited though we're assuming good faith on a bunch of print sources not in English. No copyvio detected.
  4. Family Guy (season 22)User:ULPS — Meh. It would survive AfD because of fans. It's not a copyvio.
  5. 1965–66 Hartlepools United F.C. seasonUser:ULPS — I don't see notability here.
  6. PimEyesUser:ULPS — A laughable one-sentence article but the sources are there.
  7. Walter F. HendricksUser:ULPS — I guess founding three universities is a pass. No copyvio. Sources are present though they're all primary.
  8. List of roles in the British ArmyUser:DreamRimmer — Nope.
  9. The Price (1971 film)User:DreamRimmer — No copyvio. In the future, please tag where there are large portions of text needing citation.
  10. Blockade EntertainmentUser:DreamRimmer — You were right to tag as you did and you might have been more aggressive. I have real questions that the author has a CoI.
  11. Papunta Ka Pa Lang, Pabalik Na AkoUser:DreamRimmer — Subject fails NFILM, so I've nom'd for deletion.
  12. Eseng ng TondoUser:DreamRimmer — I tag-bombed it. I encourage you to look at the sources, because mere mentions or sources from broadcasters don't equate to notability.
  13. The ChillingUser:DreamRimmer — Fails NFILM, I nom'd for deletion.
  14. Jim DownsUser:Schminnte — Subject meets NPROF, even though article is two sentences.
  15. Lakota Nation vs. United StatesUser:Schminnte — Again: few sentences but many sources. Subject meets GNG.
  16. Amos BadertscherUser:Schminnte — Good patrol; I tagged with "sources exist" because there is more than the obits listed.
  17. Sliman BensmaiaUser:Schminnte — Good patrol: no COPYVIO. Subject is notable.
  18. Gboyega OdubanjoUser:Schminnte — Good patrol: no COPYVIO. Subject meets ANYBIO.
  19. Masami KawamuraUser:JTtheOG — Good tag for deletion
  20. Graham UrquhartUser:JTtheOG — Good tag for deletion
  21. Columbia 'Coco' DiazUser:Thilsebatti — I don't think the subject is notable based upon what's present in the article.
  22. Aishwarya MishraUser:Thilsebatti — Maybe this subject meets WP:NATHLETE or WP:GNG; I guess we'll call it a pass.
  23. Darshna RathoreUser:Thilsebatti — On a skeet team that finished fourth in the Asian Games? That's a stretch.
  24. Patricia Moreno (teacher)User:Thilsebatti — No COPYVIO; coverqge in newspapers is sufficient
  25. Aliza Magen-HaleviUser:Thilsebatti — No COPYVIO; language is fine; citations are fine
  26. List of Negombo Cricket Club playersUser:Rosguill — Meh. I don't link entries that aren't blue-links but that's beyond the procedure for patrolling
  27. Estate (2022 film)User:Rosguill — Enough reviews for notability
  28. 2023 National League Championship SeriesUser:Troutfarm27 — No COPYVIO; certainly sport media produces tons of source material
  29. 13th Streamy AwardsUser:Troutfarm27 — Enough sources for notability

Coordinator’s comments edit

Hey man im josh edit

  1. 2024 Arizona electionsJTtheOG Y
  2. 2000 South Carolina Democratic presidential caucusesJTtheOG Y
  3. 2000 Colorado Democratic presidential primaryJTtheOG Y

Coordinator’s comments edit

Joseywales1961 edit

  1. Removal of Eduardo CunhaSchminnte – correctly tagged cat improve (since improved)
  2. Cathedral of CoroSchminnte – no issues
  3. William Lacey AmyReading Beans – correctly tagged ref improve (since improved)
  4. Thank You for Sending Me an AngelReading Beans – no issues
  5. Delvis LumpuyJTtheOG – sent to AfD, good call
  6. 2023 Shore Lunch 200JTtheOG – no issues
  7. Treaty of Mungi-ShevgaonChris troutman – no issues
  8. Last Known PositionChris troutman – no issues
  9. Noor ZamanThilsebatti – no issues
  10. Marija RazgutėThilsebatti – correctly tagged for unreliable and more sources needed
  11. The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills (season 13)ULPS – no issues
  12. Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981ULPS – I added a stub tag
  13. 2023 Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council, Kargil electionSimon Peter Hughes – correctly tagged for linkrot (I couldn't quick fix with refill as they are PDFs)
  14. Long Jie (disambiguation)Simon Peter Hughes – no issues
  15. Raveena DahaSimon Peter Hughes – no issues
  16. 77th Tony AwardsPichpich – I added a stub tag
  17. Imran ShariefPichpich – rightly sent to AfD by reviewer
  18. Jules Doret NdongoPichpich – I added a stub tag
  19. Republic Of Korea Civil Defense CorpsJackFromWisconsin – correctly tagged for more sources
  20. Killing of Jared LowndesJackFromWisconsin – no issues
  21. Syazrul IdrusJackFromWisconsin – no issues
  22. Ram BabooPaul Vaurie – I added a stub tag
  23. Zwalm (river)Paul Vaurie – no issues
  24. Jakub SypekPaul Vaurie – no issues
  25. Marzieh ArfaKj cheetham – no issues
  26. Lady Sarah Child-VilliersKj cheetham – correctly tagged ref improve and cat improve
  27. Tom BrightMaliner – no issues

Coordinator’s comments edit

MicrobiologyMarcus edit

  1. Fourth Siege of SzenttamásHawkeye7 – No issues, good patrol.
  2. Integration of Normandy into the royal domain of the Kingdom of FranceHawkeye7 – No issues, good patrol.
  3. If I Were a Boy (disambiguation)Reading Beans – No issues, good patrol.
  4. William Lacey AmyReading Beans – No issues, good patrol.
  5. Annaghmare Court TombShellwood – I added stub tag. Good patrol.
  6. Flag of BrittanyShellwood – Pre-existing tags, good patrol.
  7. Roller speed skating at the 2022 Asian Games – Women's inline speed slalomSimon Peter Hughes – Removed erroneous heading, good patrol.
  8. Esto Es BrujeriaSimon Peter Hughes – Tagged page as categorized; page then immediately draftified by Maliner. Discussed on backlog drive talk page.
  9. Kimani MarugeUtopes – No issues, good patrol.
  10. TopolobampoUtopes – No issues, good patrol.
  11. Linping Sports Centre GymnasiumFuzzyMagma – No issues, good patrol.
  12. EparitiFuzzyMagma – Added orphan tag, good patrol.
  13. Eugene Chan (professor)JackFromWisconsin – No issues, good patrol.
  14. Bandung Timur F.C.JackFromWisconsin – No issues, good patrol.
  15. Hurricane Lisa (2022)Tails Wx – No issues, good patrol.
  16. Miss Grand International 2013Tails Wx – No issues, good patrol.
  17. Gyaneshwar, KathmanduEdward-Woodrow – Pre-existing tag, good patrol.
  18. New ASU Stadium (redirect) – Edward-Woodrow – No issues, good patrol.
  19. Sydney A. ClarkJustiyaya – Added orphan tag, good patrol.
  20. Brodie Lee's Celebration of Life (redirect) – Justiyaya – No issues, good patrol.
  21. Aquarion Water CompanyStuartyeates – Added primary sources tag, good patrol.
  22. Election denial movementStuartyeates – Pre-existing tag, good patrol.
  23. Roman public assemblies (redirect) – EggRoll97 – No issues, good patrol.
  24. OnTracEggRoll97 – No issues, good patrol.
  25. Daniil YerofeyevTartarTorte – Pre-existing {{notability}} tag, added {{Proposed deletion}} tag; good patrol.
  26. Fartnite (redirect) – TartarTorte – Submitted for {{Rfd-NPF/core}}, good patrol.
  27. Wendy's frosty (redirect) – Clovermoss – No issues, good patrol.
  28. General secretary of the Romanian Communist Party (redirect) – Clovermoss – No issues, good patrol.
  29. The Penang Riots (1867)SunDawn – No issues, good patrol.
  30. 2022 Prince Takamado U-18 Premier LeagueSunDawn – No issues, good patrol.
  31. The Mill (2023 film)ULPS – No issues, good patrol.
  32. You Can't Run ForeverULPS – No issues, good patrol.
  33. La peor de mis bodas 3Rkieferbaum – No issues, good patrol.
  34. Death of Armita GeravandRkieferbaum – No issues, good patrol.
  35. Donlin LongKj cheetham – No issues, good patrol.
  36. Susan MurabanaKj cheetham – No issues, good patrol.
  37. Jayden FieldingLightburst – No issues, good patrol.
  38. Dillon JohnsonLightburst – No issues, good patrol.
  39. Sagi RiverSohom Datta – No issues, good patrol.
  40. NetLingoSohom Datta – Added {{Proposed deletion}} tag; good patrol.

Coordinator’s comments edit

VickKiang edit

  1. Wild for da Night- JackfromWiscosin- fails GNG/NSONG. Existing sources were user-generated YouTube videos and a non-SIGCOV database listing by a questionably reliable site. My BEFORE did not find sources meeting GNG or any indication that this charted to meet NSONG. So blanked-and-redirected (note that the page was initially created as a redirect, then expanded, and I BLAR-ed this. As such, this blank and redirect is the first for this page and permitted here).

Coordinator’s comments edit

FuzzyMagma edit

  1. Hiraiwa Shichidayū IISimon Peter Hughes – No issues, good patrol.
  2. Franco de la TorreSimon Peter Hughes – No issues, good patrol.
  3. Langlade County Public TransitSimon Peter Hughes – No issues, good patrol.
  4. Long Jie (disambiguation)Simon Peter Hughes – problems with links, see MOS:DABPERIOD. this page should not be made as per MOS:DABNOLINK A disambiguation page should not be made up completely of red links or have only one blue link on the entire page, because the basic purpose of disambiguation is to refer users to other Wikipedia pages.. Revoked the review and send a message to the page creator and moved the page to the draft space. see Wikipedia talk:New pages patrol/Backlog drives/October 2023#Long Jie (disambiguation)
  5. Rauno KalliaSimon Peter Hughes – good patrol, tagged for expansion and more citation
  6. Vaibhav SuriSimon Peter Hughes – No issues, good patrol.
  7. Absinthe (stallion)Simon Peter Hughes – No issues, good patrol.
  8. Peddha Kapu 1Simon Peter Hughes – No issues, good patrol, tagged for underlink and notability.
  9. Siddhant KambleSimon Peter Hughes – No issues, good patrol.
  10. Monastyrok, Ternopil OblastSimon Peter Hughes – No issues, good patrol.
  11. These Things Take Time (Molly Nilsson album)Pichpich – No issues, good patrol.
  12. Brussels metropolitan areaPichpich – No issues, good patrol.
  13. Line S5 (Chengdu Metro)Pichpich – No issues, good patrol. the article has rough translation issues
  14. Sovereign Right (French politics)Pichpich – No issues, good patrol.
  15. The Master BlastersPichpich – No issues, good patrol.
  16. Kepler-87JackFromWisconsin – No issues, good patrol.
  17. Republic Of Korea Civil Defense CorpsJackFromWisconsin – tagged for issues, good patrol. tagged for expansion
  18. Mi Honar SuperstarJackFromWisconsin – No issues, good patrol.
  19. Here We Are (musical)JackFromWisconsin – No issues, good patrol.
  20. Noor TV (UK)JackFromWisconsin – No issues, good patrol.
  21. Sweet PleasureDreamRimmer – appropriately tagged redirect, good patrol.
  22. Aima (film)DreamRimmer – tagged for improvement, good patrol.
  23. Hubert E. GriggsDreamRimmer – was not tagged as orphan
  24. Mata GangaDreamRimmer – correctly tagged for cats, good patrol.
  25. Maiko TajimaDreamRimmer – No issues, good patrol.

Coordinator’s comments edit

Lightburst edit

  1. User:Lightburst|LightburstUser:Schminnte – No issues, good patrol.
  2. Zbarazh urban hromadaSchminnte – No issues, good patrol.
  3. Shamim Ahmad KhanSchminnte – No issues, good patrol.
  4. Julia GibsonSchminnte – No issues, good patrol.
  5. NettelnburgSchminnte – No issues, good patrol.
  6. Ryland Steen - FuzzyMagma – No issues, good patrol.
  7. Appalachian Highlands - FuzzyMagma – No issues, good patrol.
  8. Micigan - (redirect) FuzzyMagma – No issues, good patrol.
  9. Horses in Slovenia - FuzzyMagma – No issues, good patrol.
  10. Michael Ede - Rosguill – No issues, good patrol.
  11. Never Get Over You - (disambiguation) Rosguill – No issues, good patrol.
  12. I Can Wait Forever - (disambiguation) Rosguill – No issues, good patrol.
  13. Simpson's Rest - (I added a stub tag) Rosguill – No issues, good patrol.
  14. Khalid Al-Esseily SunDawn – No issues, good patrol.
  15. Pilar Marcos Domínguez SunDawn – No issues, good patrol.
  16. Slavenska Banka SunDawn – No issues, good patrol.
  17. 2021 Italy wildfires SunDawn – No issues, good patrol.
  18. Zavojane SunDawn – Seven un-cited paragraphs article I added an insufficient citations tag and sent a message to the reviewer and the article's author.
  19. Wirgnia Joe Roe – Does not appear to pass WP:GEOLAND guide - unreviewed and messaged reviewer and author.
  20. 2023 Serbian local elections Joe Roe – No issues, good patrol.
  21. Ross King (academic) Joe Roe – No issues, good patrol.
  22. Fugoppe Cave Joe Roe – No issues, good patrol.
  23. Cynthia Hamilton Joe Roe – No issues, good patrol.
  24. Sheezan Khan C1K98V – No issues, good patrol.
  25. Black and White (novel) VickKiang – No issues, good patrol.
  26. The Red Cockade VickKiang – No issues, good patrol.

Coordinator’s comments edit

EggRoll97 edit

  1. Longfeng (Han Lin'er) - Rosguill - Looks to be fine, the foreign-language references seem fine from an auto-translation.
  2. Hawaii Federation of Japanese Labor - Rosguill - Could use some more references, but looks fine overall and was already tagged as such.
  3. Grzegorz Mazurek - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  4. Wat Sri Chum Inscription - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  5. Ean Weiler - Rosguill - Not sure of the necessity for having 3 different social media sites of the subject, but looks fine.
  6. SMA House - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  7. Ministry of Poverty Alleviation and Social Safety - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  8. Gambat Institute of Medical Sciences - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  9. Indian cricket team in South Africa in 2023–24 - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  10. Mumbai City FC results by opponent - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  11. Atul Malhotra - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  12. Calgary RATH - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  13. Oyagami - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  14. Japan at the 2013 Asian Indoor and Martial Arts Games - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  15. Guillaume Fourrier - Rosguill - Needs some work, but otherwise good patrol.
  16. Gqeberha: The Empire - Rosguill - Needs fairly significant work, but otherwise good patrol.
  17. Terrifier 3 - Rosguill - Looks fine.
  18. 2023–24 West of Scotland Football League - Rosguill - Looks fine.
  19. Drag Race Belgique (season 1) - Rosguill - Looks good, good patrol.
  20. Aliyaa - Rosguill - I would say at most this barely meets GNG, but I'll stay on the side of, good patrol.
  21. Bélizaire and the Frey Children - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  22. Layla (film) - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  23. RK Alkaloid - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  24. Dequece Carter - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.
  25. Political positions of Mahathir Mohamad - Rosguill - Looks fine, good patrol.

Coordinator’s comments edit

SunDawn edit

  1. Glokk40Spaz - Simon Peter Hughes - This one looks to have some notability problem, I will discuss it with the reviewer.
  2. 2023 Annecy stabbing - JackFromWisconsin -  Y
  3. Clanfield F.C. (Hampshire) - JackFromWisconsin -  Y
  4. Trafag AG - JackFromWisconsin -  Y
  5. Vladyslav Ukrainets - JackFromWisconsin -  Y
  6. 2023 Israel State Cup final - JackFromWisconsin - This only use one source and it should be tagged as such.
  7. Lipkovo crisis - JackFromWisconsin -  Y
  8. Kavor Motorsport - JackFromWisconsin -  Y
  9. The Pacific War and Contingent Victory - JackFromWisconsin -  Y
  10. M44 (Pretoria) - JackFromWisconsin -  Y
  11. Evergreen North–South Airpark - JackFromWisconsin -  Y
  12. EE-S1 - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  13. 10th Flak Division - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  14. 2024 Ulster Senior Football Championship - Simon Peter Hughes - I think the two sources used are too similar and it's a primary source, it should be tagged as such.
  15. 2006 Southeastern Louisiana Lions football team - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  16. Varshavska (Kyiv Metro) - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  17. 2023–24 Abilene Christian Wildcats men's basketball team - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  18. DARPA lunar programs - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  19. 2025 Western Australian local elections - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  20. 2026 Tasmanian local elections - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  21. Mahsa Jina Amini - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  22. 2019 Newcastle 500 - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  23. Murder of Mirelle Hernández - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  24. Plaza Tower (Knoxville, Tennessee) - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  25. 2018 Boni attack - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  26. Ikuta Tunnel - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  27. Compact pebblesnail - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  28. Shale pebblesnail - Simon Peter Hughes -  Y
  29. Liberty Island (horse) - Lightburst -  Y
  30. 11th Armored Division (Syria) - Lightburst -  Y
  31. Sungai Petani Clock Tower - Lightburst -  Y
  32. Hyperia (roller coaster) - Lightburst -  Y
  33. SPT-140 - Lightburst -  Y
  34. 1959–60 AC Milan season - Lightburst -  Y
  35. Flag of Yucatán - Lightburst -  Y
  36. Senzan Tunnel - Lightburst -  Y
  37. Yumesaki Tunnel - Lightburst -  Y
  38. 2nd Flak Division - Lightburst -  Y
  39. Indonesia Hospital - Lightburst -  Y
  40. 2009 Austin Peay Governors football team - Paul Vaurie -  Y
  41. 2023–24 Pro A season - Paul Vaurie -  Y
  42. Zwalm (river) - Paul Vaurie -  Y
  43. Urrós halt - Paul Vaurie -  Y
  44. 2019 Austrian Cup final - Paul Vaurie -  Y
  45. Canada‑Ukraine authorization for emergency travel - Paul Vaurie -  Y
  46. Vehicle insurance in France - Paul Vaurie -  Y

Coordinator’s comments edit

JTtheOG edit

  1. Arras school stabbingActualcpscm – no issues, good patrol
  2. Tristagma bivalveHughesdarren – meets WP:NSPECIES, no issues, good patrol
  3. 2024 AFL draftHughesdarren – probably needs better sourcing, which will become available, fine patrol
  4. Pangshura tatrotiaHughesdarren – meets NSPECIES, no issues, good patrol
  5. 1968 South Africa rugby union tour of FranceHughesdarren – meets WP:GNG, no issues, good patrol
  6. Léon DeffontainesHughesdarren – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  7. 1930s in BulgariaHughesdarren – no issues, good patrol
  8. Naomi CachiaHughesdarren – meets WP:NPOLITICIAN, no issues, good patrol
  9. Laurence SaillietHughesdarren – meets NPOLITICIAN, no issues, good patrol
  10. Lydie MassardHughesdarren – meets NPOLITICIAN, no issues, good patrol
  11. Nadiia, Luhansk OblastHughesdarren – meets WP:NGEO as a populated village, no issues, good patrol
  12. Leonardo (footballer, born 1974)Hughesdarren – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  13. Tremella olensHughesdarren – meets NSPECIES, no issues, good patrol
  14. Nike DunkLightburst – meets GNG, correctly tagged linkrot, good patrol
  15. Brandi BaeLightburst – fails WP:ENT, correctly sent to AfD
  16. Guns N' Roses 2023 TourLightburst – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  17. Osku MaukonenLightburst – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  18. Sulo KetolaLightburst – meets GNG, correctly added stub tag, good patrol
  19. Sofia LeonidakisPaul Vaurie – meets NPOLITICIAN, no issues, good patrol
  20. Under the Boardwalk (2023 film)Pichpich – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  21. Maxillaria sanantonioensisPichpich – meets NSPECIES, no issues, good patrol
  22. Hugáceo CrujienteRatnahastin – meets GNG, no issues, good patrol
  23. La Barca de la FeRatnahastin – no issues, good patrol
  24. 2023 Brussels shootingTroutfarm27 – no issues, good patrol
  25. Marriage in SudanTroutfarm27 – no issues, good patrol
  26. Make You Smile (D-Block Europe song)Troutfarm27 – no issues, good patrol
  27. Barrow Raiders Ladies - Umakant Bhalerao - no issues, good patrol

Coordinator’s comments edit

Alpha3031 edit

  1. Duane OwenTaking Out The Trash – Question re. WP:PERP raised on drive talk page

DoubleGrazing edit

  1. Yrjö HakanenPichpichDoes not qualify under WP:NPOL so relies on WP:GNG, but the two sources cited are the person's own website and a book they've written. Also, citations are insufficient for a BLP.  Y Pichpich makes the valid point that the corresponding fi.wiki article has plenty of sources, so clearly they were right and I was wrong and stand duly corrected. :)
  2. Jordan SchnitzerJTtheOG Y AfD'd as non-notable, which is the correct call as the sources don't come even close to meeting notability, and a quick search finds nothing better. Draftifying (which is what the nom also hints at, and which may yet be the outcome) would have been an option, if there is some expectation of notability coming up, but that would be speculative.
  3. Muhammad Ismi Mat TaibSchminnte Y Notable per NPOL, so fundamentally good patrol. Could/should've cn-tagged the unref'd DOB, but that's about it.
  4. Samuel C. ShimerULPS Y Notable per NPOL, no issues.
  5. NetLingo – Sohom Datta –  Y AfD'd as non-notable, which probably was the right decision as a quick BEFORE doesn't produce anything of value, and with such an outdated topic it's unlikely new sources will be appearing either.

Significa liberdade edit

  1. Memorial of Sir Alfred Lewis Jones, LiverpoolNetherzone – Subject meets GNG, no issues
  2. Jack Keith BerryHey man im josh – Subject meets NPOL, appropriately placed orphan tag
  3. Robert G. WilhelmSlgrandson – Subject meets WP:NACADEMIC, no copyvio, appropriately placed orphan tag. One source failed verification and most sources are primary, so I added a tag for that.
  4. José Domingo Jaramillo Urzúa MicrobiologyMarcus – meets WP:NPOL, appropriately added orphan tag
  5. Jeannie DevaIpigott – marked as review and tagged as orphan; later that day, it was tagged for G12 and subsequently deleted. I have left them a note.
  6. University of Alberta fraternities and sororitiesDannyS712 bot III – good bot ::head pat::
  7. Ananya RaoPraseodymium-141 – appropriately tagged for notability. However, three days later marking it as reviewed, it was brought to AfD by another editor for notability, and the consensus was to delete.
  8. Marcia Coyle, now Draft:Marcia CoylePraseodymium-141 – appropriately tagged for notability upon review. However, another editor rightfully moved the page to draft space six hours later as it only had one source, and it was primary.
  9. Gangguan PortPraseodymium-141 – overall good review. I removed a couple of unnecessary citations (though some overcite is still there)
  10. Demixing (audio), now Draft:Demixing (audio)TheChunky – looking at the page history, this appears to have been reviewed within one minute of creation. At that time, the page had no references, though it was marked as reviewed without any tags. Maybe they marked the redirect to draft page as reviewed?
  11. Morenoism and MorenoitesTheChunky – Both are redirects to Nahuel Moreno, though neither term nor any similar to it are mentioned on the target page. Based on a Google search, these appear to be pejorative terms for Moreno's followers. I'll send to RfD and see what happens.
  12. Karabo Moroka Greyzxq – speedy deletion tag for an article that had been deleted following discussion
  13. Empty Hearts (novel)Raydann – meets NBOOK, no copyvio or other issues, though I added ratings
  14. Atrusca bellaBoyTheKingCanDance – pre-existing stub tag; I added an orphan tag, but otherwise good review
  15. Katja MiaWikishovel – no copyvio or other major issues; I added an orphan tag and ratings
  16. Kelsey MataSimon Peter Hughes – no copyvio or other major issues; I added an orphan tag and ratings
  17. Katrine SakhnovThilsebatti – I think Sakhnov should meet WP:NGYMNAST, but this page isn't doing it. Most of the sources are meet results (not secondary sources) and only 3/18 mention Sakhnov. Further, some of the sources contradict the information in the article. I've tagged for primary sources and notability, added some invisible comments and failed verification tags, and marked it as unreviewed.
  18. Kendra HartleySlgrandson – no copyvio or other major issues
  19. Khushbu (Sepak takraw)Slgrandson – questionable pass of NSPORT. According to track and gymnastics, finishing in the top three at Asian Games denotes notability. However, none of the sources provide significant coverage of Khushbu.
  20. Laurence SaillietHughesdarren – Meets NPOL, no copyvio; I added a primary sources tag
  21. Lauren KozalUtopes – Meets NSPORT, no copyvio; I added a primary sources tag
  22. Belinda TateSchminnte – Meets NPEOPLE, no copyvio; I added an improve cats tag and rating
  23. Özlem ÜnsalWikishovel – Meets NPOL, no copyvio; I added rating and stub tag
  24. Kathrin MoosdorfTheChunky – Meets NPOL, no copyvio or other major issues, pre-existing stub tag
  25. Katherine McKenzieSimon Peter Hughes – questionable notability from existing sources as only one source is outside her network; no copyvio; someone else added an orphan tag later, I added notability and primary source tags, plus ratings
  26. Janika Oza - ULPS - Meets NAUTHOR, no copyvio or other major issues; another editor later appropriately added an orphan tag and stub tag
  27. Sushma Sharma (kabaddi player) - Ipigott - Meets NSPORT (won gold at Asian Games), no copyvio or other major issues; I added stub and orphan tags

Coordinator’s comments edit