User:Efcordova/Sexual victimization of Native American women

Native American women encounter an alarming and disproportionate level of sexual violence, a reality underscored by concrete statistical evidence. Reports from the U.S. Department of Justice indicate that sexual assaults and rapes perpetrated by Native American men against Native American women occur at a rate 2.5 times higher than those among other ethnic groups, spotlighting the stark disparities in victimization experienced by Native American women relative to other racial cohorts in the United States.

The spectrum of violence endured by these women spans from verbal abuse to physical harm, including but not limited to domestic and sexual assaults. Such violations not only result in lasting detrimental effects on the individuals subjected to them but also reverberate throughout their entire community, exacerbating social challenges.

Addressing this pervasive issue necessitates a multifaceted approach. One proposal emphasizes the reinstatement of tribal authority in the prosecution of crimes committed within Indigenous territories, a strategy intended to foster accountability and justice within the community itself. Simultaneously, advocates are lobbying for legislative amendments designed to ensure that non-Indigenous men who commit these crimes are held responsible under local or national laws. This dual approach offers a path towards combating the enduring issue of sexual violence against Native American women.

History of treatment towards Native American women

Abduction of Pocahontas Engraving by Johann Theodore de Bry

Native American women have grappled with a protracted chronicle of violence and abuse. A notable instance from the early 17th century involves a 15-year-old Indigenous girl from the region now known as Virginia, who was abducted from her domicile. Subjected to sexual violation and compelled into marriage with an Englishman, she was coerced into converting to Christianity and adopting the moniker Rebecca. Her life was tragically curtailed under enigmatic circumstances in England. While some accounts cite illness, her family contended she was maliciously eliminated. This narrative of assault, abduction, and enforced assimilation is the poignant tale of the woman widely referred to as Pocahontas.

In the present day, violence inflicted upon Native American women persists at alarmingly elevated rates, and their narratives remain frequently overlooked. This pattern can be traced back to a deeply ingrained American history of settler colonialism and erasure of Indigenous identities, tales, and cultures. Certain contemporary Native women perceive Pocahontas as among the earliest of numerous "stolen sisters", whose names and stories have been effaced from historical memory. Concurrently, the families and communities of others tenaciously strive for justice.

Women occupy a pivotal role within their communities, particularly in healthcare practices and decision-making, owing to the matrilineal structure of many tribes. The development of practice strategies, educational initiatives, and research approaches should incorporate the identification of beliefs and customs specific to individual clans or tribes. This consideration is crucial due to the extensive variability in values, lifestyles, and taboos across different tribes. Traditional healing methodologies, Indigenous storytelling, and talking circles may be effectively integrated into the healthcare of urban Native American women and their families.

Advocacy from Native women and other women of color led to the implementation of federal regulations providing women with a measure of safeguard against unwarranted sterilization procedures. The revised regulations stipulated an extended waiting period, stretching from the initial 72 hours to a full 30 days, between obtaining consent and proceeding with the operation.

Statistics and data

Amnesty International's "Maze of Injustice" Report

The Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW) crisis is a significant yet inadequately addressed issue in the United States. The Savanna's Act, signed in 2020, aimed to clarify the responsibilities of federal, state, tribal, and local governments and law enforcement agencies regarding MMIW cases. While it has improved data collection and increased coordination between agencies, it has yet to implement actionable solutions.

Colonization's legacy and systemic racism perpetuated by the federal government has resulted in ongoing injustices for Indigenous women. The government's consistent failure to prosecute or adequately punish perpetrators of violent crimes against these women has created a cycle of fear and distrust, discouraging them from reporting crimes.

Amnesty International, in its report "Maze of Injustice: The failure to protect indigenous women from sexual violence in the USA", presented survivors' voices of sexual violence. This research, conducted in 2005 and 2006 across the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation, Oklahoma, and Alaska, involved interviews with victims, tribal, state, and federal law enforcement officials, prosecutors, and tribal judges. The report highlighted the widespread fear among Indigenous women that their assaults would go unaddressed, leading to low reporting rates.

Pursuing justice for these women often means navigating a complex maze of tribal, state, and federal law, where jurisdictional queries delay or even prevent cases from being heard. The report identifies several factors contributing to these injustices, including lack of training and inadequate response by police officers, underfunding of justice systems, federal restrictions on tribal courts' authority, and systemic discrimination. The 1978 Oliphant v. Suquamish case, which prohibits tribal courts from prosecuting non-Native suspects, further complicates the matter.

On the state level, discrimination and the courts' failure to treat Native Americans as equal citizens further perpetuate injustice. These complex challenges call for comprehensive, systemic reform to protect Indigenous women's rights and ensure justice is served.

National Institute of Justice Research Report

The 2016 report "Violence Against American Indian and Alaska Native Women and Men: 2010 Findings from the National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey," released by the National Institute of Justice, reveals disturbing levels of sexual and intimate partner violence experienced by American Indian and Alaska Native women.

The study, which collected data from 3,978 American Indian and Alaska Natives (2,473 women and 1,505 men), found that more than half of the women surveyed had experienced sexual violence at some point in their lives. Specifically, 56.1% reported experiencing sexual violence during their lifetime, and 14.4% had experienced such violence in the year preceding the survey.

The report also indicated high rates of physical violence perpetrated by intimate partners, with 55.5% of female respondents reporting having experienced this form of violence in their lifetime. In the year before the survey, 8.6% of women reported having been victims of intimate partner violence.

These statistics underscore the urgency and importance of addressing violence against American Indian and Alaska Native women, who face significantly higher rates of sexual and intimate partner violence than women in many other demographic groups. They also point to the need for improved protective measures, law enforcement practices, and legal and judicial responses to help prevent such violence and ensure justice for survivors.

National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey (NISVS)

These findings from the National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey (NISVS) highlight the severe and pervasive violence experienced by American Indian and Alaska Native adults. The reported figures reveal that 83 percent of these individuals, or almost 3 million people, have experienced some form of violence in their lifetime. This violence ranges from psychological aggression to physical violence by intimate partners, stalking, or sexual violence.

Both women and men in these communities are victimized at similar rates, with rates of 84.3 percent for women and 81.6 percent for men. However, women experience significantly higher rates of sexual violence and stalking compared to men.

In terms of lifetime victimization, American Indian and Alaska Native women experience 1.2 times as much victimization as white women, while men from these communities experience victimization at a rate 1.3 times higher than white men.

Over two in five American Indian and Alaska Native female victims reported physical injuries as a result of this violence, and almost half needed services, most commonly medical care and legal services. Tragically, more than a third were unable to receive these necessary services.

One crucial finding is that most victims of violence in these communities experienced at least one act of violence committed by someone of a different race. This rate is 97 percent for women and 90 percent for men, while fewer victims experienced violence by an American Indian or Alaska Native individual.

This data strongly supports the call for the sovereign right of federally recognized tribes to prosecute non-Indian individuals for crimes committed on tribal lands, a right that had been denied until recently.

Federal government efforts

The Tribal Sexual Assault Services Program (TSASP)

The Tribal Sexual Assault Services Program (TSASP), managed by the U.S. Department of Justice, is a critical initiative that aims to improve and expand services for victims of sexual assault within tribal communities. The scope of the program is quite broad, covering both Indian country and Alaska Native villages.

TSASP projects are designed to provide direct services to victims of sexual assault, such as crisis intervention, accompaniment through medical and legal proceedings, counseling, and other supportive services. The program also aims to enhance the ability of tribes, tribal organizations, and nonprofit tribal organizations to respond to the needs of sexual assault victims effectively and sensitively.

Funding from the program can also be used for developing and enhancing culturally appropriate and trauma-informed strategies and services. The aim is not only to provide immediate assistance to victims but also to create a systemic change within the tribal communities to better address sexual assault and its aftermath.

In addition to direct services, TSASP promotes collaboration and coordination among tribal, federal, and state law enforcement agencies and prosecutors to ensure an effective response to sexual assault incidents within tribal jurisdiction. The ultimate goal of the program is to reduce the prevalence of sexual violence within tribal communities and to improve access to justice and healing services for victims.

The United States Department of Justice Archives Report

In response to the crisis levels of domestic violence, sexual assault, and stalking experienced by Native American women, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has initiated a number of measures to enhance the federal response to these crimes and support tribal efforts to ensure the safety of Native women.

Nearly 46 percent of all Native American women have experienced rape, physical violence, or stalking by an intimate partner, and one in three Indian women will experience the trauma of rape at some point in her life. Additionally, the murder rate of Native American women on some reservations exceeds the national average by over ten times.

To combat these alarming statistics, the DOJ has launched a department-wide initiative on public safety in tribal communities, directed U.S. Attorneys to prioritize violence against women in Indian Country, and added 28 new Indian Country Assistant U.S. Attorneys in 2010 to increase the prosecution of serious crimes.

A Violence Against Women Federal/Tribal Prosecution Task Force was established to assist in the development of best practice recommendations and resource materials concerning the prosecution of violence against women crimes in Indian country. The Office on Violence Against Women (OVW) created a national clearinghouse on the sexual assault of Native women and implemented the SAFESTAR Project to address the collection and preservation of sexual assault evidence in rural and geographically isolated tribal communities.

The Office for Victims of Crime (OVC) supports efforts to enhance American Indian and Alaska Native communities’ capacity to provide services for victims of sexual assault through the Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner–Sexual Assault Response Team (SANE-SART) Initiative.

To assist in providing accurate data for Indian tribal governments, OVW released a solicitation for the National Tribal Protection Order Registry Initiative. The OVW also announced the selection of four tribes for a Violence Against Women Tribal Special U.S. Attorney (SAUSA) Initiative, which aims to increase the likelihood that every viable violence against women criminal offense is prosecuted.

Recognizing the complexities of the legal framework for criminal jurisdiction in Indian country, the DOJ has formally recommended new Federal legislation to better protect women in tribal communities from violent crime. Proposed amendments to the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) include reaffirming tribal criminal jurisdiction over certain non-Indian offenders and clarifying tribal civil authority to issue and enforce protection orders.

In partnership with tribal governments, the OVW continues to work towards decreasing violence against Native American women, strengthening the capacity of tribal governments to respond to these crimes, and ensuring the accountability of perpetrators.

Article Draft