- Although we've covered them indirectly, it's still a good idea to know the CSD criteria for files. So just like before, define the following criteria in your own words and be sure to note any exceptions/unusual conditions/ect.
- Y F1: - Redundant files,if these images are lower resolution, unused images. Does not apply to images on commons
- N F2: - If the file does not work, meaning Wiki can't resize it or such.
- For a file to satisfy WP:CSD#F2, it must be corrupt, empty (e.g. no pixels or very few OR there is an image description page in existence, but no file associated with it), or an image description page for Commons (not including files tagged as picture of the day or valued pictures - these are of course, exceptions to the "empty" rule).
- N F3: - This seems to be one of the most common CSD that is seen, It's for improper licenses they will be deleted unless they comply to the NFC guidelines.
- This is reserved for files that limit usage, that is to say, they are licensed under free licenses, but these licenses are not free enough for Wikipedia. Essentially, any free license that limits derivatives, commercial use, or restricts usage to educational use only is not considered free enough for Wikipedia. See WP:IUP#Adding images, bold text under point 4.
- Y F4: - The file does not have licensing information, and will be deleted a week from when it was marked.
- Remember: Files subject to deletion under WP:CSD#F4 have been tagged with {{subst:nld}} for 7 days.
- Y F5: - An unfree image that is not used. Deleted a week after it was tag, exceptions can be made for upcoming articles.
- Remember: Files subject to deletion under WP:CSD#F5 have been tagged with {{subst:orfud}} for 7 days.
- N F6: - If they do not have a fair-use rationale the exception is if it has it but it is disputed.
- Remember: Files subject to deletion under WP:CSD#F6 have been tagged with {{subst:nrd}} for 7 days. If fair use rationale is disputed (aka it fails WP:NFCC), then it should be deleted under WP:CSD#F7.
- N F7: - These are for the invalid fair use claims, where images could have free equivalents. These can be deleted after two days. Or if it's clearly invalid such as a videogame cover tagged as a logo these can be deleted immediatley.
- This is the complicated one. It's rules/exceptions are essentially a parallel of the difficulty editors have with WP:CSD#A7, only for files. Basically F7 means "invalid fair-use claim"; this could mean several different things. One way F7 can be applied is with respect to WP:NFCC. As you might already know, this is why we have the {{subst:dnfcc}}, {{subst:rfu}}, and {{subst:dfu}} tags. Essentially, files that have been tagged for longer than the specified amount on the tag (lengths can vary from 2-7 days, depending on the which NFCC criteria is a file is being tagged for) should be deleted under WP:CSD#F7. The instance during which files should be deleted per F7 is when an uploader claims a non-free image as something that it is not. For instance, claiming a costume photograph of a school mascot as a logo (either through the license tag or the fair-use rationale) would make the file eligible for immediate deletion under F7.
- Y F8: - The same image is available on Commons and meets a certain set of requirements: It is the same file format and type, the license and source are absolutely correct, all of the information in the description of the commons image meets the same, and they are not protected.
- Y F9: - Copyvios, pretty self-explanatory. Just be sure to have the URL. They can be deleted immediately
- Remember: Copyvios only occur when an uploader claims work that is not theirs as their own and licenses it differently.
- Y F10: - If they are useless files that are not images, videos, or sounds.
- Y F11: - If there is no evidence of permission for the file to be used.
- We haven't discussed this in great detail yet, but this is generally an acceptable answer.
- Not bad. Many people have a lot of trouble with the above CSD criteria (especially F3 and F7, but this is something that takes some time and experience out in the field to understand so no worries.) but you are doing fairly well! Nice job!
- Now let's transition from non-free to free files again where we'll go over permission. This is going to be the last "textbook", if you will, lesson before I send you out to do some upload log patrolling.
- Let's dive headfirst into file permission. Read WP:PERMISSION and indicate below once you have finished.
- A: Read.--SKATER Speak. 04:02, 25 April 2010 (UTC)
- Hi Skater, finished up with my RL businiess earlier than I thought. Just wanted to let you know that I'm ready to resume coaching anytime you are. When you've got the time, it would be helpful if you could review everything we've gone over thus far. I look forward to hearing back from you soon! -FASTILY (TALK) 23:40, 13 May 2010 (UTC)
- A: Welcome back Fastily, hope everything went well. Of course I'd like to resume my Admin Coaching :), I'll look over everything again.--SKATER Speak. 23:44, 13 May 2010 (UTC)
- So now that we know a little more about Permission, I'll give you a quick and dirty overview of what you'll need to know about permission as applied to Files:
- So, hypothetical situation: An editor takes a picture of a tree in their backyard and uploads it to Wikipedia under a free license, say, the Creative Commons Attribution Share-alike 3.0 license for instance. Essentially, what the uploader is doing by publishing the image under a cc-by-sa-3.0 license is giving permission to others (others being anyone with an intent to use/modify and republish the file) to use the file under the terms noted here. As a result, the uploader in this case, is relinquishing some of their copyright rights over the file they took (Remember that a copyright is created the moment the photographer presses the button on the camera, i.e. the moment an artist creates their work).
- Another hypothetical situation. So now let's say that an editor (John) has a friend who is a novice photographer (Bill). John asks Bill if it's alright to upload some of his photographs to Wikipedia. Bill agrees, but does not specify a license. John posts the pictures with a {{pd-self}} license and sources the images to Bill. Although John has good intentions here, he is actually infringing on Bill's copyright rights. Firstly, John is not the creator of the photographs. Secondly, John has no right to choose what license Bill's photographs should be licensed under. Bill never gave permission of any sort to anyone to freely use/distribute/modify/republish his work.
- While the Wikimedia Foundation is largely immune to being sued over copyright (yes, the above case actually can result in a court case against the Wikimedia Foundation, because Bill's work, now "released" under a pd-license, is causing him considerable distress and/or financial loss - assuming Bill's occupation is photography), the goal of strict permission/copyright enforcement is to protect users downstream. Businesses/individuals who use improperly licensed work are also immune to the aforementioned legal allegations because they would not have known the proper copyright status of such a file because it had not been properly documented. As can clearly be seen from the above, it is the author of a work who has the most to lose when files are not properly documented and permission is not properly established. The Wikimedia Foundation has no interest in ruining or creating trouble for authors of creative works.
- Basically, when a source of a file is provided (so that would mean that a given file is sourced to someone other than the uploader), but it cannot be established whether the original author agreed to release the file under a given license, we tag the file with {{subst:npd}}, as lacking evidence of permission.
- If an uploader claims to have permission (usually in e-mail format) from the original author for a given file (meaning, that the original author has specified a license the file is to be released under), that email should be forward to the Wikimedia Foundation's OTRS at permissions-en@wikimedia.org.
- Further Reading: WP:DCP and WP:ERP (Please do it - these are solid explanations)
- I'll go through them right now, but on a side note I think I got it :)
- Read both.--SKATER Speak. 01:58, 18 May 2010 (UTC)
- With regard to the tag, excellent work. That was picture perfect. -FASTILY (TALK) 02:17, 18 May 2010 (UTC)
- Now, once you've read the above, please answer the following questions:
- Y 1. An editor uploads a photograph of a ladybug under a {{pd-self}} license, claiming their friend told them it was alright to post the photo on Wikipedia. Detail your course of action.
- A: Well, given the example you have above this is a violation of his friends copyright rights because not only is he plagiarizing (In a sense, by the definition of taking someone elses work and claiming it as your own), but it's also possible that he might not have told him to release it under the license it was given on. Seems like a simple tag of {{subst:npd}},
- Y 2. An editor uploads a photograph of the USS Midway from a website, claiming that the photograph is in the public domain, and tagging the file with {{PD-release}}. You go to the website and see nothing to back up that now dubious claim. How do you react?
- A: Another simple tag of {{subst:npd}} and move on.
- Y 3. Let's say that the editor in question 2 tagged the file with {{Cc-by-sa-2.0}}. Again, there is nothing on the source website to back up that claim. Do you do anything different?
- A:I know It's seeming repetitive, but see my answers for the first two, tag the first two and get the verification.
- N4. An editor uses Google Earth and takes several screencaps while viewing the satellite map of the natural formation, Colletto Fava. The editor uploads these screenshots under a {{pd-self}} license, noting that since they "created the images themself", they are the copyright holder of the images and can do whatever they wish. How do you react?
- A: He may have created those Screenshots themselves but not the images that he screenshotted, therefore he did not make the image themself and a {{pd-self}} tag would be innapropriate for such images, {{subst:npd}} again.
- Not quite - This was the only situation question where the answer wasn't {{subst:npd}}. Google Earth images are fully copyrighted by Google, and the editor in this case has no rights whatsoever to release the images they took under a pd-self license, despite being the one who created the screenshot. Essentially, what's happened here is that the editor has created a derivative work (we'll go into more detail on this shortly) of a non-free set of files which is in essence, a blunt copyright violation. The proper response would be to tag with {{db-f9}} (for normal users) or delete on sight (for admins). -FASTILY (TALK) 22:05, 18 May 2010 (UTC)
- Y 5. An editor uploads an image of Taylor Swift's latest album and claims it under a {{PD-release}} license. How do you react?
- A:I doubt that's in the public domain very seriously, in this case I probably wouldn't tag and would create a fair use rationale for it.
- Y 6. An editor uploads a black and white photo of a piano, sources it to a website, and tags it with {{pd-old}}. Other than the copyright tag and the external link, there is nothing else on the image description page. You head to the website provided, but are neither able to locate the image nor find information on its copyright status there. How to do you react?
- A:Just because somethings black and white does not make it old, I could go into photoshop right now and make something black and white, tag it with {{subst:npd}} and perhaps add on explaining the links wrong too.
- Y 7. Same as above, except the uploader tags the file with {{PD-release}} and through the website link provided, you find that the image was taken in 1950. There is no information on the copyright status of the file. What do you do?
- A:Looking through the public domain page, the author hasn't/couldn't have been dead long enough for it to be placed in the public domain. Seems like another {{subst:npd}} tag ((I must be a broken record...))
- Y 8. Explain the difference between copyright and permission, in your own words.
- A: A copyright, is the right to copy something and control who uses it. It is given to the creator of the work. Permission is given by the copyright holder to reproduce the image and how it should be done.--SKATER Speak. 03:38, 18 May 2010 (UTC)
- While it's clear you understand the definition of Copyright, just remember that "copyright is the set of exclusive rights granted to the author or creator of an original work, including the right to copy, distribute and adapt the work". Think of permission as sharing. When you tag a file with {{subst:npd}}, you are essentially tagging the file as "no evidence of sharing of copyright". -FASTILY (TALK) 05:59, 18 May 2010 (UTC)
- Sorry about question 4; it wasn't at all clear what I was trying to ask. Would you like to give it another shot? Or shall I just give you the answer? -FASTILY (TALK) 06:06, 18 May 2010 (UTC)
- Actually, I think I understood what to do but just didn't notice i didn't answer the question, my bad. Answered now.--SKATER Speak. 11:41, 18 May 2010 (UTC)
- It's all good. Thanks for doing it. -FASTILY (TALK) 22:07, 18 May 2010 (UTC)
And there you have it. Media files and copyright, the quick and dirty version. There's a few more important aspects we have yet to cover, but I think you know enough to give patrolling the upload log a shot. Let's get started.
- The upload log may be found at Special:Log/upload. The same rules apply to the upload log as they do with the NPP log - don't tag a file until a file has been live for more than 10 minutes or so. This is really common courtesy, that's all.
- There is, unfortunately, no "mark this file patrolled". We desparetly need one of these.
- You can tag files with twinkle or manually. If you're using twinkle, the deletion/maintenance tags you will need to use can be found under either the "csd" or "di" tabs. Be sure to notify the uploader of the file's deletion. If you use twinkle, it will be done automatically. If you tag manually, you will need to manually notify the uploader with the provided messaging template.
- If you're tagging manually, the following may be helpful:
- In short, expect the unexpected. You'll surely encounter the oddest of situations on the upload log.
- I'd like to see you you go through at least ~40-50 files from the top of the log (which shouldn't take you more than 20 min max), although, more would be nice. Please list the images you've tagged (copy & paste from your contribs works just fine) below and any files you weren't sure how to deal with (so we'll be able to go over those). Good Luck. -FASTILY (TALK) 22:32, 18 May 2010 (UTC)
- Here's some, I'm going to do more but I wasn't sure about the ones I tagged with no licence. I think they're tagged correctly though.
- Well while I'm waiting for more on the log, here's some more.--SKATER Speak. 23:45, 18 May 2010 (UTC)
18:51, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:GORIZARD (Notification: Speedy deletion nomination of File:Rambo3poster.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:51, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Rambo3poster.jpg (Requesting speedy deletion (CSD F6). (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:49, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:MoJoMayJuneCover.JPG (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 18:49, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Jnp2109 (Notification: Deletion of File:MoJoMayJuneCover.JPG. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:48, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Ischa3 (Notification: Speedy deletion nomination of File:Nederland3childident1989.png. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:48, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Nederland3childident1989.png (Requesting speedy deletion (CSD F6). (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:47, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:DD Dub (Notification: Deletion of File:Drake.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:47, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Drake.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:46, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) N User talk:Aurorapio (Notification: Deletion of File:Aurora_Reservoir_Colorado.jpg. (TW)) (top)
18:46, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Aurora Reservoir Colorado.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:45, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Galaconcierge (Notification: Deletion of File:Kandeyce-Jorden.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:45, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Kandeyce-Jorden.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW))
20:29, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar ({{subst:di-no permission-notice|1=Cristiano Ronaldo 2009-10.JPG}} ~~~~) (top) [rollback]
20:27, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Cristiano Ronaldo 2009-10.JPG ({{subst:npd}}) (top) [rollback]
20:25, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar ({{subst:di-no permission-notice|1=Zinedine Zidane Finale World Cup 2006 Penalty.jpg}} ~~~~)
20:25, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Zinedine Zidane Finale World Cup 2006 Penalty.jpg ({{subst:npd}}) (top) [rollback]
20:23, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar (→May 2010: Ooops)
20:21, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar ({{subst:di-no permission-notice|1=Sneijder 2009-10.JPG}} ~~~~)
20:19, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Sneijder 2009-10.JPG ({{subst:npd}}) (top) [rollback]
20:17, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar ({{subst:di-no permission-notice|1=Gonzalo Higuain 2009-10.jpg}} ~~~~)
20:17, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Gonzalo Higuain 2009-10.jpg ({{subst:npd}}) (top) [rollback]
19:53, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar ({{subst:npd}})
19:53, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Pepe Real Madrid.jpg ({{subst:npd}}) (top) [rollback]
19:42, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Mmschettler ({{subst:di-no license-notice|1=Irene Headshot.jpg}} ~~~~) (top) [rollback]
19:41, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Mmschettler (Undid revision 362909253 by Skater (talk)oops)
19:40, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Mmschettler ({{subst:di-no license-notice|1=Irene Headshot.jpg}} ~~~~)
19:40, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Irene Headshot.jpg ({{subst:nld}}) (top) [rollback]
19:37, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Mmschettler ({{subst:nld}})
19:37, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Irene Cover1.jpg ({{subst:nld}}) (top) [rollback]
19:36, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Mmschettler
19:36, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Irene ColorBalance.jpg ({{subst:nld}}) (top) [rollback]
19:34, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Surrey Le Roux ({{subst:di-no license-notice|1=Breaking.jpg}} ~~~~) (top) [rollback]
19:33, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Breaking.jpg ({{subst:nld}}) (top) [rollback]
19:31, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) N User talk:Lockevincent ({{subst:di-no license-notice|1=Pinnaeffect.jpg}} ~~~~) (top)
19:30, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Pinnaeffect.jpg ({{subst:nld}}) (top) [rollback]
19:28, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) N User talk:Rymac140 ({{subst:di-no source-notice|1=Arialphoto2009.jpg}} ~~~~) (top)
19:28, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Arialphoto2009.jpg ({{subst:nsd}}) (top
19:23, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Natalino7 (Another) (top) [rollback]
19:23, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Mladen Stojanovic.JPG (+more) (top) [rollback]
19:22, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Surrey Le Roux ({{subst:di-no fair use rationale-notice|1=RamRam.jpg}} ~~~~) (top) [rollback]
19:21, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:RamRam.jpg ({{subst:nrd}}) (top) [rollback]
19:20, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Natalino7 ({{subst:di-no license-notice|1=Stara kula.JPG}} ~~~~)
19:19, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Stara kula.JPG ({{subst:nld}}) (top) [rollback]
19:18, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) N User talk:Surrey Le Roux ({{subst:di-no license-notice|1=AFBTN.jpg}} ~~~~)
19:17, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:AFBTN.jpg ({{db-f4}},) (top) [rollback]
19:15, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) N User talk:Megapop ({{subst:di-no permission-notice|1=Danielle Hope, OTR.jpg}} ~~~~) (top)
19:15, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Danielle Hope, OTR.jpg ({{subst:npd}}) (top) [rollback]
19:07, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) N User talk:Canboy4u (+) (top)
19:06, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:RichardNewmanZurich.jpg ({{di-no license|month=May|day=18|year=2010}}) (top) [rollback]
19:04, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Vuk1992 (Notifying) (top) [rollback]
19:03, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Warwick sc thumb 2010 6.jpg ({{di-no permission|date=18 May 2010}}) (top) [rollback]
19:01, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Dalbster (Notifying) (top) [rollback]
19:00, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Nagano hockey profilelarge.jpg (No FU) (top) [rollback]
18:57, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Bennetea (top) [rollback]
18:55, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Graduationcu.jpg (tagging) (top) [rollback]
18:52, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Natalino7 (top) [rollback]
18:51, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Fountain in centre prijedor.jpg (Right tag) (top) [rollback]
18:51, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Fountain in centre prijedor.jpg (Undid revision 362901931 by Skater (talk)Oops)
18:50, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Fountain in centre prijedor.jpg (tag)
18:48, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) N User talk:Natalino7 (notifying)
18:48, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Glavna ulica Main street.jpg (tagging) (top) [rollback]
18:40, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Glavna ulica Main street.jpg (Undid revision 362900262 by Skater (talk)Actually not enough time has elapsed, will keep an eye)
18:40, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Glavna ulica Main street.jpg (No License)
- Just realized I messed up most, if not all of my {{subst:nld}} tags, I was talking own works with it because they did not have a permission specified..ooops.--SKATER Speak. 00:41, 19 May 2010 (UTC)
- Not bad for a first try. The majority of your tags are correctly placed. You did make a few mistakes, but this being your first time, you have already exceeded my expectations! -FASTILY (TALK) 05:28, 19 May 2010 (UTC)
- File:RamRam.jpg - You realized this was a non-free file of some sort, so you tagged it with {{subst:nrd}}. If a file has no license tag, tag it with {{subst:nld}}, regardless of whether there is fur, the file is non-free, there is a source, ect. There is an order in which problems with files should be identified. They are as follows: CSD -> nld -> nsd/nrd/dnfcc/rfu/npd -> orfud
- File:Danielle Hope, OTR.jpg - see above. While npd will work, the problem of "no license tag" supersedes npd.
- File:Warwick sc thumb 2010 6.jpg - see above.
- File:Gonzalo Higuain 2009-10.jpg - same as above.
- File:Zinedine Zidane Finale World Cup 2006 Penalty.jpg - same as above.
- File:ArcSoft Logo CMYK.jpg - same as above.
- File:Nagano hockey profilelarge.jpg - This file, despite having a pathetically short fair-use rationale, does in fact have an acceptable fair-use rationale. A table template is not required for a file to have good fair use rationale. When determining whether a file has valid fair-use rationale, look for information on portion used (is the file cropped, whole, screenshot, ect.), resolution (is the file of low resolution? If not, tag with {{non-free reduce}}), purpose of use (is the file being used to illustrate the entity in question?), and replaceability (can this file be replaced by a free version that would convey equivalent meaning?).
- Please make the appropriate corrections to the files listed above. Apart from everything just mentioned, I saw no other issues with your tagging. Great work!!
- Btw - You don't have to wait for new entries in the log - simply clicking "Older 50" will give you more entries to work with.
Done, will tag more in a bit--SKATER Speak. 14:51, 19 May 2010 (UTC)
- Please feel free to tag as many as you like! Although, I'd appreciate it if you could copy+paste from your contribs, the images you tag. Just makes it easier for me to check your, thus far, outstanding work. Cheers, FASTILY (TALK) 23:26, 19 May 2010 (UTC)
- I've been updating the list every few seconds, should I make a new list per each update?--SKATER Speak. 23:27, 19 May 2010 (UTC)
- Yeah, a new, separate list below would be nice. It would make it much easier for me to "grade", if you will. -FASTILY (TALK) 23:32, 19 May 2010 (UTC)
# 19:34, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Syedalinaqinaqvi (Notification: Deletion of File:S_ali_naqi.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:34, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:S ali naqi.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:27, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User:Skater/Admin coaching/Lesson 3 (Question)
# 19:02, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) Pioneers, Rebels, and Wolves (Wikify)
# 19:01, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) m Pioneers, Rebels, and Wolves (Adding category Category:2010 books (using HotCat))
# 19:00, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) m Anton Chekhov's The Duel (Adding category Category:2010 films (using HotCat))
# 18:59, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Kingcartwright (Notification: Speedy deletion nomination of File:ThedanceFaithless.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 18:59, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:ThedanceFaithless.jpg (Requesting speedy deletion (CSD F6). (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:51, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:GORIZARD (Notification: Speedy deletion nomination of File:Rambo3poster.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:51, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Rambo3poster.jpg (Requesting speedy deletion (CSD F6). (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:49, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:MoJoMayJuneCover.JPG (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 18:49, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Jnp2109 (Notification: Deletion of File:MoJoMayJuneCover.JPG. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:48, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Ischa3 (Notification: Speedy deletion nomination of File:Nederland3childident1989.png. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:48, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Nederland3childident1989.png (Requesting speedy deletion (CSD F6). (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:47, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:DD Dub (Notification: Deletion of File:Drake.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:47, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Drake.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:46, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) N User talk:Aurorapio (Notification: Deletion of File:Aurora_Reservoir_Colorado.jpg. (TW)) (top)
18:46, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Aurora Reservoir Colorado.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:45, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Galaconcierge (Notification: Deletion of File:Kandeyce-Jorden.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
18:45, May 19, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Kandeyce-Jorden.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW))
20:29, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar ({{subst:di-no permission-notice|1=Cristiano Ronaldo 2009-10.JPG}} ~~~~) (top) [rollback]
20:27, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Cristiano Ronaldo 2009-10.JPG ({{subst:npd}}) (top) [rollback]
20:25, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar ({{subst:di-no permission-notice|1=Zinedine Zidane Finale World Cup 2006 Penalty.jpg}} ~~~~)
20:25, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Zinedine Zidane Finale World Cup 2006 Penalty.jpg ({{subst:npd}}) (top) [rollback]
20:23, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar (→May 2010: Ooops)
20:21, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar ({{subst:di-no permission-notice|1=Sneijder 2009-10.JPG}} ~~~~)
20:19, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Sneijder 2009-10.JPG ({{subst:npd}}) (top) [rollback]
20:17, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar ({{subst:di-no permission-notice|1=Gonzalo Higuain 2009-10.jpg}} ~~~~)
20:17, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Gonzalo Higuain 2009-10.jpg ({{subst:npd}}) (top) [rollback]
19:53, May 18, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Daniaguilar ({{subst:npd}})
- Everything looks great so far. After looking through your recent tags, I recommend you look over the following three images:
- Just a quick reminder: tagging images is no different from tagging articles at WP:NPP; much care should be exercised in placing proper tags!
- Other than that, keep up the great work!! I like very much what I'm seeing.
- I'm trying to become more accurate with my taggings, but as I do that. I got my first responce from one of my taggings, would you mind seeing how I handled it?--SKATER Hmm? 14:11, 20 May 2010 (UTC)
- Everything looks good to me. Cheers, FASTILY (TALK) 23:10, 20 May 2010 (UTC)
# 16:27, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Adamlancegarcia (Notification: Speedy deletion nomination of File:GLBookMarkTitles.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:27, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:GLBookMarkTitles.jpg (Requesting speedy deletion (CSD F6). (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:27, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Arizaalberto (Notification: Deletion of File:Penguins.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:27, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Penguins.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:27, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Hoya gomez photo.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:27, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Arizaalberto (Notification: Deletion of File:Hoya_gomez_photo.jpg. (TW))
# 16:26, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Mudan.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:26, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Yangkangee (Notification: Deletion of File:Mudan.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:25, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Yejy.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:25, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Yangkangee (Notification: Deletion of File:Yejy.jpg. (TW))
# 16:24, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Kaskew (Notification: Deletion of File:Sandiego_fidm_campus.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:24, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Sandiego fidm campus.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:24, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Kaskew (Notification: Deletion of File:Camp_la_annex_2B-4.jpg. (TW))
# 16:24, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Camp la annex 2B-4.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:23, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Kaskew (Notification: Deletion of File:Fidm_oc1.jpg. (TW))
# 16:23, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Fidm oc1.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:23, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Kaskew (Notification: Deletion of File:Camp_la_front_view.jpg. (TW))
# 16:23, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Camp la front view.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:21, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Mgabrys (Notification: Deletion of File:Hackers.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:21, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Hackers.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 16:06, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) N User talk:74.128.161.39 (General note: Vandalism on Jason Spitz. (TW)) (top)
# 16:00, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) m Jason Spitz (Reverted 1 edit by 74.128.161.39 identified as vandalism to last revision by Skater. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 13:24, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) N User talk:31stbath (Notifying of Speedy Deletion)
# 13:24, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) The Simpsons (season 23) ({{db-a1}},)
# 13:21, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) m Dean Aspen(actor) (Wikifiy)
# 11:27, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Skater (→Re-your message- Radio23 image use: fix)
# 11:26, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Skater (→Re-your message- Radio23 image use: re)
# 10:15, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Fiedorczuk (→Talkback: new section)
# 10:11, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User:Skater/Admin coaching/Lesson 3 (sign) (top) [rollback]
# 10:10, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User:Skater/Admin coaching/Lesson 3 (re with question)
# 10:08, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Skater (→Re-your message- Radio23 image use: re)
# 09:43, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Charron69 (Notification: Deletion of File:Charron.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 09:43, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Charron.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 09:43, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Fiedorczuk (Notification: Deletion of File:Radio_23.jpg. (TW))
# 09:43, May 20, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Radio 23.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
- Looking much better!! There was one issue however. File:Hackers.jpg is a dead copyvio. I saw the discussion on your talk page, and I know the user claims that it's a Public Domain file, but you should really be skeptical of such claims. Just because a user claims a free license and permission doesn't necessarily mean they have it. In the case with File:Hackers.jpg, the file should have been tagged with {{subst:npd}}, the uploader should have been directed to WP:DCP, and then asked to forward the letter containing permission to OTRS. Alternatively, you could have listed the file at WP:PUF, but more on that later. I would not have expected you to have been well acquainted with any of the processes I just detailed, but alas, practice and experience makes perfect. Keep up the good work!! -FASTILY (TALK) 23:21, 20 May 2010 (UTC)
- Yeah, something didn't seem quite right to me on that one. He had me somewhat believing he had made enough changes to it to make it a seperate piece. Bad judgement on my part when I hadn't seen the original, ah well, no use crying over spilt milk.--SKATER Hmm? 23:26, 20 May 2010 (UTC)
# 19:20, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Vitam et Mortem.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:20, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Goroth (Notification: Deletion of File:Vitam_et_Mortem.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:20, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Life in Death cover.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:20, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Goroth (Notification: Deletion of File:Life_in_Death_cover.jpg. (TW))
# 19:19, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Commanding the Obscure Imperius.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:19, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Goroth (Notification: Deletion of File:Commanding_the_Obscure_Imperius.jpg. (TW))
# 19:18, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Death Metal 666.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:18, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Goroth (Notification: Deletion of File:Death_Metal_666.jpg. (TW))
# 19:17, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:RohanMalik1999 (Notification: Deletion of File:Speednewmovie.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:17, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Speednewmovie.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:16, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Cyrus40 (Notification: Deletion of File:Montanatale.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:16, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Montanatale.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:15, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Nerd 101 (Notification: Speedy deletion nomination of File:Merrie melodies blueribbon.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 19:15, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Merrie melodies blueribbon.jpg (Requesting speedy deletion (CSD F6). (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:10, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Juniormembershipform.pdf (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:10, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) N User talk:Mattashdene (Notification: Deletion of File:Juniormembershipform.pdf. (TW)) (top)
# 17:08, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:ShippBrick.JPG (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:08, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Lizleung (Notification: Deletion of File:ShippBrick.JPG. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:07, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Lizleung (Notification: Deletion of File:HSskyDiving.JPG. (TW))
# 17:07, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:HSskyDiving.JPG (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:07, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Fergumungus (Notification: Speedy deletion nomination of Visnic Custom Homes. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:07, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) Visnic Custom Homes (Requesting speedy deletion (CSD G11). (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:06, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Archaka (Notification: Deletion of File:Sapatil.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:06, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:Sapatil.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:06, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Rui789 (Notification: Deletion of File:High-society.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:06, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:High-society.jpg (This file is up for deletion per WP:CSD. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:04, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) User talk:Lotus Wolf (Notification: Speedy deletion nomination of File:LawOfIllusion.jpg. (TW)) (top) [rollback]
# 17:04, May 21, 2010 (diff | hist) File:LawOfIllusion.jpg (Requesting speedy deletion (CSD F6). (TW)) (top) [rollback]
- Much better!! I found no glaring issues, although, I think the tag on File:Merrie melodies blueribbon.jpg could have been a bit better placed; the file had short, but sufficient fair-use ratioanle. Frankly, I like what I see - with a ~5% error ratio, I think we're more than ready to move on. I'd like to request that you continue posting your the files you tag from your contribs at User:Skater/Admin coaching/Lesson 3/File Tagging. Practice tagging as often as time allows!! -FASTILY (TALK) 06:33, 22 May 2010 (UTC)
|