- The "Season" column refers to the season during which the competition was held, and links to the article about that season.
- The two-legged series are listed in the order they were played.
| Year | Leg | Country | Winners | Score | Runners-up | Country | Venue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | Leg 1 |  Mexico
|
UNAM | 1–1 | Herediano |  Costa Rica
|
Estadio Olímpico Universitario
|
| Leg 2 | Costa Rica
|
Herediano | 3–2 | UNAM | Mexico
|
Estadio Eladio Rosabal Cordero
| |
| Agg | Costa Rica
|
Herediano | 4–3 | UNAM | Mexico
|
||
| 2016 | Leg 1 | Mexico
|
Toluca | 1–1 | Herediano | Costa Rica
|
Estadio Nemesio Díez
|
| Leg 2 | Costa Rica
|
Herediano | 2–0 | Toluca | Mexico
|
Estadio Eladio Rosabal Cordero
| |
| Agg | Costa Rica
|
Herediano | 3–1 | Toluca | Mexico
|
||
| 2017 | Leg 1 | Mexico
|
Pachuca | 3–0 | Guadalajara | Mexico
|
Estadio Chivas
|
| Leg 2 | Mexico
|
Pachuca | 1–0 | Guadalajara | Mexico
|
Estadio Hidalgo
| |
| Agg | Mexico
|
Pachuca | 4–0 | Guadalajara | Mexico
|
||
| 2018 | Leg 1 | Sporting Kansas City  v. Herediano
|
Children's Mercy Park
| ||||
| Leg 2 | Herediano v. Sporting Kansas City
|
Estadio Eladio Rosabal Cordero
| |||||
| Agg | Herediano v. Sporting Kansas City
|
||||||