Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive index


Report generated based on a request from Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States). It matches the following masks: Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive <#>, Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States).
This page was last edited by Legobot (talk | contribs) 5 months ago. (Update timer)

Discussion Topic Replies (estimated) Archive Link
Latest Changes 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Latest Changes
Wong Kim Ark 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Wong Kim Ark
Unclarity regarding meaning of "natural-born"; need for further research 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Unclarity regarding meaning of "natural-born"; need for further research
Cross-references; Also for further research: 14th Amendment 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Cross-references; Also for further research: 14th Amendment
And what about Outside the USA? 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#And what about Outside the USA?
Weedin v. Chin Bow 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Weedin v. Chin Bow
Supreme Court cases: some not relevant here 8 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Supreme Court cases: some not relevant here
"Naturalization at birth" concept makes no sense and is original research 17 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#"Naturalization at birth" concept makes no sense and is original research
Goldwater 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Goldwater
United States 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#United States
Incorporated US Territory and the Goldwater Case 7 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Incorporated US Territory and the Goldwater Case
"None was" vs. "none were" 12 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#"None was" vs. "none were"
John McCain is Constitutionally ineligible to be President 11 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#John McCain is Constitutionally ineligible to be President
pov tag 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#pov tag
2008 Presidential Election: section needs to be redone for NPOV, or else removed 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#2008 Presidential Election: section needs to be redone for NPOV, or else removed
Why is state department policy being cited? 18 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Why is state department policy being cited?
First 8 or 9 presidents 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#First 8 or 9 presidents
Rewording: Legislation and legal arguments 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Rewording: Legislation and legal arguments
How do things look from the other direction? 8 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#How do things look from the other direction?
Native-born citizen vs Natural-born citizen 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Native-born citizen vs Natural-born citizen
1937 law: "retrospective" vs. "retroactive"? 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#1937 law: "retrospective" vs. "retroactive"?
Collaboration to get this to good-article status 15 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Collaboration to get this to good-article status
Herbert Hoover 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Herbert Hoover
Power of Congress 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Power of Congress
Citizen at adoption of Constitution 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Citizen at adoption of Constitution
Charles Curtis 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Charles Curtis
References 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#References
Natural Born includes any part of the United States 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Natural Born includes any part of the United States
Donofrio v. Wells 10 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Donofrio v. Wells
Constitutional Topic: Citizenship 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Constitutional Topic: Citizenship
Natural born citizens, forgetting about presidential eligiblity 7 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Natural born citizens, forgetting about presidential eligiblity
Obama article probation applies here too? 16 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Obama article probation applies here too?
Proposal to delete section on "Prominent Elected Officials ... ineligible to hold the Presidency" 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Proposal to delete section on "Prominent Elected Officials ... ineligible to hold the Presidency"
Case law 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Case law
Goldwater 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Goldwater
New information about President Chester Arthur 14 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#New information about President Chester Arthur
Obama 22 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Obama
See also section 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#See also section
Barack Obama citizenship conspiracy theories 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Barack Obama citizenship conspiracy theories
Discussion of Barack Obama citizenship conspiracy theories 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Discussion of Barack Obama citizenship conspiracy theories
Was protection appropriate? 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Was protection appropriate?
Vice Presidential candidates whose eligibility was questioned 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Vice Presidential candidates whose eligibility was questioned
Insular Cases should probably be referenced in regard to status of US territories and possession 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 1#Insular Cases should probably be referenced in regard to status of US territories and possession
Suggestion: retitle the article or globalize it 22 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Suggestion: retitle the article or globalize it
Elk v. Wilkins 7 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Elk v. Wilkins
New reference sites 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#New reference sites
Loonymonkey's vandalism 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Loonymonkey's vandalism
Only three reasons . . . 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Only three reasons . . .
Clarification needed under "Legislation and executive branch policy" 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Clarification needed under "Legislation and executive branch policy"
Merger proposal 10 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Merger proposal
"Key distinction" and "to parents who are U.S. citizens" 7 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#"Key distinction" and "to parents who are U.S. citizens"
Constitutional provisions 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Constitutional provisions
"Irrevocability of Natural Citizenship" ?? 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#"Irrevocability of Natural Citizenship" ??
Irrevocability of natural citizenship 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Irrevocability of natural citizenship
Material removed from article 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Material removed from article
"Consular reports of birth abroad ..." 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#"Consular reports of birth abroad ..."
Historical References 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Historical References
Quote from Emmerich de Vattel is misleading. 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Quote from Emmerich de Vattel is misleading.
Verification needed 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Verification needed
The certainty over whether Chester Arthur and Barack Obama were born in Vermont & Hawaii, respectively 9 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#The certainty over whether Chester Arthur and Barack Obama were born in Vermont & Hawaii, respectively
Archiving 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Archiving
US citizenship derived through State citizenship 10 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#US citizenship derived through State citizenship
The Insular Cases 12 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#The Insular Cases
Róger Calero 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Róger Calero
Redirect 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Redirect
June 27, 2004 Associated Press story, via The Standard (Kenya), reported Barack Obama was born in Kenya 9 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#June 27, 2004 Associated Press story, via The Standard (Kenya), reported Barack Obama was born in Kenya
Ankeny versus Governor of the State of Indiana 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Ankeny versus Governor of the State of Indiana
Reword Intro? 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 2#Reword Intro?
Natural-born in U.S. territories? 8 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Natural-born in U.S. territories?
Congressional Research Service Report RL30527 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Congressional Research Service Report RL30527
American Law Review 1884 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#American Law Review 1884
deletion 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#deletion
Presidential candidates whose eligibility was questioned? 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Presidential candidates whose eligibility was questioned?
Edit request from Ktmotox, 11 April 2010 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Edit request from Ktmotox, 11 April 2010
The Insular Cases 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#The Insular Cases 2
Major Revison Needed 20 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Major Revison Needed
What is a natural born citizen? 9 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#What is a natural born citizen?
Discrepancy of McCain’s Place of Birth 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Discrepancy of McCain’s Place of Birth
Definition vs requirements 9 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Definition vs requirements
McCain's fake birth certificate 34 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#McCain's fake birth certificate
Congressional Research Service memo of April 2009 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Congressional Research Service memo of April 2009
David Ramsay 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#David Ramsay
A few observations 16 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#A few observations
unlike Obama.... 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#unlike Obama....
See also section 11 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#See also section
Vattel, Obama and previous presidents 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Vattel, Obama and previous presidents
Article move (renaming) 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Article move (renaming)
Incorrect assertion about natural birth requirement. 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Incorrect assertion about natural birth requirement.
Vattel as 'possible source?' 82 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Vattel as 'possible source?'
Constitution Society 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Constitution Society
Comment/suggestion 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Comment/suggestion
Or a Citizen 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Or a Citizen
Description of Chester Arthur circumstances vs Barack Obama circumstances 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Description of Chester Arthur circumstances vs Barack Obama circumstances
Alexander Hamliton and the Natural Born Citizen Clause 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Alexander Hamliton and the Natural Born Citizen Clause
Rewrite. 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Rewrite.
Bias against a source you don't like 9 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Bias against a source you don't like
OED 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#OED
Vattel 58 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 3#Vattel
RFC/U (Sempi) 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#RFC/U (Sempi)
Natural born citizen, contemporary meaning 14 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Natural born citizen, contemporary meaning
Pushing POV and OR 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Pushing POV and OR
Ankeny 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Ankeny
"Legislation and executive branch policy" section -- delete? 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#"Legislation and executive branch policy" section -- delete?
Minor v. Happersett 14 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Minor v. Happersett
"Case law" section — delete? 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#"Case law" section — delete?
Madison quote. 9 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Madison quote.
Contemporary interpretations 9 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Contemporary interpretations
Is Rubio a "candidate"? 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Is Rubio a "candidate"?
Election season has started. 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Election season has started.
DISPUTED: applicability of U.S. Code, Title 8, Chapter 12, Subchapter III, Part 1, Section 1401 34 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#DISPUTED: applicability of U.S. Code, Title 8, Chapter 12, Subchapter III, Part 1, Section 1401
Citizen at birth 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Citizen at birth
Time is important 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Time is important
Huffpost quote from CRS report 16 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Huffpost quote from CRS report
Minor v. Happersett revisited 28 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Minor v. Happersett revisited
Recommended new source 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 4#Recommended new source
Founders/18th Century views 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Founders/18th Century views
Minor v. Happersett is relevent to the subject matter. 55 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Minor v. Happersett is relevent to the subject matter.
Court decisions sections 8 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Court decisions sections
Citation to Congressional Research Service Report 29 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Citation to Congressional Research Service Report
Obama article probation 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Obama article probation
Totally biased in favor of Obama? 30 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Totally biased in favor of Obama?
"Birther" as a pejorative / derogatory / offensive term? 22 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#"Birther" as a pejorative / derogatory / offensive term?
Hassan Case 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Hassan Case
Dating the translation of Vattel 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Dating the translation of Vattel
Obama Cases 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#Obama Cases
The common use and meaning of the phrase "natural-born subject" in England and in the Colonies in the 1700s, 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 5#The common use and meaning of the phrase "natural-born subject" in England and in the Colonies in the 1700s,
Legal concepts not sufficiently considered 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Legal concepts not sufficiently considered
Diacritical usage against wikilaw and English 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Diacritical usage against wikilaw and English
Mitt Romney, his forebears, and Mexican citizenship 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Mitt Romney, his forebears, and Mexican citizenship
Conspicuous lack of eligibility 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Conspicuous lack of eligibility
Minor v. Happersett 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Minor v. Happersett
Sourcing for Hollander v. McCain 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Sourcing for Hollander v. McCain
The quote in the lead and the quote in its supporting cite 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#The quote in the lead and the quote in its supporting cite
This Article is pretty well Impenetrable 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#This Article is pretty well Impenetrable
Trump comments 7 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Trump comments
Automatic archiving of this Talk page. 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Automatic archiving of this Talk page.
Barack Obama and Hawaiian birth 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Barack Obama and Hawaiian birth
Naturalization Acts of 1790 and 1795 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Naturalization Acts of 1790 and 1795
We need discussion and consensus here 72 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#We need discussion and consensus here
Bobby Jindal 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Bobby Jindal
Cited Reference Doesn't Support Claim that Case Law Allows for "Natural Born" Citizenship to Foreign-born Children of U.S. Citizens 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Cited Reference Doesn't Support Claim that Case Law Allows for "Natural Born" Citizenship to Foreign-born Children of U.S. Citizens
Antecedents in England section. 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Antecedents in England section.
Lead 22 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Lead
Proposed reorganizing 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Proposed reorganizing
Proposed reorganizing of "Interpretations of the clause" section 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Proposed reorganizing of "Interpretations of the clause" section
All done. Looks much better. Thanks! 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#All done. Looks much better. Thanks!
Sourced content deleted and replaced with original research 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Sourced content deleted and replaced with original research
What do suits about the validity of a birth certificate have to do with the natural born citizen clause? 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#What do suits about the validity of a birth certificate have to do with the natural born citizen clause?
Sentence Clarification Needed 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Sentence Clarification Needed
Paranoia 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Paranoia
Is There any Proof of Who Obama's Father Is? 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Is There any Proof of Who Obama's Father Is?
Barack Obama court cases 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Barack Obama court cases
James Buchanan 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#James Buchanan
Illegal Aliens 11 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#Illegal Aliens
General comments about "natural born citizen" 20 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#General comments about "natural born citizen"
New source needed for opening paragraph 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 6#New source needed for opening paragraph
External links modified 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#External links modified
President of the U.S. != President of the State governed 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#President of the U.S. != President of the State governed
Interpretation by the Courts 7 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Interpretation by the Courts
Non-U.S. births of presidential parents 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Non-U.S. births of presidential parents
Proposed addition for COI check 4 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Proposed addition for COI check
Can we make this more precise? 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Can we make this more precise?
External links modified 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#External links modified 2
External links modified (February 2018) 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#External links modified (February 2018)
Naturalization 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Naturalization
Move Interpretations by the Courts to before Government Officials's interpretations 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Move Interpretations by the Courts to before Government Officials's interpretations
Kamala Harris 8 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Kamala Harris
Weasel words 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Weasel words
Off-point: 'at the moment of birth' 5 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Off-point: 'at the moment of birth'
terms in terms of terms 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#terms in terms of terms
Kamala Harris 42 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Kamala Harris 2
Citizen at time of adoption 3 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Citizen at time of adoption
Edit Protection? 6 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Edit Protection?
Imbalance 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Imbalance
Natural-born Citizen was defined prior to the United States adopting a Constitution. 14 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Natural-born Citizen was defined prior to the United States adopting a Constitution.
hyphens and capital 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#hyphens and capital
Blackstone in 1765 re modern statutes 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Blackstone in 1765 re modern statutes
Elaine Chao 2 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Elaine Chao
(Vice) presidents delivered through caesarean section are expressly NOT natural born persons. 7 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)#(Vice) presidents delivered through caesarean section are expressly NOT natural born persons.
Preamble 24 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Preamble
Vattel yet again 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)/Archive 7#Vattel yet again
Vice President 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)#Vice President
2024 candidates 1 Talk:Natural-born-citizen clause (United States)#2024 candidates