| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Status of this page |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Status of this page
|
| Major vs. Minor |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Major vs. Minor
|
| merge with Wikipedia:Importance |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#merge with Wikipedia:Importance
|
| Third clause meaning |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Third clause meaning
|
| Plot Summaries |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Plot Summaries
|
| Subpages |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Subpages
|
| Usage of WIKIBOOKS |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Usage of WIKIBOOKS
|
| Merge all minor characters into big lists? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Merge all minor characters into big lists?
|
| Criticism |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Criticism
|
| Interwiki |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Interwiki
|
| Requested move |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Requested move
|
| When to merge - don't just auto-merge minor characters |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#When to merge - don't just auto-merge minor characters
|
| Subjects only existing in fictional encyclopedias |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Subjects only existing in fictional encyclopedias
|
| Movies and games |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Movies and games
|
| "Cultural icon" |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#"Cultural icon"
|
| TV episodes |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#TV episodes
|
| AfD vote going on |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#AfD vote going on
|
| Sub-policy proposal |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Sub-policy proposal
|
| Extensive and detailed notability examples |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 1#Extensive and detailed notability examples
|
| Ramblings of a burning out editor |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 2#Ramblings of a burning out editor
|
| lists of non-notable characters |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 2#lists of non-notable characters
|
| Summary |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 2#Summary
|
| Concern over this guideline |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 2#Concern over this guideline
|
| Keep this guideline |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 2#Keep this guideline
|
| Re: Proposal |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 2#Re: Proposal
|
| Oppose proposed changes and my own thoughts |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 2#Oppose proposed changes and my own thoughts
|
| Re: RE: RE: RE: RE: Proposal |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 2#Re: RE: RE: RE: RE: Proposal
|
| Examples section |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 2#Examples section
|
| Spoiler tag usage |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 2#Spoiler tag usage
|
| Who did this? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 2#Who did this?
|
| Clarification of "notability" for fictional characters |
48 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Clarification of "notability" for fictional characters
|
| Verifiability is of use here |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Verifiability is of use here
|
| suggestion for character notability wording |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#suggestion for character notability wording
|
| CVG articles |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#CVG articles
|
| Notability criteria for works of fiction |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Notability criteria for works of fiction
|
| Fictional character stubs? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Fictional character stubs?
|
| Edits |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Edits
|
| Is this a guideline? |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Is this a guideline?
|
| Sources in Fiction |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Sources in Fiction
|
| Self-publishing? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Self-publishing?
|
| Policy on plot summaries |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Policy on plot summaries
|
| New WikiProject: Wikipedia:WikiProject Science Fiction |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#New WikiProject: Wikipedia:WikiProject Science Fiction
|
| Applying WP:FICT to reality shows |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Applying WP:FICT to reality shows
|
| Minor characters |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Minor characters
|
| Why Notability? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Why Notability?
|
| Main characters |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Main characters
|
| Definition of Notability |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Definition of Notability
|
| Peer review on soap opera character |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Peer review on soap opera character
|
| Major rewrite being proposed within two weeks |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 3#Major rewrite being proposed within two weeks
|
| Rewrite proposed |
137 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Rewrite proposed
|
| Articles about fictional appearances of real-world topics |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Articles about fictional appearances of real-world topics
|
| Could you possibly comment at... |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Could you possibly comment at...
|
| Wikipedia:Television article review process as a fictional article noticeboard |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Wikipedia:Television article review process as a fictional article noticeboard
|
| Confusion between main and minor |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Confusion between main and minor
|
| Trivial/Incidental characters |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Trivial/Incidental characters
|
| Rewrite |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Rewrite
|
| Example cases |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Example cases
|
| Minor quibble with WP:FICT#Fanfiction and unreleased fiction |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Minor quibble with WP:FICT#Fanfiction and unreleased fiction
|
| The occasional exception? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#The occasional exception?
|
| Question |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Question
|
| Help with a debate |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Help with a debate
|
| This 'in-universe' notability issue |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#This 'in-universe' notability issue
|
| Relocating material |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Relocating material
|
| Random test |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Random test
|
| Smallville |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Smallville
|
| Problem with this page |
147 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Problem with this page
|
| A question of interpretation |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#A question of interpretation
|
| Fictional Characters and Notability |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Fictional Characters and Notability
|
| Episode articles? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Episode articles?
|
| Break? |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#Break?
|
| An attempt at a new wording |
37 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 4#An attempt at a new wording
|
| Boiling down the issues |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#Boiling down the issues
|
| Archive |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#Archive
|
| The sub-article issue |
36 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#The sub-article issue
|
| paradoxical concept of noteability |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#paradoxical concept of noteability
|
| Comprehensibility |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#Comprehensibility
|
| Guidelines intended to exclude encyclopedic content? |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#Guidelines intended to exclude encyclopedic content?
|
| An interesting case regarding notability and foreign fiction |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#An interesting case regarding notability and foreign fiction
|
| Draft of something. Maybe this page? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#Draft of something. Maybe this page?
|
| AfD nomination of Spoo |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#AfD nomination of Spoo
|
| Bowing out |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#Bowing out
|
| Changes already made to the wording |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#Changes already made to the wording
|
| Another point for consideration: more on lists |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#Another point for consideration: more on lists
|
| Wikia |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 5#Wikia
|
| My problem with this |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 6#My problem with this
|
| Combined proposals: new wording |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 6#Combined proposals: new wording
|
| Comments on the new wording |
104 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 6#Comments on the new wording
|
| Proposal |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 6#Proposal
|
| real world users of wikipedia |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 6#real world users of wikipedia
|
| inclusion criteria |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 7#inclusion criteria
|
| Why does this guideline exist? |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 6#Why does this guideline exist?
|
| Addition to support style sub-articles |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 8#Addition to support style sub-articles
|
| A certain few Bleach character articles |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 7#A certain few Bleach character articles
|
| Where are we going? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 7#Where are we going?
|
| Mass removal of articles related to fiction |
55 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 7#Mass removal of articles related to fiction
|
| A cynical view |
35 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 7#A cynical view
|
| Wikia's |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 8#Wikia's
|
| Undelete deleted examples in subpage of this page |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 7#Undelete deleted examples in subpage of this page
|
| Notability criterion of this guideline |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 8#Notability criterion of this guideline
|
| Example section |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 8#Example section
|
| Archive |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 7#Archive
|
| Current status of rewrite |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 8#Current status of rewrite
|
| Indvidual episodes (or similar) |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 8#Indvidual episodes (or similar)
|
| Example |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 8#Example
|
| Tired of this policy being abused |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 8#Tired of this policy being abused
|
| Lists of fictional characters - deprecated? |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 8#Lists of fictional characters - deprecated?
|
| And things could have just gotten a lot worse... |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 9#And things could have just gotten a lot worse...
|
| Is the deletion of articles ethical? Is it making Wikipedia a better site? |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 9#Is the deletion of articles ethical? Is it making Wikipedia a better site?
|
| Feedback |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 8#Feedback
|
| This guideline sucks |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 9#This guideline sucks
|
| Proposed change to the guideline |
64 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 11#Proposed change to the guideline
|
| Contradicting policies and guidelines |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 9#Contradicting policies and guidelines
|
| Current wording |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 9#Current wording
|
| How much is "significant" and "substantial"? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 9#How much is "significant" and "substantial"?
|
| Altered WP:PLOT to cover fiction in general |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 9#Altered WP:PLOT to cover fiction in general
|
| This deletionism mentality is getting really, well, stupid. |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 10#This deletionism mentality is getting really, well, stupid.
|
| History of this guideline |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 9#History of this guideline
|
| totally disputed? |
46 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 9#totally disputed?
|
| tagged as "proposed" |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 10#tagged as "proposed"
|
| Ahem |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 10#Ahem
|
| Tag wars don't help |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 9#Tag wars don't help
|
| Rewrite |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 10#Rewrite
|
| Can someone answer this for me? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 10#Can someone answer this for me?
|
| Notability and special effects |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 10#Notability and special effects
|
| Another stab |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 10#Another stab
|
| Core issues |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 10#Core issues
|
| Deletion at the bottom |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 10#Deletion at the bottom
|
| Many points disputed |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 10#Many points disputed
|
| Rejected? |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 11#Rejected?
|
| How to proceed |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 11#How to proceed
|
| Quality (and Potential) of Wikias and Episode Pages |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 11#Quality (and Potential) of Wikias and Episode Pages
|
| Question |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 12#Question
|
| Does merchandise indicate notability? |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 12#Does merchandise indicate notability?
|
| The problems with this guideline and the current proposed rewrite |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 12#The problems with this guideline and the current proposed rewrite
|
| Proposed change version 2 - One proposition to rule them all |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 12#Proposed change version 2 - One proposition to rule them all
|
| RFC |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 12#RFC
|
| My draft |
43 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 12#My draft
|
| Draft #2 |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 12#Draft #2
|
| depth of coverage? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 12#depth of coverage?
|
| Lack of participation |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 15#Lack of participation
|
| 3rd Draft |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 12#3rd Draft
|
| More about notability of fictional concepts in general |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 13#More about notability of fictional concepts in general 2
|
| More about notability of fictional concepts in general |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 13#More about notability of fictional concepts in general
|
| Three steps toward a consensus solution |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 13#Three steps toward a consensus solution
|
| Draft #4 - ready for more... |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 13#Draft #4 - ready for more...
|
| The mass exodus of fiction content and Wikia |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 13#The mass exodus of fiction content and Wikia
|
| RfC: Acceptable direction for WP:FICT guideline |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 13#RfC: Acceptable direction for WP:FICT guideline
|
| Memory Alpha template deletion notice |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 13#Memory Alpha template deletion notice
|
| Secondary sources for in-universe information |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 15#Secondary sources for in-universe information
|
| Inconsistent treatment of fiction compared to other topics |
45 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 13#Inconsistent treatment of fiction compared to other topics
|
| Understanding the anger |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 14#Understanding the anger
|
| Draft #5 |
62 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 16#Draft #5
|
| Ye Art Cordially Invited to the Annex |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 14#Ye Art Cordially Invited to the Annex
|
| Fiction guidelines are not up to the task of dealing with roleplaying games |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 16#Fiction guidelines are not up to the task of dealing with roleplaying games
|
| I feel dictating is evolving |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 17#I feel dictating is evolving
|
| Draft #6 |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 16#Draft #6
|
| Use old draft as a starting point |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 14#Use old draft as a starting point
|
| Where are we at this point? |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 14#Where are we at this point?
|
| Defining notability for fiction |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 14#Defining notability for fiction
|
| Draft #7 - snippy snippy |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 14#Draft #7 - snippy snippy
|
| Preventing drive-by tagging |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 16#Preventing drive-by tagging
|
| Dealing with non-notable fictional topics |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 14#Dealing with non-notable fictional topics
|
| An attempt to ban images from character lists |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 15#An attempt to ban images from character lists
|
| Looks good & questions |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 14#Looks good & questions
|
| Does this now follow PLOT and NOTE, or is it more restrictive? |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 14#Does this now follow PLOT and NOTE, or is it more restrictive?
|
| Contemporary culture is "lucky" |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 15#Contemporary culture is "lucky"
|
| Proposing a noticeboard |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 15#Proposing a noticeboard
|
| Informal MedCab for character articles within the Firefly universe |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 15#Informal MedCab for character articles within the Firefly universe
|
| Draft #8 - ready for wider review |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 15#Draft #8 - ready for wider review
|
| Those coming to review per request |
33 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 17#Those coming to review per request
|
| In-universe content? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 15#In-universe content?
|
| Needs to be more explicit on how to handle fictional elements as well as works |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 15#Needs to be more explicit on how to handle fictional elements as well as works
|
| Query about the Demonstrating Notability section of the current draft |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 15#Query about the Demonstrating Notability section of the current draft
|
| Draft #9 |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 17#Draft #9
|
| Is this a policy or a guideline? |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 18#Is this a policy or a guideline?
|
| Why? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 17#Why?
|
| This is a good idea. A suggested modification, though. |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 18#This is a good idea. A suggested modification, though.
|
| Why not forget about this and take the discussion of change to WP:NOT? |
42 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 18#Why not forget about this and take the discussion of change to WP:NOT?
|
| External wiki list |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 17#External wiki list
|
| Character lists? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 17#Character lists?
|
| Longevity and secondary literature |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 17#Longevity and secondary literature
|
| Centralized TV Episode Discussion |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 17#Centralized TV Episode Discussion
|
| The Brothers Karamazov |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 18#The Brothers Karamazov
|
| New redirection template |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#New redirection template
|
| Where we are right now with the rewrite |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 18#Where we are right now with the rewrite
|
| Fiction stubs are acceptable |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 18#Fiction stubs are acceptable
|
| Slight revision in draft |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#Slight revision in draft
|
| Time to move on? |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#Time to move on?
|
| The 'danger' of fancruft |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#The 'danger' of fancruft
|
| Updated version |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#Updated version
|
| proposal by Dorftrottel |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#proposal by Dorftrottel
|
| A tweak |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#A tweak
|
| Support for new guideline |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#Support for new guideline
|
| The article on X needs more anime\fan material\spam |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#The article on X needs more anime\fan material\spam
|
| Notice board |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#Notice board
|
| See also |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#See also
|
| What about MacGuffins? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#What about MacGuffins?
|
| Revision comments... |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#Revision comments...
|
| On real-world notability and real encyclopedias |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#On real-world notability and real encyclopedias
|
| Depth of coverage - one shot vs series |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#Depth of coverage - one shot vs series
|
| creator commentary section |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#creator commentary section
|
| List of films that most frequently use the word "fuck" |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#List of films that most frequently use the word "fuck"
|
| Plugging Wikia in a policy may create a conflict of interest. |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 19#Plugging Wikia in a policy may create a conflict of interest.
|
| Summary style approach for sub-articles |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 20#Summary style approach for sub-articles
|
| Things have seemed to stop |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 20#Things have seemed to stop
|
| Encouraging the creation of redirection articles for non-notable elements |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 20#Encouraging the creation of redirection articles for non-notable elements
|
| The examples |
79 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 20#The examples
|
| Comments from the original author |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 20#Comments from the original author
|
| Stubs and WP:FICT/WP:EPISODE |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 20#Stubs and WP:FICT/WP:EPISODE
|
| Independent of the subject |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 21#Independent of the subject
|
| List vs. sub-article in discussion of WP:SS, and related paragraph in WP:FICT |
69 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 21#List vs. sub-article in discussion of WP:SS, and related paragraph in WP:FICT
|
| Redirect link colors |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 22#Redirect link colors
|
| mark approved! |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 22#mark approved!
|
| Moving on? |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 22#Moving on?
|
| Am I reading this right? |
60 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 23#Am I reading this right?
|
| When to act |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 22#When to act
|
| Relocating non-notable fictional material |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 22#Relocating non-notable fictional material
|
| Defining cases where lists are appropriate or not, in the absence of significant coverage |
57 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 22#Defining cases where lists are appropriate or not, in the absence of significant coverage
|
| Is this a policy or not? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 22#Is this a policy or not?
|
| Rules and consensus |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 23#Rules and consensus
|
| Suggestion to include link |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 22#Suggestion to include link
|
| Don't institutionalise lists |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 25#Don't institutionalise lists
|
| Question about non-notable characters vs. Body of Work. |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 23#Question about non-notable characters vs. Body of Work.
|
| Example section |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 23#Example section
|
| Regarding the PROD suggestion |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 23#Regarding the PROD suggestion
|
| Question on how to proceed |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 23#Question on how to proceed
|
| RE: "Depth of coverage" section |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 23#RE: "Depth of coverage" section
|
| If a spinout shrinks |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 23#If a spinout shrinks
|
| Identifying spinouts (Was: Partial revert) |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 23#Identifying spinouts (Was: Partial revert)
|
| Spinout of spinout |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 23#Spinout of spinout
|
| Guidance requested — inclusion criteria in list of ... |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 23#Guidance requested — inclusion criteria in list of ...
|
| Guidelines and consensus |
51 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 24#Guidelines and consensus
|
| 21st Century Text Structure |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 24#21st Century Text Structure
|
| Aggregate articles |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 24#Aggregate articles
|
| Suggested addition to resolve the spinout issue |
33 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 24#Suggested addition to resolve the spinout issue
|
| Proposal or notability guideline? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 25#Proposal or notability guideline?
|
| Forget notability, scholarship is at stake |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 25#Forget notability, scholarship is at stake
|
| New concept for sub-articles - a possible line of compromise? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 25#New concept for sub-articles - a possible line of compromise?
|
| Enough |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 25#Enough
|
| Some topics are necessary to understand others |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 25#Some topics are necessary to understand others
|
| Subpages? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 25#Subpages?
|
| Disputed sections & subsections which conflict or are inconsistent with existing guidelines |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 25#Disputed sections & subsections which conflict or are inconsistent with existing guidelines
|
| Please, a précis |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 25#Please, a précis
|
| We need to PAUSE AND STOP for a moment |
39 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#We need to PAUSE AND STOP for a moment
|
| ... or do you want the full half-hour? |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 25#... or do you want the full half-hour?
|
| Acceptable spinouts |
46 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 25#Acceptable spinouts
|
| Suggested rule of thumb |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 26#Suggested rule of thumb
|
| Working with what we have |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 26#Working with what we have
|
| Is WP:N per-topic or per-article? |
51 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 26#Is WP:N per-topic or per-article?
|
| Lists |
35 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 26#Lists
|
| Are non-notable spinouts of fictional elements appropriate |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 26#Are non-notable spinouts of fictional elements appropriate
|
| RFC |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 26#RFC
|
| Comments |
44 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 26#Comments
|
| User statements |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 26#User statements
|
| Some specific suggestions to straw poll |
186 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#Some specific suggestions to straw poll
|
| Inheritable Notability with actors and characters |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#Inheritable Notability with actors and characters
|
| What's going on now, I'm too lazy to read it all |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#What's going on now, I'm too lazy to read it all
|
| A pretty problem… |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#A pretty problem…
|
| draft page |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#draft page
|
| Real world information |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#Real world information
|
| Definition of Fiction |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#Definition of Fiction
|
| Pushing the definition of Fiction one step further |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#Pushing the definition of Fiction one step further
|
| Notice board |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#Notice board
|
| Poll regarding the definition |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#Poll regarding the definition
|
| Approaching the problem from a different angle |
122 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#Approaching the problem from a different angle
|
| A thought about how to better deal with some fictional articles |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#A thought about how to better deal with some fictional articles
|
| We never talk about describing editorial behaviour and how to fix it |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#We never talk about describing editorial behaviour and how to fix it
|
| Specific sources of notability (via secondary sources) for fictional elements |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#Specific sources of notability (via secondary sources) for fictional elements
|
| My two cents (just thoughts/feelings about this whole thing) |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#My two cents (just thoughts/feelings about this whole thing)
|
| Clarification |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 27#Clarification
|
| Normalising Terminology |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 29#Normalising Terminology
|
| Contextualising the Framework for this Discussion |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 28#Contextualising the Framework for this Discussion
|
| Radical proposal |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 28#Radical proposal
|
| Lists |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 28#Lists
|
| Requiring "Reception" sections in fictional character articles is asinine. |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 28#Requiring "Reception" sections in fictional character articles is asinine.
|
| RFC Closed? |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 28#RFC Closed?
|
| Frequent changes to WP:FICT must cease |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 28#Frequent changes to WP:FICT must cease
|
| Exemption for LOE/LOC? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 29#Exemption for LOE/LOC?
|
| Proposed wording on second paragraph of dependent notability |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 28#Proposed wording on second paragraph of dependent notability
|
| Dependent Notability |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 28#Dependent Notability
|
| Deletion |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 28#Deletion
|
| Fictional elements as part of a larger topic |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 30#Fictional elements as part of a larger topic
|
| Depth of coverage |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 29#Depth of coverage
|
| Determining notability for elements of fiction |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 29#Determining notability for elements of fiction
|
| Can of worms |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 29#Can of worms
|
| How do ensure that Fictional topics are not unencylopedic if you don't apply GNC? |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 29#How do ensure that Fictional topics are not unencylopedic if you don't apply GNC?
|
| Moving onwards |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 29#Moving onwards
|
| Rowling |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 29#Rowling
|
| Is GNC relevant to fictional topics? |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 30#Is GNC relevant to fictional topics?
|
| Standing issues? |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 29#Standing issues?
|
| elements of fiction |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 29#elements of fiction
|
| Topics for fictional works |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 29#Topics for fictional works
|
| Awards, figures, rankings - relating to specific elements |
54 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 30#Awards, figures, rankings - relating to specific elements
|
| Proposed changes to the preamble |
59 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 31#Proposed changes to the preamble
|
| AFI 100 as an example |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 33#AFI 100 as an example
|
| Awards of sufficient stature |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 30#Awards of sufficient stature
|
| Handling characters not worth an article |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 30#Handling characters not worth an article
|
| Clariying (lack of) primacy of GNC |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 30#Clariying (lack of) primacy of GNC
|
| Undue weight on groupings? |
65 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 30#Undue weight on groupings?
|
| Other reason to cover fictional elements: consolidation |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 30#Other reason to cover fictional elements: consolidation
|
| Rewrite |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 30#Rewrite
|
| Guideline |
33 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 31#Guideline
|
| Current Version |
72 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 32#Current Version
|
| Reasons Against the Proposed Changes |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 31#Reasons Against the Proposed Changes
|
| Protected |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 31#Protected
|
| Flowchart for WP:FICT |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 31#Flowchart for WP:FICT
|
| Wikipedia:Plot summaries |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 31#Wikipedia:Plot summaries
|
| Skype discussion for WP:FICT |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 31#Skype discussion for WP:FICT
|
| Creative Works |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 31#Creative Works
|
| Hi, I'm Troy McClure |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 31#Hi, I'm Troy McClure
|
| Content dispute at Glitch City |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 31#Content dispute at Glitch City
|
| Next steps |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 32#Next steps
|
| Duplication of guidance on article deletion |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 31#Duplication of guidance on article deletion
|
| New MOS for TV |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 32#New MOS for TV
|
| RfC: Proposing WP:FICT for global acceptance |
370 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 34#RfC: Proposing WP:FICT for global acceptance
|
| Not ready |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 33#Not ready
|
| Real world |
37 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 32#Real world
|
| Licensed vs Self-Published |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 33#Licensed vs Self-Published
|
| Hammer some changes home |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 33#Hammer some changes home
|
| Break it up |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 33#Break it up
|
| Under the assumption of NOTE that GNC is not absolute... |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 33#Under the assumption of NOTE that GNC is not absolute...
|
| Guidance on writing guidelines |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 33#Guidance on writing guidelines
|
| Pride and Prejudice |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 33#Pride and Prejudice
|
| Failed proposal |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 33#Failed proposal
|
| New survey prep |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 35#New survey prep
|
| A poll idea |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 33#A poll idea
|
| Reality and policy |
48 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 34#Reality and policy
|
| Some random discussion break |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 34#Some random discussion break
|
| Closure |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 35#Closure
|
| Wait, so what's going on here? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 35#Wait, so what's going on here?
|
| Why inclusion matters |
71 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 35#Why inclusion matters
|
| Historical, pt. x |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 36#Historical, pt. x
|
| I created a monster! |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 35#I created a monster!
|
| Bring back the old... |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 36#Bring back the old...
|
| Merge and redirect to WP:WAF |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 36#Merge and redirect to WP:WAF
|
| Is this funny or scary? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 36#Is this funny or scary?
|
| proposed, historical, essay |
30 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 36#proposed, historical, essay
|
| Abandon this bad idea |
56 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 36#Abandon this bad idea
|
| Spinoff articles |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 36#Spinoff articles
|
| Request for comment at Faith (Buffy the Vampire Slayer) |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 37#Request for comment at Faith (Buffy the Vampire Slayer)
|
| Time to compromise |
54 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 37#Time to compromise
|
| Discussion points from Wikipedia Talk:Notability |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 37#Discussion points from Wikipedia Talk:Notability
|
| oh gawd |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 37#oh gawd
|
| Wikipedia:Notability/RFC:compromise |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 37#Wikipedia:Notability/RFC:compromise
|
| Topical |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 37#Topical
|
| Dead links |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 37#Dead links
|
| Fiction Survey 2008 draft |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 37#Fiction Survey 2008 draft
|
| Draft proposal |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Draft proposal
|
| Small (edit) nit - large nit (since July??) |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Small (edit) nit - large nit (since July??)
|
| Fictional elements as part of a larger topic (FEAPOALT) |
45 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#Fictional elements as part of a larger topic (FEAPOALT)
|
| A plea |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#A plea
|
| Barring objection |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Barring objection
|
| Derivative works |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Derivative works
|
| DGG's changes |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#DGG's changes
|
| Archive time |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#Archive time
|
| Recommendations for the proposal |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Recommendations for the proposal
|
| A hard-line approach |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#A hard-line approach
|
| Claimed AfD consensus |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Claimed AfD consensus
|
| Preserving via merge |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Preserving via merge
|
| Breaking out a subject from a list |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Breaking out a subject from a list
|
| notability of a character list article? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#notability of a character list article?
|
| use of primary sources for citing production staff |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#use of primary sources for citing production staff
|
| Just a note |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Just a note
|
| Some thoughts |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#Some thoughts
|
| proposing a split of this proposal |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#proposing a split of this proposal
|
| comments about non-wikipedia wikis to move information too |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#comments about non-wikipedia wikis to move information too
|
| Plotcruft and Narrative Complexity |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Plotcruft and Narrative Complexity
|
| Shortening |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Shortening
|
| Honest introduction to the guideline |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Honest introduction to the guideline
|
| Another reason to keep Fictional Elements articles... |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Another reason to keep Fictional Elements articles...
|
| Brainstorm: re-framing "complexity" |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Brainstorm: re-framing "complexity"
|
| A somewhat harder line, but closer to WP:N |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#A somewhat harder line, but closer to WP:N
|
| Bias towards telivision? |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Bias towards telivision?
|
| We're now down to three factors |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#We're now down to three factors
|
| Questions of imperfection? |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Questions of imperfection?
|
| "Bias towards commercialism" section title |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#"Bias towards commercialism" section title
|
| Notability of episodes and elements |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Notability of episodes and elements
|
| Use of sources |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Use of sources
|
| Is this "notability outside the show" policy is about to expand for real people as well? |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Is this "notability outside the show" policy is about to expand for real people as well?
|
| Soundtracks |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Soundtracks
|
| Presenting this to a larger audience |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Presenting this to a larger audience
|
| Wow |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#Wow
|
| copyedit |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 38#copyedit
|
| Real world |
45 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#Real world
|
| 1 of the 3 prongs and sourcing |
40 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#1 of the 3 prongs and sourcing
|
| Sound-bite-ish phrases |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#Sound-bite-ish phrases
|
| Perhaps a more pragmatic approach? |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#Perhaps a more pragmatic approach?
|
| Another try on reviews and sourcing |
44 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#Another try on reviews and sourcing
|
| Importance within the fictional work |
33 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Importance within the fictional work
|
| Primary Sources - Gameplay |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#Primary Sources - Gameplay
|
| sources section rewrite |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#sources section rewrite
|
| Episode rework |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#Episode rework
|
| "Biography" of fictional characters |
42 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 51#"Biography" of fictional characters
|
| WP:IMPERFECT in the lede |
55 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 39#WP:IMPERFECT in the lede
|
| Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glidoler |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Glidoler
|
| Non-notable elements should preferably be concisely covered |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Non-notable elements should preferably be concisely covered
|
| Lists |
39 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Lists
|
| Specific tendencies |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Specific tendencies
|
| Primary sources section |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Primary sources section
|
| discuss: multiple media adaptations |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#discuss: multiple media adaptations
|
| Trivial sources |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Trivial sources
|
| Creator commentary and critical commentary |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Creator commentary and critical commentary
|
| Overkill |
36 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Overkill
|
| Blogs - can they be used to provide evidence of importance? |
46 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Blogs - can they be used to provide evidence of importance?
|
| Inclusion criteria is not a presentational issue |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Inclusion criteria is not a presentational issue
|
| development AND reception vs. development OR reception |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#development AND reception vs. development OR reception
|
| how do we leave "lists" an open issue? |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#how do we leave "lists" an open issue?
|
| supplementary essay |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#supplementary essay
|
| A seasonal request |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#A seasonal request
|
| Is this guideline a generally accepted standard? |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Is this guideline a generally accepted standard?
|
| Real world |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#Real world
|
| opening the floodgates |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 40#opening the floodgates
|
| Importance within the fictional work |
42 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Importance within the fictional work
|
| Checking in with some fresh eyes |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Checking in with some fresh eyes
|
| How far are we from ready with this? |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#How far are we from ready with this?
|
| Notabillity extremists are ignoring this. Why bother |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Notabillity extremists are ignoring this. Why bother
|
| OK, let's pass this thing |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#OK, let's pass this thing
|
| independence clause |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#independence clause
|
| Arguments based on primary sources |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Arguments based on primary sources
|
| Where to notify |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Where to notify
|
| while you were out... |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#while you were out...
|
| After 9 months of being proposed, what is the conclusion? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#After 9 months of being proposed, what is the conclusion?
|
| Archiving prior to final comments |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Archiving prior to final comments
|
| Speaking of three prongs... |
52 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Speaking of three prongs...
|
| Real-world coverage |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Real-world coverage
|
| Final comments |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Final comments
|
| Systemic bias |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Systemic bias
|
| "Significant" |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#"Significant"
|
| Because I fail at grammar |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Because I fail at grammar
|
| Where is the new discussion? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Where is the new discussion?
|
| GNG and SNG |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#GNG and SNG
|
| Availability of research |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Availability of research
|
| Non-Independent Sources |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Non-Independent Sources
|
| Real-world coverage 2 |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Real-world coverage 2
|
| Clarify first prong |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 41#Clarify first prong
|
| Three-pronged test for Elements of Fiction |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Three-pronged test for Elements of Fiction
|
| That second prong |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#That second prong
|
| Where is Notability proposal for fictional subjects? |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Where is Notability proposal for fictional subjects?
|
| Three Options instead of three prongs |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Three Options instead of three prongs
|
| An observation about tightening standards |
33 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#An observation about tightening standards
|
| Regarding importance within the fictional work |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Regarding importance within the fictional work
|
| Remember the goal... |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Remember the goal...
|
| reality check: how to compromise |
48 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#reality check: how to compromise
|
| Fiction survey 2009 |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#Fiction survey 2009
|
| Copy-edit |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Copy-edit
|
| General opinions |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#General opinions
|
| Huh... |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Huh...
|
| Renaming "importance within the fictional work" |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#Renaming "importance within the fictional work"
|
| hmm |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#hmm
|
| Time to work on articles |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Time to work on articles
|
| FICT in practise in the long run |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#FICT in practise in the long run
|
| Comments on draft |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#Comments on draft
|
| Second prong |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Second prong
|
| Okay, so I think I'm getting this. |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 42#Okay, so I think I'm getting this.
|
| One line should be removed |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#One line should be removed
|
| No 'trousers rolled' for me, thank you |
48 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 44#No 'trousers rolled' for me, thank you
|
| I propose a novel solution |
18 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#I propose a novel solution
|
| Articles for Wikia |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#Articles for Wikia
|
| Independent sources |
57 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#Independent sources
|
| Character Pages, and Equipment Pages |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#Character Pages, and Equipment Pages
|
| list of legitimate reference sites/publications |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#list of legitimate reference sites/publications
|
| Opportunity for compromise v Threat of Statemate |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#Opportunity for compromise v Threat of Statemate
|
| My issues with independence |
47 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#My issues with independence
|
| A couple alternatives |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#A couple alternatives
|
| Time to move on people |
64 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#Time to move on people
|
| "prong" |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#"prong"
|
| Reducing archive time |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#Reducing archive time
|
| Trial period |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 43#Trial period
|
| What about single-appearance characters? |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 44#What about single-appearance characters?
|
| Tagged |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 44#Tagged
|
| Compromise wording |
57 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 44#Compromise wording
|
| Radical compromise proposal |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 44#Radical compromise proposal
|
| suggesting a straw poll |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 44#suggesting a straw poll
|
| Overriding guidelines |
47 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 44#Overriding guidelines
|
| Will this ever actually become a guideline? |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 44#Will this ever actually become a guideline?
|
| Recurring element vs. character |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 44#Recurring element vs. character
|
| pulling in two different directions |
26 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#pulling in two different directions
|
| Independence |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#Independence
|
| Done |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#Done
|
| Disruption of wikipedia to push an unpopular policy |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#Disruption of wikipedia to push an unpopular policy
|
| Starting Fresh |
104 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#Starting Fresh
|
| Visibility proposal |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#Visibility proposal
|
| Independent sources, again |
37 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#Independent sources, again
|
| Request for stability |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#Request for stability
|
| The resulting issue of Episodes |
75 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#The resulting issue of Episodes
|
| What does the second prong do? |
36 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#What does the second prong do?
|
| Re:Above straw poll |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#Re:Above straw poll
|
| breadth of viewpoints |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#breadth of viewpoints
|
| advice on "list of xxxx characters" page |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 44#advice on "list of xxxx characters" page
|
| Next step |
54 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#Next step
|
| Final adoption as a guideline |
288 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#Final adoption as a guideline
|
| Problems with the RfC |
112 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#Problems with the RfC
|
| Nature of commissioning |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 48#Nature of commissioning
|
| Section on "Secondary Sources" |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#Section on "Secondary Sources"
|
| more feedback |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 48#more feedback
|
| Third prong editing question. |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#Third prong editing question.
|
| An observation on the RFC |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#An observation on the RFC
|
| In a nutshell |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#In a nutshell
|
| Rename guideline? |
36 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#Rename guideline?
|
| Proof and pudding |
70 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#Proof and pudding
|
| Concerns about intent, reach and clarity |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#Concerns about intent, reach and clarity
|
| Proposed changes - can we have discussion on specifics |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 45#Proposed changes - can we have discussion on specifics
|
| Good article status |
62 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#Good article status
|
| Protecting this guideline for the next couple weeks? |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#Protecting this guideline for the next couple weeks?
|
| Mark as WikiProject essay and withdraw proposal to become a guideline |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#Mark as WikiProject essay and withdraw proposal to become a guideline
|
| Move to Notability (elements of fiction)? |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#Move to Notability (elements of fiction)?
|
| Halftime score |
52 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#Halftime score
|
| First prong tinker |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#First prong tinker
|
| Multiple Participations in Art seems notable-qualifying to me. |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#Multiple Participations in Art seems notable-qualifying to me.
|
| Episodes as elements |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#Episodes as elements
|
| What's confusing? |
46 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#What's confusing?
|
| Nick's edits |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#Nick's edits
|
| scrapping the first prong |
56 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#scrapping the first prong
|
| personal summary of the issue |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#personal summary of the issue
|
| "Articles that don't meet the inclusion criteria" section |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 46#"Articles that don't meet the inclusion criteria" section
|
| Usability and focus |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#Usability and focus
|
| what's next? |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#what's next?
|
| Why not just go back? |
74 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 48#Why not just go back?
|
| An illustrative flowchart |
21 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#An illustrative flowchart
|
| Question |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#Question
|
| Test case |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 48#Test case
|
| Line has been crossed. |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#Line has been crossed.
|
| What inclusionists thought we had |
51 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 48#What inclusionists thought we had
|
| Final impasse; close the poll as no consensus or remove the language |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 47#Final impasse; close the poll as no consensus or remove the language
|
| Failed, Feb 2009 |
61 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 48#Failed, Feb 2009
|
| This isn't about fiction |
43 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 48#This isn't about fiction
|
| Alternative to Wikia? |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#Alternative to Wikia?
|
| The Policy doesn't adequately address the Double Standards on Wikipedia |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#The Policy doesn't adequately address the Double Standards on Wikipedia
|
| On episode articles |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#On episode articles
|
| This proposed guideline is useless instruction creep |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#This proposed guideline is useless instruction creep
|
| Perspective |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#Perspective
|
| Moving forward |
34 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#Moving forward
|
| Doesn't exist but is notable |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#Doesn't exist but is notable
|
| Prong 2 |
36 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#Prong 2
|
| Opposed |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#Opposed
|
| The way it works |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#The way it works
|
| current danger to the compromise |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#current danger to the compromise
|
| the darkening future.... |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#the darkening future....
|
| Gavin Collins' proposed version of prong 2 |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#Gavin Collins' proposed version of prong 2
|
| Mistaken Attribution |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#Mistaken Attribution
|
| Guideline structure |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 49#Guideline structure
|
| Rewrite it |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#Rewrite it
|
| Agree on rewrite - new title: WP:When and how to create a sub-page of a fiction article |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#Agree on rewrite - new title: WP:When and how to create a sub-page of a fiction article
|
| I think we've lost sight of our goal |
31 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#I think we've lost sight of our goal
|
| archive time increased |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#archive time increased
|
| The rules |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#The rules
|
| So exactly what is presently wrong with how FICT is written? |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#So exactly what is presently wrong with how FICT is written?
|
| Removing the first prong |
25 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#Removing the first prong
|
| Afraid to use examples |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#Afraid to use examples
|
| What articles does this apply to again? |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#What articles does this apply to again?
|
| Proposal is now being used a guideline |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#Proposal is now being used a guideline
|
| Notability & Deletability |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#Notability & Deletability
|
| A "Grandfather clause" approach? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#A "Grandfather clause" approach?
|
| Inclusion critiera: Moving Forward |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 51#Inclusion critiera: Moving Forward
|
| Tag for this page |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#Tag for this page
|
| Proposal to gain more support from the community |
53 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 51#Proposal to gain more support from the community
|
| Attention |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#Attention
|
| Multi-phasic transdimensional super conducting guideline |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 51#Multi-phasic transdimensional super conducting guideline
|
| Mark as failed |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 50#Mark as failed
|
| next step |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 51#next step
|
| Failed or essay |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 51#Failed or essay
|
| Llamas |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 51#Llamas
|
| Fiction and Primary Sources |
39 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 51#Fiction and Primary Sources
|
| is there interest in keeping the old proposal as an essay? or moving to something different? |
41 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 51#is there interest in keeping the old proposal as an essay? or moving to something different?
|
| How does deleting so-called "fancruft" improve Wikipedia? |
62 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#How does deleting so-called "fancruft" improve Wikipedia?
|
| Poll: autoformatting and date linking |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 51#Poll: autoformatting and date linking
|
| Bring back the history |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#Bring back the history
|
| See also -> Previous versions |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#See also -> Previous versions
|
| LET'S PLAY MONEY MAKING GAME: WP:FICT, mk. whatever |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#LET'S PLAY MONEY MAKING GAME: WP:FICT, mk. whatever
|
| A proposal with no chance |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#A proposal with no chance
|
| What we each want |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#What we each want
|
| Notability (fiction)/Original |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#Notability (fiction)/Original
|
| The problem with third party sources |
38 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#The problem with third party sources
|
| To mention, or not to mention |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#To mention, or not to mention
|
| "Real-world coverage" in the current proposal |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#"Real-world coverage" in the current proposal
|
| In comparison |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#In comparison
|
| Proposal |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#Proposal
|
| meta-discussion |
19 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#meta-discussion
|
| Proposal: on usefulness and transwikifying |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#Proposal: on usefulness and transwikifying
|
| Forget the long drawn out discussions no one reads through, how many want the rules changed back? |
13 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#Forget the long drawn out discussions no one reads through, how many want the rules changed back?
|
| Salvaging the old proposal |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Salvaging the old proposal
|
| Nice as it stands. |
35 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 52#Nice as it stands.
|
| can we decide on an overall approach first? |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#can we decide on an overall approach first?
|
| Real-World Coverage & NPOV |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Real-World Coverage & NPOV
|
| Notability & Deletion Policy |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Notability & Deletion Policy
|
| Inclusion Criteria for Fictional Topics |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Inclusion Criteria for Fictional Topics
|
| Alternative #inf |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Alternative #inf
|
| Preamble: Overall approach |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Preamble: Overall approach
|
| Changing what FICT is |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Changing what FICT is
|
| Gavin's proposal |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Gavin's proposal
|
| Expanding the lower threshold |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Expanding the lower threshold
|
| Userspace table of possible help |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Userspace table of possible help
|
| WP:UNDUE |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#WP:UNDUE
|
| Proposal |
7 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Proposal
|
| A deletionist proposal |
46 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#A deletionist proposal
|
| Here's a frightening thought |
15 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Here's a frightening thought
|
| Notability |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Notability
|
| Significant, direct coverage |
54 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Significant, direct coverage
|
| Lower Threshold |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Lower Threshold
|
| Articles that don't meet the inclusion criteria |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#Articles that don't meet the inclusion criteria
|
| going in circles |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#going in circles
|
| In a nutshell |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 53#In a nutshell
|
| Epiphany |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Epiphany
|
| Real-World |
45 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Real-World
|
| Language tidy on Inclusion criteria |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Language tidy on Inclusion criteria
|
| challenge assertion of "general concensus" |
23 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#challenge assertion of "general concensus"
|
| Going round in circles Part II |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Going round in circles Part II
|
| Spinoffs / "real world" |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Spinoffs / "real world"
|
| multitude of minor direct references |
32 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#multitude of minor direct references
|
| Thinking beyond notability |
24 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Thinking beyond notability
|
| Real World Perspective |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Real World Perspective
|
| Removals and restorations |
22 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Removals and restorations
|
| Mediation |
20 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Mediation
|
| "List articles" |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#"List articles"
|
| Stand long enough |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Stand long enough
|
| RFC |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#RFC
|
| Lets see if there's any consensus by case |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Lets see if there's any consensus by case
|
| Ticking all the boxes |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Ticking all the boxes
|
| Content forks |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 54#Content forks
|
| First error I noticed |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#First error I noticed
|
| Redundancy |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Redundancy
|
| Significant coverage |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Significant coverage
|
| Creator commentary |
12 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Creator commentary
|
| Directories and databases |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Directories and databases
|
| Significant or Non-Trivial? |
17 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Significant or Non-Trivial?
|
| Drive-by comment |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Drive-by comment
|
| Sniff test |
28 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Sniff test
|
| Straw poll |
9 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Straw poll
|
| Inclusion & Deletion |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Inclusion & Deletion
|
| Another view |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Another view
|
| "Not be used for a deletion critiera"? |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#"Not be used for a deletion critiera"?
|
| Question: Is there any TV character which deserves their own article? |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Question: Is there any TV character which deserves their own article?
|
| Presumption of notability |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Presumption of notability
|
| Brainstorming |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Brainstorming
|
| Other guidance |
59 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Other guidance
|
| Resources |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Resources
|
| Reguritation |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Reguritation
|
| Other criteria |
97 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 55#Other criteria
|
| Hang on |
11 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 56#Hang on
|
| Notability and Real World Coverage |
29 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 56#Notability and Real World Coverage
|
| RfC Awards for fictional elements |
37 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 56#RfC Awards for fictional elements
|
| Rather than "article or no article", how about "how much content"? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 56#Rather than "article or no article", how about "how much content"?
|
| Spoiler Warning Discussion |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 56#Spoiler Warning Discussion
|
| Nutshell... |
58 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 56#Nutshell...
|
| Fiction-related non-flag test case of WP:MOSICON at TfD |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 56#Fiction-related non-flag test case of WP:MOSICON at TfD
|
| Combinations and groups of articles about a fictional work |
88 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 56#Combinations and groups of articles about a fictional work
|
| bewitched |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 57#bewitched
|
| Real World Coverage |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 56#Real World Coverage
|
| Nutshell revert |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 57#Nutshell revert
|
| The character has been given a major award |
51 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 57#The character has been given a major award
|
| Other criteria |
56 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 57#Other criteria
|
| Required sources are likely to exist |
200 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 57#Required sources are likely to exist
|
| Mediation |
35 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Mediation
|
| Primary Sourcing of Plots |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Primary Sourcing of Plots
|
| Primary sources & notability |
6 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Primary sources & notability
|
| Lead paragraph |
57 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Lead paragraph
|
| a question |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#a question
|
| Rework of the introduction |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Rework of the introduction
|
| RFC: Should Notability (fiction) be reinstated as a guideline? |
68 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#RFC: Should Notability (fiction) be reinstated as a guideline?
|
| One pesky change to discuss |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#One pesky change to discuss
|
| Close this suggested guideline as historical once and for all |
27 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Close this suggested guideline as historical once and for all
|
| Popping in to say "I'm Sorry". |
5 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Popping in to say "I'm Sorry".
|
| Seasons episode lists |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Seasons episode lists
|
| Reducing page to a simply essay with links to guide |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Reducing page to a simply essay with links to guide
|
| Query about a history-merge |
10 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Query about a history-merge
|
| Fiction related proposal |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Fiction related proposal
|
| WP:PSTS and reviews of fictional works |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#WP:PSTS and reviews of fictional works
|
| Is this TV series even notable? |
8 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Is this TV series even notable?
|
| Streels of Urtah |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Streels of Urtah
|
| List of characters notability? |
4 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#List of characters notability?
|
| Proposal: this page should be re-marked as a failed guideline |
16 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Proposal: this page should be re-marked as a failed guideline
|
| Deletion of articles about fiction |
110 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 59#Deletion of articles about fiction
|
| Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Television#Cleanup of very bad character articles |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)/Archive 58#Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Television#Cleanup of very bad character articles
|
| More restrictions on List of fictional elements |
14 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)#More restrictions on List of fictional elements
|
| Wikipedia:Comic book notability guidelines / WP:NCOMIC |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)#Wikipedia:Comic book notability guidelines / WP:NCOMIC
|
| RfC on whether and how to cover J. K. Rowling's trans-related views in the lead of her article |
3 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)#RfC on whether and how to cover J. K. Rowling's trans-related views in the lead of her article
|
| Adapted characters |
1 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)#Adapted characters
|
| Significant coverage about merchandise |
2 |
Wikipedia talk:Notability (fiction)#Significant coverage about merchandise
|
