Wikipedia

Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/July 2021 Backlog Drive/Participants/Doric Loon

< Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation‎ | July 2021 Backlog Drive‎ | Participants
  1. D (bio) Draft:Joe Barbagallo (40 days)
    Pass agree, nowhere near notable enough based on the sources cited. --DoubleGrazing (talk) 11:24, 18 July 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  2. A Neela Vaswani (25 days)
  3. A Stephen A. Miller (128 days)
  4. A Powermetrics model (92 days)
  5. A Lorenzo Córdova Vianello (79 days)
  6. D (bio) Chandler Davidson (50 days)
  7. D (mergeto) Draft:Algorand (blockchain platform) (36 days)
    Pass a good catch with the slightly different disambiguation. -2pou (talk) 20:52, 15 July 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  8. D (bio) Draft:Jon Belsher 13 days
  9. A Religion and Gun Practice (88 days)
    Pass Bogger (talk) 06:46, 4 August 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  10. A Jazz Thornton (96 days)
    Fail Notable, but (ignoring false positives) copyvios report shows a number of phrases that should have been paraphrased. Bogger (talk) 06:46, 4 August 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  11. R (n) Draft:ADVFN (27 days)
  12. R (n) Draft:GaleForce (roller coaster) (147 days)
  13. D (v, music) Draft:LEYA (band) (148 days)
  14. A 17th Lux Style Awards (0 days)
  15. D (prof) Draft:Bart Koet (0 days)
  16. D () Draft:Melvin Wulf (145 days)
    Pass Bogger (talk) 06:46, 4 August 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  17. D (bio) Draft:B. M. Balakrishna (45 days)
  18. D (bio) Draft:Katja Bednařik Sudec (0 days)
  19. A Scotland's Home of the Year (149 days)
  20. D (v) Draft:Nikon of Jerusalem (138 days)
    Pass Would disagree with the comment that academic sources necessarily should be in English. (Open to correction, but) If the sources are reputable, the language is immaterial. Bogger (talk) 06:46, 4 August 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  21. A European Centre of Excellence for Civilian Crisis Management (80 days)
  22. A EU initiatives against illegal maritime activites in the Gulf of Guinea (39 days)
  23. R (n) Draft:Duy Long Nguyen (0 days)
  24. R (n) Draft:Olivia Stambouliah (8 days)
  25. D (v, nn) Draft:Australian Christian College – Launceston (59 days)
    Pass Thorough comment on shortcomings of the draft Bogger (talk) 06:46, 4 August 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  26. A Anna Moir Rennie (8 days)
    Pass FiddleTimtrent FaddleTalk to me 16:24, 17 July 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  27. A Arooj Aftab (66 days)
  28. D (nn) Draft:Skydive Lodi Parachute Center (79 days)
  29. A Critical juncture theory (145 days)
  30. D (v) Draft:John Sedgwick (author) (129 days)
  31. A Pasquale De Bonis (136 days)
  32. D (adv) Draft:Lisbon Heritage Hotels (135 days)
  33. R (n) Draft:Austin Keen (135 days)
  34. A Destination Earth (European Union) (136 days)
  35. R (n) Draft:Steve Covino (radio) (125 days)
  36. A Clario Tech (107 days)
  37. R (n) Draft:Trevor Henderson (126 days)
  38. R (e) Draft:SuperCarlinBrothers (135 days)
  39. R (e) Draft:Mercku (34 days)
  40. A Eliza Hayley (54 days)
  41. D (v, bio) Draft:Sean Lìonadh (49 days)
  42. D (v) Draft:A Lady in Paris (18 days)
  43. D (v) Draft:Villem Lüüs (119 days)
  44. D (v) Draft:Norwegian Directorate of Immigration (76 days)
  45. D (mergeto) Draft:Rose Castle (Norway) (51 days)
  46. A David Millar (civil servant) (89 days)
  47. D (v, nn) Draft:Dracula (color scheme) (112 days)
    Pass. Very difficult case, but a good decision. Devonian Wombat (talk) 23:29, 20 July 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  48. D (v) Draft:Chapel of Our Lady Restoration (64 days)
  49. A Butler & Wilson (120 days)
    Pass Tricky one, the sources are barely enough to establish notability, but all the same I think the right call was made on a borderline case. --DoubleGrazing (talk) 11:43, 18 July 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  50. D (v) Draft:Ari Alexander Ergis Magnússon (43 days)
  51. D (nn) Draft:Sleady Castle (37 days)
  52. A Tenma (musician) (45 days)
  53. D (v) Draft:Sashai (4 days)
  54. D (v) Draft:Todor Rupić (76 days)
  55. D (v) Draft:Seventh Day Baptist World Federation (56 days)
  56. D (v) Draft:Seth Frotman (52 days)
  57. A Kenny Golde (writer and director) (111 days)
  58. R (n) Draft:Antstream Arcade (20 days)
    Fail I understand why this was rejected, but I would have declined this. It's promotional, lacks some references, notability is borderline at best, and there are layout etc. issues, so it's nowhere near ready for publishing. But could it be developed into something worthwhile? Probably. (Although that said, it has been declined twice already, and it's only got this far, so might need another 17 reviews before it's finally ready!) --DoubleGrazing (talk) 11:08, 18 July 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  59. D (v) Draft:Embassy of Bolivia, Paris (0 days)
  60. D (music) Draft:Jury Everhartz (96 days)
  61. D (prof) Draft:Wolfgang Tschacher (89 days)
  62. A Claire Bidwell Smith (123 days)
  63. D (bio) Draft:Kuldeep Raghav (122 days)
  64. D (v) Draft:John Kador (67 days)
  65. D (v) Draft:Kings Daughters (116 days)
  66. R (e) Draft:Eric Decker (disambiguation) (0 days)
  67. D (v) Draft:Gotham City (blog) (140 days)
  68. D (music) Draft:Isabelle Stern (99 days)
  69. D (v) Draft:Fleur de Son Classics (84 days)
  70. A Orsola de Castro (121 days)
  71. A IDare (0 days)
  72. A LGFG Fashion House (0 days)
    Fail. None of the references meet the criteria for establishing notability as per WP:NCORP, most references discuss the CEO not the company or discuss an event involving a lawsuit. HighKing++ 12:48, 3 August 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  73. A Springboard injunction (108 days)
  74. D (nn) Draft:Bernovich (117 days)
  75. A Shinobu (band) (118 days)
  76. D (nn) Draft:Extramural English (18 days)
  77. D (v) Draft:Suitor Armor (40 days)
  78. D (adv) Draft:Linda Waite (27 days)
  79. D (v, context) Draft:George William Gage (76 days)
  80. D (bio) Draft:Jay Heinrichs (49 days)
  81. R (n) Draft:Sinatra: Behind the Legend (75 days)
  82. D (nn) Draft:Fluorescent Chemosensors for Ion and Molecule Recognition (50 days)
  83. D (nn, context) Draft:Reuben Gauci (diplomat) (0 days)
  84. A Canadian Federation of Library Associations (16 days)
  85. A Zimbabwe Library Association (49 days)
  86. D (nn) Draft:Gas Station Carnivals (1 day)
  87. D (nn) Draft:The Luminous Fairies and Mothra (1 day)
  88. A Joseph Rogers (neuroscientist) (83 days)
  89. D (nn) Draft:Bartosz Jastrzębski (112 days)
  90. D (v, context) Draft:Ishmael ben Koraiah ben Daliah (11 days)
  91. A Salman Eliyahu (103 days)
  92. A COPIM (5 days)
  93. A Sistine Chapel of Football (1 day)
  94. D (nn, context) Draft:Zajdel Park (0 days)
  95. D (nn) Draft:Gadi Fraiman (1 day)
  96. A Animal Cracker Conspiracy Puppet Company (1 day)
  97. D (context, adv) Draft:Saatchi Yates (8 days)
  98. D (context) Draft:Ravi Zupa (3 days)
  99. D (v, context) Draft:Aqua Sport Sea Skimmer (4 days)
  100. A Dignity Taking (20 days)
    Pass. Very close, but there are just enough non-Bernadette Atauhene citations. Devonian Wombat (talk) 00:10, 24 July 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  101. D (v, nn) Draft:Vassilis Papatheodorou (120 days)
  102. A Robert Castagnon (96 days)
  103. D (v, nn) Draft:UNCG MFA Program (82 days)
  104. D (nn) Draft:Berlin music video awards (101 days)
  105. D (v, adv) Draft:Spacesmith (90 days)
  106. A Legal coaching (99 days)
  107. D (nn) Draft:Deity Microphones (63 days)
  108. D (context) Draft:Atlantic Sapphire (48 days)
  109. D (context) Draft:Selgannah (38 days)
  110. D (context) Draft:Scotcash (68 days)
  111. D (nn) Draft:St. Xenia Sisterhood (28 days)
  112. D (nn) Draft:Mario Saeed (44 days)
  113. D (nn) Draft:Ioannis Koskinas (100 days)
  114. A Rome Med - Mediterranean Dialogues (43 days)
  115. D (v) Draft:RIOTSports (84 days)
  116. A The John H. Jackson Moot Court Competition (76 days)
  117. D (nn) Draft:Leaders of a Beautiful Struggle (24 days)
  118. D (context) Draft:Monument Fire (42 days)
  119. D (v) Draft:Brink Literacy Project (34 days)
  120. D (adv) Draft:Samanea Phnom Penh Market (51 days)
  121. D (nn) Draft:Rick Brennan (27 days)
  122. D (v) Draft:Medal of the Order of Merit of Councilor Thomaz Coelho (20 days)
  123. D (adv) Draft:Happy Dad (0 days)
  124. A Vintage Photo Festival (23 days)
  125. A Mardi Paws (13 days)
  126. D (v) Draft:World Hunger Day (43 days)
  127. A Cremades & Calvo-Sotelo (68 days)
  128. D (v) Draft:Secular Institute of Schoenstatt Fathers (8 days)
  129. A Salem Assli (12 days)
  130. A Ollie and Scoops (33 days)
  131. A V1 Saliency Hypothesis (30 days)
  132. A Self-supervised learning (48 days)
  133. D (nn) Draft:David Ho chi-hoo (50 days)
  134. D (v) Draft:Brian Chater (49 days)
  135. A Nora Wilhelm (47 days)
  136. D (nn) Isidore Ostrer (45 days)
  137. D (v) Draft:Civil Liberties Australia (45 days)
  138. D (nn) Draft:Christian Sailer (42 days)
  139. A Jon Moses (47 days)
    Comment This one would be unfair to pass/fail on. It is at AfD. I sent it there, but it has been cyclically "probably good enough" and "certainly not good enough" so often that DL's acceptance is shrouded in mist. I suggest a "Benefit of several doubts Pass" if pressed on the matter. FiddleTimtrent FaddleTalk to me 21:32, 29 July 2021 (UTC)[reply]
  140. D (mergeto) Draft:Hoffmann Mineral (43 days)
  141. D (bio) Draft:Geoffrey Bartlett (35 days)
  142. D (v) Draft:Synthetik Messiah (35 days)
  143. A Ramanujan (soundtrack) (37 days)
  144. A Minsara Kanavu (soundtrack) (37 days)
  145. A Jigarthanda (soundtrack) (37 days)
  146. D (nn) Draft:Brothertiger (40 days)
  147. D (nn) First African Baptist Church (Beaufort, South Carolina) (1 day)
  148. D (v) Draft:Rodolfo Comerio (1 day)
  149. A Gerrit Wunder (0 days)
  150. D (nn) Rafał Brzoska (39 days)
    Pass correctly declined IMO at the time (although has since been accepted). --DoubleGrazing (talk) 10:20, 8 August 2021 (UTC)[reply]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:WikiProject_Articles_for_creation/July_2021_Backlog_Drive/Participants/Doric_Loon&oldid=1037729522"