Wikipedia:RfA reform 2011/Question profiles
(Redirected from Wikipedia:RfA reform (continued)/Question profiles)
 | This page in a nutshell: This is part of the project for reform of the admin selection process. It covers a detailed sortable table of questioner profiles, issues, and suggestions for discussion concerning the questions that are posed during RfA. Feel free to add other stats/percentages/analysis, etc. Other views, comments, and solutions are more than welcome on this page's talk page. |
This project is divided into sub pages in order to keep discussions focused and on track.
Read the main page first, then join a discussion on the respective page.
Please do not start a new thread or a new sub page on something that is already under discussion - see the TOC on each talk page.
Read the main page first, then join a discussion on the respective page.
Please do not start a new thread or a new sub page on something that is already under discussion - see the TOC on each talk page.
Suggestions for question reform
edit(Please remember that these are suggestions only, and because they are ideas some of them may even be contradictory. They are here mainly to stimulate discussion. )
- Three standard mandatory template questions.
- User questions are definitely optional.
- No oppose vote can be made for not answering. Neutral vote can be made for not answering.
- Questions from voters only, and possibly only from experienced editors.
- Maximum of one question per user. (addressed in RfA reform Dec 2015. Fixed at 2)
- No compound questions. (addressed in RfA reform Dec 2015. Multiple questions masquerading as one are disallowed))
- No follow-on questions.
- No discussion threads in the question section except one answer from the candidate.
- Relevant questions only (see User:Kudpung/RfA criteria#The questions they ask)
- No trick questions deliberately contrived to lead the candidate to err on the side of negativity.
- A maximum number of user questions.
Miscellaneous stats
editQuestioners
edit- Assog is an indef blocked sock.
- Dusti retired following his 3rd RfA.
- The maximum number of questions asked at an RfA in this time period was 29. (This does not count 'compound' questions).
- The average number of questions per RfA was 7.95.
- 234 users posed questions.
- 91 are admins.
- 98 users posed one question only
- 39 admins posed one question only
Editing history
edit- Of the top 22 (10+ questions), 5 had less than 4,000 edits
- The second most prolific questioner (39 questions) had 1,604 edits
- Of the 8 highest edit counts (100,000+), the average number of questions was 2.60.
- Of the 8 highest edit counts (100,000+), 5 are admins.
- Of the 8 highest edit counts (100,000+), all registered in 2006 or earlier.
- 12 users had less than 1,000 edits
- 19 users had less than 2,000 edits
- 50 users had less than 5,000 edits
- 48 users had 5,000 - 10,000 edits
- 102 users had 10,000 - 50,000 edits
Question history
edit- 98 users posed 1 question
- 31 users posed 2 questions
- 26 users posed 3 questions
- 18 users posed 4 question
- 16 users posed 5 questions
- 5 users posed 6 questions
- 4 users posed 8 questions
- 11 users posed 10 - 15 questions
- 5 users posed 11 - 20 questions
- 6 users posed 21+ questions:
- Keepscases 23 questions, 1,583 edits
- Doc Quintana 24 questions, 5,659 edits
- HJ Mitchell 24 questions, 48,994 edits. Admin
- Wifione 37 questions, 10,261 edits. Admin
- Groomtech 39 questions, 1,604 edits
- Fetchcomms 45 questions, 38,083 edits. Admin
Registration
edit- 4 users registered since 01 Jan 2011
- 30 users registered in 2010
- 35 users registered in 2009
- 29 users registered in 2008
- 34 users registered in 2005
- 13 users registered before 31 Dec 2004
Voter profiles (questioners)
edit(Research courtesy of Scottywong)
This is a list of editors who posed additional questions at RfA's between April 2010 to April 2011. Note that this sortable table was compiled by a bot, and contains errors and omissions due to the wide variety of ways different editors format their questions. This page was generated on 00:17, 9 April 2011 (UTC).
| User | Questions asked | Edit count | First edit | Admin |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pharaoh of the Wizards | 1 | 34748 | October 3, 2006 | No |
| Wingdude88 | 1 | 383 | February 21, 2010 | No |
| Soundvisions1 | 1 | 10242 | November 6, 2007 | No |
| Wireless Keyboard | 1 | 4762 | April 20, 2009 | No |
| Begoon | 7 | 6287 | September 13, 2009 | No |
| MJ94 | 2 | 4312 | May 29, 2009 | No |
| Ironholds | 2 | 62006 | April 2, 2008 | Yes |
| Rami R | 1 | 4713 | August 6, 2006 | Yes |
| Perseus8235 | 1 | 857 | February 4, 2011 | No |
| Access Denied | 7 | 8709 | May 22, 2010 | No |
| Elvey | 1 | 2747 | February 21, 2005 | No |
| ScottyBerg | 2 | 6905 | January 17, 2010 | No |
| Heymid | 1 | 9375 | January 15, 2010 | No |
| Shawn in Montreal | 2 | 47534 | October 23, 2006 | No |
| Doc Quintana | 24 | 5659 | September 16, 2009 | No |
| Soap | 1 | 18835 | January 8, 2006 | Yes |
| 2over0 | 2 | 14781 | August 3, 2005 | Yes |
| Hi878 | 1 | 9679 | November 29, 2008 | No |
| Suomi Finland 2009 | 3 | 4112 | September 8, 2009 | No |
| MC10 | 18 | 21493 | May 31, 2006 | No |
| RadManCF | 1 | 1346 | November 22, 2008 | No |
| RP459 | 5 | 7268 | February 8, 2008 | No |
| King of Hearts | 5 | 40674 | May 5, 2005 | Yes |
| Cardamon | 9 | 1962 | August 19, 2006 | No |
| Sandstein | 1 | 46671 | July 31, 2005 | Yes |
| Pilif12p | 1 | 3205 | October 20, 2008 | No |
| Látches | 1 | 3789 | August 4, 2010 | No |
| Alansohn | 3 | 358904 | May 23, 2005 | No |
| Guerillero | 1 | 5431 | November 6, 2009 | No |
| SoWhy | 4 | 29744 | March 25, 2004 | Yes |
| SoCalSuperEagle | 1 | 11152 | December 5, 2006 | No |
| MacMed | 1 | 2626 | May 12, 2009 | No |
| Diego Grez | 2 | 19148 | June 4, 2007 | No |
| UncleDouggie | 2 | 7582 | February 23, 2006 | No |
| Explicit | 3 | 64123 | July 11, 2007 | Yes |
| Avenged Eightfold | 1 | 15720 | July 28, 2007 | No |
| Gfoley4 | 2 | 24628 | February 18, 2010 | Yes |
| Collect | 3 | 15867 | June 21, 2006 | No |
| MichaelQSchmidt | 5 | 29438 | January 10, 2008 | No |
| Bwrs | 3 | 4530 | May 19, 2008 | No |
| Airplaneman | 3 | 36545 | February 20, 2008 | Yes |
| Seth Kellerman | 2 | 100 | March 12, 2010 | No |
| TParis | 2 | 4669 | September 5, 2008 | No |
| Doh5678 | 1 | 662 | January 5, 2011 | No |
| HJ Mitchell | 24 | 48994 | March 30, 2009 | Yes |
| Keepscases | 23 | 1583 | May 7, 2007 | No |
| Fastily | 15 | 37277 | January 14, 2008 | No |
| The Blade of the Northern Lights | 3 | 12344 | March 5, 2010 | No |
| Hegvald | 1 | 1282 | September 22, 2007 | No |
| Aiken drum | 1 | 7245 | September 28, 2009 | No |
| TeleComNasSprVen | 2 | 10300 | February 28, 2010 | No |
| OlEnglish | 2 | 52131 | May 26, 2008 | Yes |
| Kraftlos | 7 | 12479 | November 26, 2006 | No |
| Townlake | 14 | 2628 | March 24, 2007 | No |
| Noloop | 1 | 2793 | March 12, 2009 | No |
| BrownHairedGirl | 2 | 239417 | January 8, 2006 | Yes |
| Madrid 2020 | 1 | 307 | October 3, 2009 | No |
| Sole Soul | 1 | 8901 | November 4, 2005 | No |
| Salvio giuliano | 14 | 19043 | December 10, 2009 | Yes |
| Richwales | 7 | 5394 | March 6, 2005 | No |
| TomStar81 | 1 | 26759 | September 3, 2004 | Yes |
| Gigs | 3 | 10694 | September 25, 2005 | No |
| Minimac | 3 | 17903 | October 23, 2009 | No |
| Alpha Quadrant | 8 | 13723 | April 21, 2010 | No |
| Robofish | 3 | 41909 | January 15, 2006 | No |
| Armbrust | 16 | 67911 | December 3, 2008 | No |
| Tikiwont | 4 | 28521 | October 19, 2006 | Yes |
| Coffee | 4 | 19362 | April 6, 2007 | Yes |
| FT2 | 1 | 42835 | July 11, 2004 | Yes |
| Epeefleche | 3 | 66718 | July 7, 2006 | No |
| Lear's Fool | 5 | 9205 | July 10, 2009 | Yes |
| Baseball Watcher | 1 | 3490 | December 13, 2010 | No |
| Hasteur | 3 | 2589 | November 13, 2007 | No |
| Mattinbgn | 3 | 44395 | September 25, 2006 | Yes |
| Panyd | 5 | 6269 | October 13, 2007 | Yes |
| WikiCopter | 3 | 2938 | August 6, 2010 | No |
| Tedder | 2 | 46820 | April 28, 2005 | Yes |
| TCO | 4 | 8968 | April 8, 2007 | No |
| 7 | 1 | 32287 | December 6, 2007 | Yes |
| Ais523 | 1 | 11521 | June 7, 2006 | No |
| Legolas2186 | 1 | 26616 | June 24, 2008 | No |
| Tommy2010 | 17 | 68085 | February 20, 2010 | No |
| MWOAP | 3 | 1 | September 4, 2010 | No |
| Esteffect | 1 | 6281 | February 18, 2005 | Yes |
| Atama | 4 | 10995 | November 22, 2006 | Yes |
| Seresin | 1 | 14588 | March 3, 2007 | Yes |
| Hokeman | 1 | 9230 | February 27, 2006 | No |
| Guoguo12 | 4 | 8924 | March 14, 2008 | No |
| Phantomsteve | 12 | 26366 | May 25, 2005 | Yes |
| SlimVirgin | 1 | 113798 | November 5, 2004 | Yes |
| Lambanog | 14 | 3120 | October 4, 2009 | No |
| Dank | 2 | 41049 | December 7, 2007 | Yes |
| Dusti | 9 | 0 | Unknown | Unknown |
| Uncle G | 6 | 42602 | January 6, 2005 | Yes |
| Wayne Olajuwon | 1 | 42470 | May 29, 2010 | No |
| Nn123645 | 1 | 9963 | June 27, 2007 | No |
| Parrot of Doom | 7 | 30972 | December 25, 2005 | No |
| Ebe123 | 1 | 3266 | February 6, 2010 | No |
| Newyorkbrad | 1 | 27861 | February 25, 2006 | Yes |
| Leaky caldron | 6 | 6474 | February 23, 2006 | No |
| Morgankevinj | 4 | 1810 | July 6, 2010 | No |
| BigDom | 4 | 14771 | July 19, 2006 | Yes |
| Buggie111 | 2 | 4696 | November 30, 2009 | No |
| Sven Manguard | 10 | 13314 | September 19, 2010 | No |
| Shadowjams | 6 | 63303 | January 22, 2009 | No |
| Seddon | 1 | 6223 | November 1, 2006 | Yes |
| Snottywong | 3 | 8600 | March 17, 2007 | No |
| ErikHaugen | 1 | 6949 | March 25, 2005 | Yes |
| Chzz | 6 | 82677 | April 29, 2008 | No |
| 1234r00t | 3 | 4332 | May 4, 2010 | No |
| Nakon | 5 | 53334 | December 13, 2005 | Yes |
| WereSpielChequers | 7 | 84887 | April 9, 2007 | Yes |
| Off2riorob | 1 | 60966 | December 4, 2008 | No |
| Jc37 | 7 | 32340 | February 12, 2006 | Yes |
| CT Cooper | 2 | 22792 | March 16, 2007 | Yes |
| Scientizzle | 1 | 24438 | March 3, 2006 | Yes |
| Pedro | 1 | 20541 | July 28, 2006 | Yes |
| Decltype | 3 | 19379 | December 18, 2005 | Yes |
| Seahorseruler | 1 | 2029 | September 27, 2009 | No |
| Sandman888 | 1 | 7003 | October 30, 2009 | No |
| WFCforLife | 7 | 9338 | September 30, 2009 | No |
| White Shadows | 4 | 19156 | July 22, 2009 | No |
| True Pagan Warrior | 5 | 6565 | September 13, 2005 | No |
| Skater | 1 | 5580 | July 19, 2007 | No |
| NativeForeigner | 1 | 8304 | April 14, 2006 | Yes |
| Noraft | 4 | 5644 | October 31, 2009 | No |
| Strikerforce | 1 | 2188 | October 15, 2008 | No |
| N419BH | 1 | 7544 | January 15, 2009 | No |
| Pepper | 1 | 7875 | March 1, 2009 | No |
| Cube lurker | 3 | 9579 | August 29, 2007 | No |
| DGG | 19 | 85101 | September 5, 2006 | Yes |
| Excirial | 1 | 84467 | October 5, 2007 | Yes |
| Perseus, Son of Zeus | 1 | 3203 | July 8, 2010 | No |
| Allmightyduck | 2 | 6211 | June 15, 2007 | No |
| Connormah | 3 | 25571 | July 26, 2006 | Yes |
| Qwyrxian | 5 | 20120 | October 21, 2008 | No |
| Rje | 1 | 20239 | September 24, 2004 | Yes |
| Beeblebrox | 8 | 49141 | July 21, 2007 | Yes |
| Amatulic | 3 | 16999 | January 21, 2006 | Yes |
| Courcelles | 3 | 137907 | September 19, 2006 | Yes |
| Timotheus Canens | 4 | 26470 | December 31, 2005 | Yes |
| Orlady | 2 | 53491 | August 21, 2004 | Yes |
| Graeme Bartlett | 1 | 38166 | January 15, 2004 | Yes |
| Etineskid | 1 | 409 | June 30, 2008 | No |
| Nsk92 | 4 | 14310 | August 20, 2007 | No |
| SandyGeorgia | 1 | 127250 | February 3, 2006 | No |
| Gggh | 2 | 4192 | February 19, 2008 | No |
| Efcmagnew | 8 | 362 | December 30, 2009 | No |
| Amalthea | 3 | 24368 | September 11, 2005 | Yes |
| Zzuuzz | 1 | 81643 | August 3, 2005 | Yes |
| Ryan White Jr. | 1 | 118 | January 5, 2011 | No |
| VernoWhitney | 1 | 29275 | January 12, 2010 | Yes |
| Clovis Sangrail | 2 | 3011 | February 1, 2007 | No |
| Bwilkins | 1 | 17156 | March 13, 2006 | Yes |
| Wiooiw | 17 | 2317 | May 10, 2010 | No |
| Balloonman | 5 | 23368 | April 1, 2006 | No |
| Unionhawk | 3 | 8554 | March 21, 2007 | No |
| S h i v a (Visnu) | 2 | 6469 | October 19, 2008 | No |
| Avicennasis | 1 | 30233 | August 11, 2006 | No |
| Mr.Z-man | 1 | 26378 | December 7, 2005 | Yes |
| N5iln | 2 | 25754 | May 15, 2006 | No |
| Zalgo | 4 | 7494 | May 1, 2006 | No |
| Toddst1 | 1 | 61314 | May 2, 2007 | Yes |
| Tofutwitch11 | 9 | 5017 | September 1, 2009 | No |
| Deckiller | 1 | 32458 | July 16, 2005 | Yes |
| Hipocrite | 1 | 18810 | October 28, 2004 | No |
| Kingpin13 | 1 | 52595 | September 3, 2008 | Yes |
| Espresso Addict | 1 | 17317 | May 14, 2006 | Yes |
| Chase me ladies, I'm the Cavalry | 1 | 27180 | August 8, 2005 | Yes |
| Shirik | 3 | 15900 | December 17, 2008 | Yes |
| Peter | 1 | 10506 | August 19, 2005 | Yes |
| ArcAngel | 2 | 11809 | September 24, 2006 | No |
| Malleus Fatuorum | 4 | 101919 | June 3, 2006 | No |
| Thparkth | 1 | 3651 | May 6, 2004 | No |
| Assorg | 3 | 0 | Unknown | Unknown |
| RJaguar3 | 2 | 14666 | April 18, 2007 | No |
| Prodego | 1 | 27318 | September 23, 2005 | Yes |
| Blanchardb | 3 | 79214 | September 12, 2007 | No |
| Seraphimblade | 1 | 20551 | March 14, 2005 | Yes |
| Kudpung | 1 | 28791 | October 18, 2006 | Yes |
| Ojay123 | 1 | 1812 | July 1, 2008 | No |
| Xeno | 1 | 82651 | July 14, 2006 | Yes |
| Paul Erik | 2 | 29514 | January 14, 2007 | Yes |
| Bejinhan | 1 | 5845 | June 2, 2009 | No |
| Mike Cline | 12 | 24755 | January 3, 2007 | Yes |
| Wifione | 37 | 10261 | April 1, 2009 | Yes |
| Strange Passerby | 5 | 3678 | March 19, 2010 | No |
| Jclemens | 9 | 29466 | August 24, 2006 | Yes |
| Worm That Turned | 2 | 5787 | July 13, 2008 | No |
| Pol430 | 1 | 7507 | December 27, 2008 | No |
| The Utahraptor | 12 | 14642 | November 8, 2009 | No |
| Paralympiakos | 1 | 14613 | September 23, 2009 | No |
| Immunize | 1 | 18223 | January 7, 2010 | No |
| Vejvančický | 1 | 19592 | March 15, 2008 | Yes |
| Bad edits r dumb | 1 | 646 | September 14, 2010 | No |
| Highspeedrailguy | 1 | 685 | February 24, 2011 | No |
| Racepacket | 1 | 15107 | September 13, 2006 | No |
| 28bytes | 14 | 11403 | December 14, 2006 | No |
| Iridescent | 2 | 157588 | February 15, 2006 | Yes |
| Mono | 7 | 17068 | September 24, 2009 | No |
| StephenBuxton | 5 | 8545 | February 22, 2006 | Yes |
| Groomtech | 39 | 1604 | May 3, 2009 | No |
| My76Strat | 2 | 10533 | March 24, 2010 | No |
| Jimmy Pitt | 1 | 9263 | January 31, 2006 | No |
| Deliriousandlost | 5 | 4398 | September 12, 2009 | No |
| Hobit | 11 | 8176 | October 11, 2005 | No |
| Jusdafax | 1 | 52905 | October 8, 2007 | No |
| Rd232 | 1 | 46275 | October 27, 2004 | Yes |
| MuZemike | 5 | 56521 | May 31, 2008 | Yes |
| Wackywace | 1 | 8961 | April 10, 2010 | No |
| Casliber | 1 | 80496 | May 5, 2006 | Yes |
| Jayjg | 4 | 92913 | January 4, 2003 | Yes |
| Gimmetoo | 6 | 4252 | April 2, 2010 | No |
| NuclearWarfare | 13 | 72534 | October 30, 2007 | Yes |
| Hydroxonium | 4 | 4189 | May 19, 2010 | No |
| Boing! said Zebedee | 4 | 36677 | September 4, 2007 | Yes |
| Fly by Night | 1 | 5028 | January 20, 2010 | No |
| Rockfang | 2 | 23045 | September 24, 2007 | No |
| Likeminas | 1 | 2613 | October 3, 2007 | No |
| Beetstra | 5 | 100893 | March 19, 2006 | Yes |
| ClubOranje | 1 | 14386 | December 28, 2007 | No |
| Metropolitan90 | 5 | 25534 | May 9, 2005 | Yes |
| Kayau | 1 | 10130 | September 3, 2006 | No |
| ImperfectlyInformed | 4 | 8213 | August 16, 2007 | No |
| Shimeru | 2 | 7161 | December 18, 2004 | Yes |
| Fetchcomms | 45 | 38083 | October 2, 2009 | Yes |
| SarekOfVulcan | 8 | 30705 | March 30, 2004 | Yes |
| Frank | 1 | 16805 | May 21, 2006 | Yes |
| Andrensath | 1 | 881 | February 5, 2008 | No |
| Dlohcierekim | 5 | 44216 | March 3, 2006 | Yes |
| Amorymeltzer | 1 | 16442 | December 8, 2005 | Yes |
| Tiptoety | 1 | 41531 | May 2, 2007 | Yes |
| Secret | 1 | 9168 | September 22, 2007 | No |
| Geometry guy | 1 | 28959 | February 7, 2007 | Yes |