Wikipedia:Picture peer review/High Knob Wind Turbines at Sunset

High Knob Wind Turbines at Sunset edit

Original - The wind turbines on High Knob in the Moosic Mountains of the Pocono Mountains at sunset from Little Keen Road in Canaan Township, Pennsylvania.

This image, which I want to try for featured picture, has to be my best picture of the 10 or so tries of the wind turbines on High Knob. This image, taken on Little Keen Road (Canaan Township Road 456) in Canaan Township, is taken at sunset while walking down the one lane township road. Any comments are welcome :)

Articles this image appears in: Wind turbine, Moosic Mountains, Canaan Township, Wayne County, Pennsylvania

Creator: User:Mitchazenia

Nominated by: 3 1/2 years of Mitch 32 15:51, 30 May 2009 (UTC)[reply]

Comments

The picture itself is OK, but technical qualities are just too low. This is probably a consequence of a combination of the camera used, the conditions it was taken in, the nature of the subject, and too much downsampling. It suffers from excessive noise, substantial artifacting, and lacks any real detail anywhere, in particular on the subject itself (the wind turbines). Sorry, but this won't be an FP any time soon. As a comparison take a good look at the technical standard of this existing wind turbine FP . You could perhaps consider nominating at VPC, but I personally would consider its chances there slim as well. --jjron (talk) 14:32, 4 June 2009 (UTC)[reply]

Seconder