Wikipedia:Picture peer review/Chris Young

Chris Young, pitcher for the San Diego Padres

It is a higher quality picture than the current main image, which is a FP

It looks to be a good shot - well composed, quite interesting, at a quick glance appears good quality - but the legs of the first baseman (?) are rather unfortunately positioned! That may significantly affect its chances. I'm also not sure about that fact that an image of him is already featured, especially given that they are both action shots of him pitching (like say one was a 'portrait' shot it may be a different matter). It's not like he's a particularly significant figure (talking on a world scale; I know relatively little about American baseball and he may be huge in that), but to have two photos of him as FPs, and as best I can remember, none of any other baseball player - well it just strikes me as a little unbalanced. Perhaps if you think it's good enough, a Delist and Replace nomination would be more in order? --jjron (talk) 10:00, 19 September 2008 (UTC)[reply]