Wikipedia:Peer review/World of Music, Arts and Dance/archive1

World of Music, Arts and Dance edit

This article is one i have edited quite a lot, and I want to put it up for a featured article, any advice. Or just tell me what you think of it. Cheers JimHxn 16:14, 17 April 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Where's the article? All it is is a brief introduction and a set of pointless lists. This is not nearly ready for FAC. Start with overview, history and structure sections. It's an interesting event, and worthy of a decent Wikipedia article.--cj | talk 07:46, 18 April 2006 (UTC)[reply]
Actually, it looks like you've already nominated for FAC [1], which this article is clearly not ready for. For this stub to become an article, you'll need information on:
- Why did Peter Gabriel start WOMAD? Did it effect his career? Is he still proactive with WOMAD?
- Was it successful? (I know it initially wasn't, hense the Six of the Best concert, which is the only time EVER that Gabriel reunited with Genesis (band) for a live concert since leaving the band in 1974.
- Was WOMAD successful? Have critics discussed WOMAD, or the acts, or its influence on others?

Once this and more has been added, then you should consider fixing this up for Featured Article. But right now, more research is needed. --Ataricodfish 01:04, 19 April 2006 (UTC)[reply]