Wikipedia:Peer review/Queen (band)/archive3
Queen (band) edit
| Toolbox |
|---|
This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because I'd like to finally push this article through as a featured one. Me and the other frequent editors have been doing a lot of work on this article in the recent weeks and would like to know your thoughts on what could be improved before we enter it as a FA nominee.
Thanks, TheStig 16:39, 20 January 2010 (UTC)
A couple of mainly technical things I noticed:
- Refs 2-5, 26, 81, 82 need extra information on them, currently they're just links. Author, date etc.
- Refs 16 and 101 have been marked as dead, these need fixing
- dablinks brings up Amandla, Band Aid and Dave Stewart pointing to disambig pages, point these in the right direction.
- Alt text needed for all images though all the licensing looks great.
I'll try and do a thorough read through later, bit strapped for time but I hope that helps. CrimsonFox talk 20:54, 22 January 2010 (UTC)
- Thanks, we'll work on this. You advice is much appreciated. :) TheStig 22:09, 22 January 2010 (UTC)
If the article is heading for an FAC, the lead will probably need some expansion. Three somewhat beefed-up paragraphs seems reasonable for a major band like Queen. Also, a lead should not contain citations of its own since it's supposed to be a summary of the article. Placing one right after the the first verb seems taking it a bit too far and is quite distracting. If there are frequent disputes about changing "are" to "were", then I recommend adding a caveat as a hidden comment instead.
By just a quick scan of parts of the text, I suspect the prose might need some work. For example, there's a lot of stubby paragraphs that could probably be merged with others paragraphs or expanded. Cutting down on the list of bands and artists under "Influence" might be a good idea as well. It looks a bit like a collapsed bullet list at the moment. And you could probably lighten up the read a bit by sorting the remaining examples into (specifically stated) genres.