Wikipedia:Non-free content review/Archive 23

Archive 20Archive 21Archive 22Archive 23Archive 24Archive 25Archive 30

File:2013 Boston Marathon finish line explosion.png

File:Pac-12-Uniform-UA.png

File:Frosty paws.jpg

Energy Tower (Midland, Texas)

Question

File:Unknownpleasures.jpg

Submissions for List of Australian flags and List of New Zealand flags

File:McCotter logo.gif

File:Prince logo.svg

File:Osaka University logo.svg

File:2013 European Youth Winter Olympic Festival logo.png

File:Gnnsjb001.jpg

Screenshots of websites

excerpt from famous music review

File:WWE Undisputed Championship Belt.jpg

File:Scrabble Showdown (title card).jpg

{{archive top}} In the article Scrabble. The NFUR states "The image is used for identification and clarification in the context of critical commentary of the work from which the screenshot is taken. It makes a significant contribution to the user's understanding of the article, which could not practically be conveyed by words alone. Commentary in the article about the screenshot itself: Use for this purpose does not compete with the purposes of the original work, a single frame, being of comparatively low commercial value." The section of Scrabble (Scrabble#Television game show versions) where the image appears does not have such critical commentary; the image appears to merely show the logo decoratively, in violation of WP:NFCC #8. RJaguar3 | u | t 19:21, 30 March 2013 (UTC)

If the show had its own article (assuming notability) it might be reasonable there. But the show doesn't appear to be notable, and just to show its title card on a larger subject is inappropriate. Agree it fails NFCC#8. --MASEM (t) 19:47, 30 March 2013 (UTC)
The show does have its own article at Scrabble Showdown for which the use of the image of the nonfree titlecard falls within WP:NFCC, which is why I went here and not to WP:FFD. RJaguar3 | u | t 02:53, 31 March 2013 (UTC)
Then its use on the main Scrabble game is completely out of NFCC allowance. --MASEM (t) 03:30, 31 March 2013 (UTC)
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

Illmatic and the Source excerpt image

File:Nighthawks.jpg

File:TheSprektors.jpg

File:New York Rangers.svg

File:GG Allin sshot.jpg

File:Adaptations of Les Misérables

File:Djarum Indonesia Super League.png

File:OasisTowerRender.jpg

File:Atlantic Coast Conference logo.png

File:Botola vf.PNG

File:Ivy League logo.svg

File:LourdesGrayWolves.png

File:PaladinsLogo.svg

File:2012iccworldt20.png

File:UFL-Uniform-LV.png

File:Logo World Squash Federation.jpg

File:NFL(Australia).png

File:UFL-Uniform-OMA.png

File:NBL Logo 2009-2010.png

Papua New Guinea (song)

File:Ottawa LPP Stadium Proposal.JPG

Linux gaming images

File:UMassLogo9302.gif

File:Samuelwilderking.jpg

File:YBMSeoulRecords.jpg

File:Ioannina radio deejay logo.jpg

File:Four Square logo 2013.jpg

File:Michael Hill Jeweller logo 2013.jpg

File:Piraeus Bank New Logo.gif

File:Vibration three.jpg

File:Lemouv logo.png