Wikipedia:Kvetch
 | This page is currently inactive and is retained for historical reference. Either the page is no longer relevant or consensus on its purpose has become unclear. To revive discussion, seek broader input via a forum such as the village pump. |
Kvetch is the name of a project to add a "report an issue" feature to articles.
Implementation considerations edit
- Link placement
- probably makes most sense to put the link in the sidebar
- toolbox section? interaction section?
- another option is a page tab at the top of the page (more noticeable)
- Underlying code
- at least as a start, should be implemented in JavaScript; can be moved to a MediaWiki extension later if appropriate
- use jQuery goodness
- Page exclusion
- needs a sane, scaleable system to exclude certain articles
- hidden category?
- specific template
- hit the API or check the HTML of the rendered page?
Coverage edit
Types of issues that users could report with this tool:
- copyright violations
- typos/fact issues/etc.
- BLP issues
- broken templates
- vandalism
- in Spanish Wikipedia a lot of readers report vandalism using this tool because they don't know how to revert
- mediawiki bugs (part is affecting only unlogged editors)
- {{db}} quality pages missed on new page patrol
Additional coverage edit
- requests for article creation/expansion/deletion
- help desk issues
- "my car is broken" reports
- YA place for vandalism (but is also good as vandalism is not visible for readers)
Interaction edit
- user notices an issue
- user clicks link/button/tab to report issue
- encourage user to fix problems themselves; be bold!
- show links to privacy policy and terms of use (her report and IP are going to be public and free licensed)
- do not add phone number or e-mail
- user can report issue
- issue gets sent to separate page (on plwiki it is pl:wp:ZB)
Processing edit
- for more serious issues, perhaps send e-mail to volunteer response team?
- confusing?
- append section on a noticeboard?