Wikipedia:Featured list removal candidates/List of Indian Nobel laureates/archive1

List of Indian Nobel laureates

List of Indian Nobel laureates (edit | talk | history | protect | delete | links | watch | logs | views)

• Featured list candidates/List of Indian Nobel laureates/archive2

• Featured list removal candidates/List of Indian Nobel laureates/archive1

Notified: JB Hoang Tam, Kalisidina, The Herald, IWikiProject India, WikiProject Awards

I am nominating this for featured list removal because it does not fulfill the featured list criteria anymore. I used this page as inspiration for my FL candidate List of Swiss Nobel laureates, but found that the list in its current status has several issues:

• Sourcing
  • The column "Family" is completely unreferenced
  • For many entries, the column "field" is unreferenced
  • Statements on citizenship at the time of the award are unsourced
• Accessibility
  • Table sorting by name, date of birth or death date does not work. Unclear why "Field" or "Image" should be sortable columns
  • Uses column headers in the middle of the table MOS:COLHEAD
  • No alt text in images
• Prose
  • Excessive use of MOS:CAPS
  • Some entries have an asterisk that is never explained
  • The table section "Expatriates" has different content than the rest of the table, the headers are misleading
• Original research
  • Entries such as Mohammad Hosain Khan (probably Mohammad Habib (1895–1971)) – "probably" according to whom?

The list needs major work to be brought (again) to standard. Broc (talk) 12:42, 2 July 2024 (UTC)