Wikipedia

Wikipedia:Featured list candidates/List of winners of the Boston Marathon/archive1

< Wikipedia:Featured list candidates‎ | List of winners of the Boston Marathon

List of winners of the Boston Marathon edit

The following is an archived discussion of a featured list nomination. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the article's talk page. No further edits should be made to this page. The closing editor's comments were: 20 days, 4 support, 2 oppose. Many unanswered concerns are left. Fail. Crzycheetah 01:15, 4 August 2007 (UTC)[reply]
10 Days Ends July 25
Current Opinion User
Support Circeus
Oppose Rmhermen
Support TonyTheTiger
Support WillMak050389
Support LaraLove

Partial self-nom, though most of the grunt work was done by previous editors. A couple questions for reviewers to answer:

  • is the lead long enough?
  • is it OK to have countries overlinked when using the county/flag template rather than just the flagicon template?
Geraldk 23:50, 15 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
    • I don't mind the countries being overlinked as long as the runners aren't underlinked. IMO I shouldn't have to hunt for a link to click, especially lower in the list. --Golbez 13:34, 16 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
      •   Done Re-linked the runners. What about the states?
        • To further justify my remarks - in a list where a large number of people aren't linked, having someone blacklinked because they're already listed earlier makes no sense; I might have no clue they're linked earlier if they're surrounded by people who don't have articles. I don't mind delinking the repeated states. --Golbez 01:28, 17 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
    • Image:Gareau.jpg, Image:Boston1979.jpg, and Image:Ronald J. MacDonald.jpg are fair use images but do not have fair use rationale to be used in this article. If you feel they are necessary images for the article, add fair use rationale for this article on their image pages. Without this, I cannot support promoting this list. --WillMak050389 16:05, 16 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
      •   Done Dropped the problematic images, added one good one from Commons. Geraldk 22:08, 16 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • neutral
    • Drop the links from the "year" columns. (unless you can link to an article about that year's marathon)
    • The lead could certainly be made more useful: Who won the most times? Set the most records? Who were the first winners outside North America? What are the by-country statistics? etc. (although that could be made into a separate section before the listings.)
    • Maybe add a "synopsis" table combining all four categories with only the winner and time?
    • There's an extraneous parenthesis in the 1981 men's wheelchair entry.
  • Circeus 17:57, 16 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
    • Fixed the last one. --Golbez 21:01, 16 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
    • Expanded lead. Let me know if it works. Added table showing number of victories by nationality. I'm not sure I like the idea of a synopsis table, both because it would be very repetitive (adding a lot of length for only a little extra reader convenience) and because such a table would have 70-some years with just a men's winner and blank cells for the other three divisions. But if there's consensus on that, I'll add it. Geraldk 01:17, 17 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
      • Good point. Support. Really like the nationalities table. New lead is fine for me. Circeus 21:06, 18 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Oppose: There is something odd about the "course record" notations. If the course wasn't standardized before 1924 (as lead text claims), why are some times indicated as course records? Why after 1924 does Clarence DeMar set course records that are slower than his previous times? Rmhermen 02:40, 17 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
Good questions. I think the lead makes clear that the BAA recognizes course records for alternate lengths of the race, but I added another sentence to the lead to clarify some of these variances - esp. why DeMar is listed with a 1927 course record that's 15 minutes slower than Johnny Miles' 1926 course record. Geraldk 10:43, 17 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Support This is an important and well done list. --TonyTheTiger (t/c/bio/tcfkaWCDbwincowtchatlotpsoplrttaDCLaM) 04:06, 20 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Support All faults I have seen are now fixed. Featured material for me. --WillMak050389 04:14, 20 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Comment Weak Oppose. I find that putting the state name next to the american flag, while all other countries have their names displayed next to their flags, too US-centric (even if it's a Boston event). It would be better if the "United States" is displayed next to the flag and the state in abbreviation format (eg: United States (MA) or United States,MA). And one more thing. I find it odd that this list is displayed in reverse chronological order. Isn't it common practice to make it the other way round? Anyway great list. CG 19:00, 29 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Support - However, I would like to comment that I don't agree with the underlinking of states if everything else is going to be consistently linked. I think it would look better to just have it all consistently linked. Otherwise, very good work. Lara♥Love 15:24, 30 July 2007 (UTC)[reply]
  • Comment - Please add a note in the intro or something to explain what the Military Relay marathon was in 1918. --Golbez 06:39, 2 August 2007 (UTC)[reply]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Featured_list_candidates/List_of_winners_of_the_Boston_Marathon/archive1&oldid=1138487848"