Wikipedia:Featured list candidates/List of Dexter episodes/archive2

The following is an archived discussion of a featured list nomination. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the article's talk page or in Wikipedia talk:Featured list candidates. No further edits should be made to this page.

The list was not promoted by Scorpion0422 20:38, 9 June 2009 [1].

List of Dexter episodes

Nominator(s): --Music26/11, 97198 (talk), Nergaal (talk)

Featured list removal candidates/List of Dexter episodes/archive1

I am nominating this for featured list because I think it meets all of the criteria, all the issues of its previous FLc have been adressed. 97198 and Nergaal helped a lot with expanding the article. Thank you very much.--Music26/11 14:10, 25 May 2009 (UTC)[reply]

Oppose from Dabomb87 (talk · contribs) The prose isn't bad, but it needs a final copy-edit for polish. Please find someone uninvolved. I would ordinarily help out, but I'm swamped with requests already as well as real-life commitments.

"Dexter is an American television series which is broadcast on premium cable channel Showtime in the United States."-->Dexter is an American television series that is broadcast on the premium cable channel Showtime in the United States.
"Dexter was first broadcast on October 1, 2006, and is based on the novel Darkly Dreaming Dexter by Jeff Lindsay"-->First broadcast on October 1, 2006, Dexter [it?] is based on the novel Darkly Dreaming Dexter by Jeff Lindsay
"... didn't see the opportunity in the second book" Not sure what purpose the ellipses serve here.
"The series has received positive critical acclaim throughout its run." The last three words are probably unnecessary.
"The pilot episode attracted over a million viewers, giving Showtime its highest ratings" Link "pilot" and "ratings" to relevant articles, please.
"Three seasons, each of twelve episodes, have been broadcast in the United States, while the fourth and fifth seasons have also been confirmed."-->Three seasons, each comprising twelve episodes, have been broadcast in the United States. The fourth and fifth seasons have been confirmed [confirmed for what?].
"The first season of Dexter premiered on October 1, 2006,[5] and ended on December 17, 2006." Why not "The first season of Dexter aired from October 1, 2006 to December 17, 2006."?
"and Dexter's girlfriend, Rita Bennett (Julie Benz), wants to take their relationship to the next level." Too loose. Suggest "and Dexter's girlfriend, Rita Bennett (Julie Benz), wants to their relationship to be more intimate." (or something similar)
"Meanwhile" Nine times out of ten, this word is idle; kill it whenever possible.
Spell out and link abbreviations such as "Lt." and "Sgt." on their first appearance. Dabomb87 (talk) 00:35, 31 May 2009 (UTC)[reply]

All the comments except the meanwhile one have been addressed. Isn't meanwhile a good linker, and necessary to add flow to the paragraph? Nergaal (talk) 04:16, 3 June 2009 (UTC)[reply]

Reduced the instances of meanwhile to about 1/3. n

Review by Truco (talk · contribs)

General

Fix the 3 dab links

done. n

Lead

'First broadcast on October 1, 2006, the series is based on the novel Darkly Dreaming Dexter by Jeff Lindsay.' -- The way the sentence starts is incorrect, as is the way it transitions to the other topic. It should be something more like The series is based on the novel Darkly Dreaming Dexter by Jeff Lindsay, and was first broadcast on October 1, 2006.

it was initially something very similar, but the previous reviewer requested the present version. n

Yeah, but when you read it, it sounds very awkward. The latter version would read better and retain the same idea.--Tru co 15:46, 6 June 2009 (UTC)[reply]

Reworded as proposed.--Music26/11 13:14, 7 June 2009 (UTC)[reply]

Truco's suggestion sounds better. Dabomb87 (talk) 13:28, 7 June 2009 (UTC)[reply]

Season 1

'Meanwhile Debra discovers the refrigerated truck in which the Ice Truck Killer dismembers his victims, and is promoted by her superior, Lieutenant Maria LaGuerta (Lauren Vélez), to the Homicide Department.' -- Comma after 'Meanwhile'
Try to use phrases like 'During this time' instead of repeating 'Meanwhile' over and over, it gets real repetitive and boring to read.

reduced the usage. n

Season 2

'Meanwhile, Debra struggles to recover after escaping an attempt on her life, and Rita sends Dexter to Narcotics Anonymous meetings when she suspects that he has an addiction.' -- 'after escaping an attempt on her life' doesn't really make sense to me, elaborate please?
'He starts attending NA meetings, while still trying to evade Doakes' constant surveillance.' -- You need to have Narcotics Anonymous (NA) <<<formatted like that in its first occurrence in order to use the acronym.
'A copycat killer mimics and claims to be inspired by the Bay Harbor Butcher, whom the police must find otherwise the FBI will take over the case completely.' -- 1)mock would sound so much better than 'copycat' 2)Comma before/after 'otherwise'

Season 3

'Miguel's brother, Ramon (Jason Manuel Olazabal), criticizes the police for having not found his brother's killer, and when Miguel suggests telling Dexter the truth, Dexter must prove that Ramon cannot be trusted.' 'found' should be finding
'Debra and Quinn are assigned to the case of a man who was killed by his fiancée. Angel becomes entangled in a sting operation when he picks up a prostitute who is really a Vice Detective Barbara Gianna (Kristin Dattilo). ' -- Either remove the 'a' before 'Vice Detective' or add a colon after it
'Dexter struggles to distance himself from Miguel, who will be his best man at Dexter's wedding, and starts plotting to kill him.' -- 'at Dexter's wedding' should be at his wedding

References

What makes comingsoon.net reliable?--Tru co 23:25, 4 June 2009 (UTC)[reply]

Fixed all the comments and changed the reference to ign.com. Nergaal (talk) 01:32, 5 June 2009 (UTC)[reply]

Oppose

Reference dates should be consistent per MoS, currently I see am mix of Month DD, YYYY and ISO. Make them all the same (my preference is the former).
"do not follow the respective novels", but you only mention one respective novel in the following sentence. I think it needs rewording and suggest giving the names of the novels before refering to them as "respective novels", alternatively you could just say "do not follow the other novels in the series".
"The series has received positive critical acclaim throughout its run." I just don't see this as neutral. Sounds like something a fan would say. Either balance with negative reviews (which you even ref in the list]) or remove.
"CBS began to broadcast Dexter on February 17, 2008." is it just showing re-runs and Showtime still airs the episodes first? If so surely this is only as notable as airing on CTV Television Network in Canada.
"giving the channel its highest ratings in nearly two years" is potentially misleading, the ref says "gave Showtime its highest series rating in nearly two years"
Contistency, for season one you use "Season One" but in season two it is "season two" and in season three it is "Season Three". Be consistent, and I believe the lower case version is correct.
Summaries need copyediting, I found the following issues in only two episode summaries:
- "38 days have passed since the previous season's finale." MOSNUM point 4, don't start sentences with numbers
- "With his first opportunity, though, he finds himself unable to kill gang leader Little Chino (Matthew Willig)." Doakes was the subject of the previous sentence, I may be wrong, but I think your talking about Dexter in this sentence so "he" doesn't suffice.
- "Both Dexter and the Miami Police Department hunting for Little Chino" are hunting?
- "Dexter and Debra struggle to overcome their experiences with Brian; Dexter is haunted by his memory and Debra feels unsafe when her memories of Brian resurface" isn't Brain dead, experiences with Brian sounds like it is in the present. Also the "memory/memories" are unclear, what is the memory exactly, guessing it is about killing Brian but should be explicit. In fact something like "Both struggle to overcome memories of the encounter with Brian that lead to his death", not sure if that is right as I've never watched the show but hopefully you get the gist.
- "LaGuerta's new boss, Lieutenant Esmee Pascal, played by Judith Scott, is grateful when she ignores the fact that Pascal is using department resources to research her fiancé." Um isn't Pascal the subject of the sentence. How can Pascal be ignoring Pascal?

Rambo's Revenge (talk) 17:56, 8 June 2009 (UTC)[reply]

The above discussion is preserved as an archive. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this page.