Wikipedia:Featured and good topic candidates/Characters of Halo/addition1

Characters of Halo (1st supplementary nomination)

edit

This topic is already featured. It is being re-nominated to add additional items. See Wikipedia talk:Featured topics/Characters of Halo for discussions of the topic's previous nominations. The additional items are:

  1.   Nicole (Dead or Alive)
Main page Articles
  Characters of Halo   Master Chief (Halo) -   Cortana -   Arbiter (Halo) -   Gravemind -   Nicole (Dead or Alive)

I have run this by David Fuchs, who nominated the original topic, and he supports this addition. If you would look back to the original nomination for this topic, you'll see there was some controversy over the inclusion of Nicole (Dead or Alive) in the topic. Proponents of this article's inclusion (myself included) pointed to the fact that excluding the article may constitute an obvious and notable gap, thus violating criterion 1.d) However, opponents pointed to the fact that this article was not at the time properly integrated with the other articles (specifically Characters of Halo and Template:Halo characters), thus violating criterion 1.c), and hence the result of the nomination was that it passed, but without the Nicole article.

Since then, I have integrated the Nicole article with the others, where it has sat for over a month now, and feel that this should remove any objections to its inclusion here. On the other hand, I think that excluding the article would still violate criterion 1.d) (now more than ever). While Nicole has not appeared in any media outside Dead or Alive 4, she is still regarded as an in-continuity character of the Halo Universe - rst20xx (talk) 20:09, 4 August 2008 (UTC)[reply]