| Closure review |
Start date |
Discussion reviewed |
Diff of close |
Result
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive267#Close review please
|
2 January 2015
|
Template talk:Infobox person/Archive 25#RfC: Proposed addition of pronunciations to infobox person
|
[33]
|
Endorsed
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive268#Closure Review Request at Talk: Ayurveda#Objection to improper closure
|
11 January 2015
|
Talk:Ayurveda/Archive 9#Should this article be categorized as "pseudoscience"?
|
[34]
|
No consensus to overturn
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive270#Review of Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2015 January 8#Kirby Delauter and Draft:Kirby Delauter
|
18 January 2015
|
Wikipedia:Deletion review/Log/2015 January 8#Kirby Delauter
|
[35]
|
Reinstating the salting is not an enforceable provision of the DRV close
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Review of the Closing for a WP:RFC for America: Imagine the World Without Her
|
24 January 2015
|
Talk:America: Imagine the World Without Her/Archive 7#RfC: Is Breitbart.com a reliable source for the opinion of Ben Shapiro
|
[36]
|
Endorsed
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive268#Review Closure of debate : Proposed Hypothesis/Theory as fact
|
27 January 2015
|
Wikipedia:Fringe theories/Noticeboard/Archive 45#Proposed Hypothesis/Theory as fact
|
[37]
|
Overturned as premature
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive268#Reviewing RfC closure : Battle of Chawinda
|
28 January 2015
|
Talk:Battle of Chawinda/Archive 1#DID the battle lead to Major Pakistani victory?
|
[38]
|
Endorsed
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Requesting review of close of RfC at Griffin article
|
4 February 2015
|
Talk:G. Edward Griffin/Archive 7#RfC: "conspiracy theorist" in first sentence
|
[39]
|
No consensus to overturn, further discussion recommended
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Request for review of closure at AN/I
|
8 February 2015
|
Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive872#Conduct of J Doug McLean
|
[40]
|
Result
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive270#Review of non-admin closure at Manual of Style/Icons
|
11 February 2015
|
Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Icons/Archive 14#Formula 1
|
[41]
|
No consensus to overturn
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Closure review: Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/RfC to physically restrict access to the Helper Script
|
18 February 2015
|
Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/RfC to physically restrict access to the Helper Script
|
[42]
|
Overturned
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Requesting review of close of RfC at Template talk:Infobox officeholder#RfC Congressmen's tenures in infobox
|
27 February 2015
|
Template talk:Infobox officeholder/Archive 19#RfC Congressmen's tenures in infobox
|
[43]
|
Withdrawn
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive270#Closure Review Request at MOS page
|
5 March 2015
|
Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Biographies/2015 archive#RfC: Comma or no comma before Jr. and Sr.
|
[44]
|
No consensus to overturn
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Review request for non-admin closure at WT:NCF
|
10 March 2015
|
Wikipedia talk:Naming conventions (films)/Archive 2#RFC: Series subject as a name
|
[45]
|
Endorsed
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive269#Closure review
|
18 March 2015
|
Wikipedia talk:Protection policy/Archive 15#Own userspace pages protection policy
|
[46]
|
Rationale amended
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive271#Request for review of close at Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Capital letters#Request for comment - Capitalise universe
|
24 April 2015
|
Wikipedia talk:Manual of Style/Capital letters/Archive 18#Request for comment - Capitalise universe
|
[47]
|
No consensus to overturn
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive271#Request for review of RfC closed at Talk:Project for the New American Century
|
5 May 2015
|
Talk:Project for the New American Century/Archive 5#RfC
|
[48]
|
No consensus to overturn
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive271#Review non-admin close of RFC
|
20 May 2015
|
Wikipedia talk:Conflict of interest/Archive 20#RfC on COI for alt-med practitioners
|
[49]
|
Endorsed
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive272#RFC Review at Talk:Ayurveda/Archive 9
|
4 June 2015
|
Talk:Ayurveda/Archive 9#Should this article be categorized as "pseudoscience"?
|
[50]
|
RfC close retracted due to extensive sockpuppetry; new RfC started
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive272#RFC closure challenge
|
19 June 2015
|
Talk:Dennis Hastert/Archive 1#RfC: Should the lead mention that there were allegations of sexual abuse?
|
[51]
|
Overturned
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive272#Where is Poland?
|
23 June 2015
|
Talk:Poland/Archive 6#RfC: Eastern vs. Central Europe
|
[52]
|
Closer self-reverted
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive273#Closure Review
|
26 June 2015
|
Talk:Grand Theft Auto V/Archive 3#Merger proposal
|
[53]
|
Overturned to merge
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive891#RFC Close for Ayurveda
|
7 July 2015
|
Talk:Ayurveda/Archive 12#Category:Pseudoscience
|
[54]
|
RfC close reverted and RfC reclosed by uninvolved admin
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive274#RfC closure review: Talk:Kosovo#Request for comment
|
10 August 2015
|
Talk:Kosovo/Archive 31#Request for comment
|
[55]
|
Endorsed
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive274#RfC closure challenge: Template talk:Cite doi#RfC: Should Template:cite doi cease creating a separate subpage for each DOI?
|
8 September 2015
|
Template talk:Cite doi/Archive 1#RfC: Should Template:cite doi cease creating a separate subpage for each DOI?
|
[56]
|
Newer RfC will decide the matter
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive274#Request closure review for RfC at Monsanto Legal Cases
|
22 September 2015
|
Talk:Monsanto legal cases/Archive 3#RfC: Should this article mention current lawsuits by U.S. cities against Monsanto?
|
[57]
|
Withdrawn
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive275#Request for RFC close review
|
17 October 2015
|
Talk:Serbs of Croatia/Archive 9#Serbs as "constitutive" nation in Socialist Republic of Croatia
|
[58]
|
Closure left as is
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive276#Challenge closure on Climate change denial talk page
|
10 November 2015
|
Talk:Climate change denial/Archive 31#Redirects to this page
|
[59]
|
Third closing statement by an uninvolved admin added that does not change the result
|
| Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Archive277#Closure review at Talk:Martha Jefferson
|
3 December 2015
|
Talk:Martha Jefferson#Restored article
|
[60]
|
Endorsed
|
| Closure review |
Start date |
Discussion reviewed |
Diff of close |
Result
|
