Wikipedia:2013 main page redesign proposal/Draft RFC/1

{{rfc|prop}} (RFC notice)

The main page hasn't been redesigned since 2006. This RFC intends to develop design criteria for a new main page by discussing the various aims of the main page, whether the current main page achieves each aim, and if not, what needs to change.

For each statement, please leave a comment in the appropriate subsection. Alternative statements may be provided by anyone at any time. Remember, this is not a vote - the ultimate aim of this RFC is to develop discussion leading to the (rough) consensus views of the community. This RFC will stay open until (date 30 days after opening), though individual sections may remain open longer if discussion is ongoing.

For more information, please see Wikipedia talk:2013 main page redesign proposal - ~~~~ (signature and datestamp)

"Showcasing Wikipedia's best content is an aim of the main page" edit

The current main page fully achieves this aim edit

The current main page does not fully achieve this aim edit

This should not be an aim of the main page edit

"Enticing readers to become editors is an aim of the main page" edit

The current main page fully achieves this aim edit

The current main page does not fully achieve this aim edit

This should not be an aim of the main page edit

"Helping readers to navigate to articles on specific topics is an aim of the main page" edit

For example, via portals, topics, categories, etc.

The current main page fully achieves this aim edit

The current main page does not fully achieve this aim edit

This should not be an aim of the main page edit

"Showcasing timely and newsworthy content is an aim of the main page" edit

The current main page fully achieves this aim edit

The current main page does not fully achieve this aim edit

This should not be an aim of the main page edit

--Pine^✉ 05:42, 5 February 2013 (UTC)=="Promoting the breadth of Wikimedia projects is an aim of the main page"== For example, links to other language Wikipedias and links to WMF sister projects.[reply]

The current main page fully achieves this aim edit

The current main page does not fully achieve this aim edit

This should not be an aim of the main page edit

"Motivating editors to create new content is an aim of the main page" edit

The current main page fully achieves this aim edit

The current main page does not fully achieve this aim edit

This should not be an aim of the main page edit

"Directing readers and editors seeking help to appropriate venues is an aim of the main page" edit

The current main page fully achieves this aim edit

The current main page does not fully achieve this aim edit

This should not be an aim of the main page edit

"Describing the purpose of Wikipedia is an aim of the main page" edit

For example, an About Wikipedia section.

The current main page fully achieves this aim edit

The current main page does not fully achieve this aim edit

This should not be an aim of the main page edit

"Encouraging donations to WMF is an aim of the main page" edit

For example, a Donate section

The current main page fully achieves this aim edit

The current main page does not fully achieve this aim edit

This should not be an aim of the main page edit

The amount of change needed is ... edit

No change edit

Only minor fixes edit

(Minimal tweaks. Remove a couple of outdated links, update a few small things.)

A re-style edit

(Same basic layout, but change the look)

A major update edit

(new style and modified layout, which would probably also entail content adjustment/s to make it work)

A major overhaul edit

(something utterly different from the current main page)