User talk:Vchimpanzee/How to edit constructively

Latest comment: 8 years ago by Jerzy in topic His own page

(Anonymous?) edit

"(to the extent to which anything is "not anonymous" on the internet)" should probably be removed as ordinary use of the internet does not necessarily confer anonymity.Dankpoet007 (talk) 02:58, 26 July 2014 (UTC)Reply

   The multiple negative is a bit confusing. What the parenthesized phrase asserts is consistent with the fact that many things can be done on the 'net in ways that make impractical to positively establish what birth certificate or driver's license corresponds to the doer. Besides, even most of the otherwise impractical ones are likely to require a court order.
But i would favor rewording the phrase, or maybe the sentence.
--Jerzyt 02:35, 13 June 2015 (UTC)Reply

His own page edit

   DG's talk contribution included this:

Even the founder of Wikipedia, Jimmy Wales, cannot make unsourced changes to his own Wikipedia page.

...which i had to stare at a long time to get over the impression that it was ridiculous. OK, i admit that possessive pronouns are inherently ambiguous: there's an important difference between your hat and your mother. (One is your property, and one merely pertains to you even if she is no one else's mother.) User:Jimbo Wales is entirely different from Jimmy Wales, and i'm rewording accordingly (because the accompanying essay -- even tho it's not mine -- isn't Dave Golland's, nor Vchimpanzee's, either).
--Jerzyt 02:35, 13 June 2015 (UTC)Reply