Kneague
Joined 21 May 2006
Latest comment: 16 years ago by Ward3001 in topic Erdős–Bacon number
"we have recently discovered that this is bogus, because the link, named Gene Patterson, is not the same person in N is a Number"
- Who is "we"? Can you cite a reliable source for this information? If so, we may have something to discuss. If not, case closed. Ward3001 (talk) 02:53, 3 April 2008 (UTC)
- ""I think the burden of proof is to demonstrate that IMDB is right. It's listing a stuntman and an expert/friend of Paul Erdos as the same person, which sounds suspicious to me. Has anyone actually seen N is a Number? I encourage someone to e-mail the Erdős' Number Project, which is the most reliable source on the topic of Erdős' Numbers, and the source of my above quote. --Kneague 14:43, 3 April 2008 (UTC)"
- No, the burden on proof is on anyone who wants to challenge information in the article that is already sourced. Also, you have not explained who "we" is in your statement that "''we have recently discovered that this is bogus", nor explained your evidence that it is bogus. And Kneague, you can email the Erdős' Number Project if you wish. Ward3001 (talk) 16:02, 3 April 2008 (UTC)
- ""I think the burden of proof is to demonstrate that IMDB is right. It's listing a stuntman and an expert/friend of Paul Erdos as the same person, which sounds suspicious to me. Has anyone actually seen N is a Number? I encourage someone to e-mail the Erdős' Number Project, which is the most reliable source on the topic of Erdős' Numbers, and the source of my above quote. --Kneague 14:43, 3 April 2008 (UTC)"