Altmusicreviews

The lyrics are correct, the writing is proper, and I listened to it plenty. Sputnik's reviews are allowed on Wikipedia. You have no leg to stand on. Thank you.

Manifoldcuriosity (talk) 17:06, 26 June 2011 (UTC)

You don't know what kind of leak I got. Is there a different version out there that is better than the one I have? Will the songs magically not suck?

And I've listened to the album about three times. Once, to get a first impression, then I started taking notes. Second and third time I listened I started fleshing out the notes to a full fledged opinion. I don't understand what's unprofessional about that. Is there a professional standard time between first hearing an album and writing a review? If I waited a week and wrote the same review would that make a difference? Also, my comments on the review's message board are irrelevant. They have no bearing on the review itself. The review is the same with or without knowledge of how much "professional time" went into writing it. Which, for what it's worth, was quite a lot of time.

Manifoldcuriosity (talk) 21:04, 26 June 2011 (UTC)