Nominated
edit- Ben Edwards (American football) (updated Sept 2024)
- Connor Hamlett (updated Sept 2024)
- Corey Moore (safety) (updated Sept 2024)
- Greg Mancz (updated Sept 2024), possible FA
- Hal Hunter (American football, born 1932) (updated Sept 2024)
- James Jones (basketball, born 1980) (updated Sept 2024)
- Jared Norris (updated Sept 2024)
- Joel Heath (updated Sept 2024)
- Jordan Williams (American football) (updated Sept 2024)
- Josh McCown (updated Sept 2024)
- Jarrod Pughsley (updated Sept 2024)
- J. T. O'Sullivan (updated Sept 2024)
- Kasey Peters (updated Sept 2024)
- Pete Thomas (American football) (updated Sept 2024)
- Robb Butler (updated Sept 2024)
- Steve Longa (updated Sept 2024)
- T. T. Toliver (updated Sept 2024)
- Trevor Williams (American football) (updated Sept 2024)
Reviewed
edit- Aaron Hertzman
- Andy Gibler
- Art Rooney Jr.
- Bob Vaughn
- Brad White (defensive lineman)
- C. A. Clingenpeel
- Cedric Oglesby
- Ching Hammill
- Dave Viti
- Derrick Walton
- Dick Harris (center)
- Dim Montero
- Doug Fisher (American football)
- Doug Turley
- DuWayne Deitz
- Frank Deig (not done)
- Frank Fitzgerald (American football)
- George H. Hobson
- Gordon Cooper (American football)
- Harry Bolick
- Henry Bell (American football)
- Henry Janzen (not done)
- Ira Valentine
- Jack Teele (not done)
- Jeff Allen (defensive back, born 1948)
- Jeff Jordan (defensive back)
- Jim Cullivan
- Jim Dillard (gridiron football) (not done)
- Jim Mueller
- Jimmy Cole (American football)
- Joe Gray (American football)
- Joe Hall (American football)
- John Kinch
- John Lookabaugh
- John Thompson (American football executive)
- Johnny Fripp (not done)
- Lewis Manly
- Lou Daukas
- Louis Crews
- Max Bielfeldt
- Mike Kullman
- Moses Gray (American football)
- Obe Wenig (not done)
- Oliver C. Dawson
- Pat Ragusa
- Paul Loudon (not done)
- Quency Williams
- Ralph Smith (American football)
- Rick Buffington
- Riley Morris
- Rodney Parker
- Ronnie Amadi
- Sid Justin
- Skip Walker
- Tony Okanlawon
- Tony Pajaczkowski (not done)
- Vivian Hultman
- William P. Trimble