2016–17
editNorth
edit| Middlesbrough | 6–0 | York City | Riverside Stadium | |
Flinders  19' (o.g.)Nugent 23'Downing 33'Rhodes 63' 87'Fischer 75' |
West
edit| Huddersfield Town | 1–0 | Bradford City | John Smith’s Stadium | |
| van La Parra 6' |
| Guiseley | 3–4 | Leeds United | Nethermoor Park | |
| Palmer 7', 24' Lawlor 12' |
Hernández 45' Wood 63'Phillips 71'Doukara 73' |
| Leeds United | 0–1 | Huddersfield Town | Elland Road | |
| Mooy 55' |
East
edit| Hull City | 2–0 | North Ferriby United | KCOM Stadium | |
| Maloney 79' Hernández 90+2' |
South
edit| Sheffield United | 1–0 | Doncaster Rovers | Bramall Lane | |
| Sharp 81' |
| Rotherham United | 2–1 | Sheffield United | New York Stadium | |
| Ward 12' 83' |
Done 13' |
| Barnsley | 1–2 (a.e.t.) | Sheffield Wednesday | Oakwell | |
| MacDonald 90+2' |
Winnall 50' Hutchinson 118' |
| Sheffield Wednesday | 1–0 | Rotherham United | Hillsborough Stadium | |
| Fletcher 90+4' (pen.) |
Wood  90+3' |
Semi finals
edit| Hull City | 2–1 | Sheffield Wednesday | KCOM Stadium | |
| Snodgrass 61' Dawson 63' |
Hutchinson 90+2' |
| Huddersfield Town | 1–2 | Middlesbrough | John Smith’s Stadium | |
| Kachunga 69' |
Ramírez 39' Downing 56' |
Final
edit| Middlesbrough | 1–0 | Hull City |
|---|---|---|
| Ramírez 60' |
          Middlesbrough
|
     Hull City
|
2017–18
editNorth
edit| Middlesbrough | 2–0 | York City | Riverside Stadium | |
| Assombalonga 23', 60' |
West
edit| Leeds United | 1–3 | Huddersfield Town | Elland Road | |
| Hernández 26' |
Kachunga 6' Mooy 23'Depoitre 50' |
| Guiseley | 1–2 | Bradford City | Nethermoor Park | |
| Southwell 4' |
Wyke 64' McMahon 76' |
| Bradford City | 0–1 | Huddersfield Town | Valley Parade | |
| van La Parra 44' Schindler  25'  57' |
East
editSouth
edit| Rotherham United | 2–1 | Doncaster Rovers | New York Stadium | |
| Smith 90+3' Newell 90+13' (pen.) |
Marquis 39' |
| Rotherham United | 4–0 | Barnsley | New York Stadium | |
| Proctor 67', 73', 75' Moore 90+1' |
| Sheffield United | 2–1 (a.e.t.) | Sheffield Wednesday | Bramall Lane | |
| Duffy 97' Clarke 107' |
Loovens 25' 64' João 96' |
| Sheffield United | 2–1 | Rotherham United | Bramall Lane | |
| Ihiekwe 68' (o.g.) Stevens 80' |
Yates 86' |
Semi finals
edit| Hull City | 1–0 | Sheffield United | KCOM Stadium | |
| Dicko 55' |
| Middlesbrough | 0–1 | Huddersfield Town | Riverside Stadium | |
| Depoitre 90' |
Final
edit| Hull City | 1–4 (a.e.t.) | Huddersfield Town |
|---|---|---|
| Dicko 52' |
Tomori 60' (o.g.) Mounié 94'van La Parra 97'Ince 106' |
    Hull City
|
     Huddersfield Town
|