User:PantherLeapord/sandbox/fourrfcdraft

First of many RfC's for changes to WP:FOUR

Issue 1: The nominations area

edit

Should all nominations for the award go to the nominations area or should the category be used as it is now?

Use the nominations area

edit

Continue using Category:Possible Wikipedia four award articles as a "holding area" for nominations

edit

Discussion

edit

Issue 1.5: How awards should be decided

edit

If the results of Issue 1 say that we should use the nominations area; how should we use that to decide which articles get the award or not?

Have articles listed if a reviewer feels it should be

edit

Have community debate and discussion decide

edit

Discussion

edit

Issue 2: Do we even need a director?

edit

Have a listed director

edit

Do not have a listed director

edit

Discussion

edit

Issue 3: What about collaborations?

edit

Should this award recognise when multiple editors have worked on a single article?

Award to collaborations

edit

Do not award to collaborations

edit

Discussion

edit

Issue 3.5: How will collaborations be recognised?

edit

If collaborations are to be recognised then how will it be determined which editors are eligible for the award?

Suggestions

edit

Discussion

edit