Players from [1] I need to work on:
- Bert Abbey - 06-10-27
- Doug Allison - 06-10-27
- Cap Anson - in progress
- Al Atkinson (baseball player) - 06-10-27
- Ross Barnes
- Jimmy Barrett
- Joe Battin - 06-10-29
- Jake Beckley - in progress
- Steve Bellán
- Charlie Bennett - 06-10-27
- Bill Bernhard - 06-10-27 - more info http://www.baseballlibrary.com/baseballlibrary/ballplayers/B/Bernhard_Bill.stm
- Charlie Berry (19th century baseball player) - 06-10-29
- Steve Bloomer
- Tommy Bond (baseball)
- Joe Borden - 06-11-16
- Jack Boyle - 06-11-24 (many statements have no citations)
- Bill Bradley (baseball player) - 06-10-27
- George Bradley - 06-11-20
- Asa Brainard
- Dan Brouthers
- Tom Brown (baseball player)
- Pete Browning
- Charlie Buffinton - 06-10-27
- Dick Burns - 06-10-27
- Bob Caruthers
- Doc Casey - 06-11-14
- Elton Chamberlain - 06-11-12
- John Clapp (baseball) - 06-11-24
- Fred Clarke
- John Clarkson
- Jimmy Collins
- Charles Comiskey
- Roger Connor
- Joe Corbett - 06-11-13
- Larry Corcoran - 06-11-15
- Tommy Corcoran
- Sam Crawford
- Jim Creighton
- Lave Cross
- Candy Cummings
- Nig Cuppy - 06-11-27
- Bill Dahlen
- Hugh Daily
- Abner Dalrymple
- George Davis (baseball player)
- Harry Davis (baseball player)
- Ed Delahanty
- Jerry Denny
- Red Donahue
- Bill Donovan (baseball)
- Patsy Donovan
- Hugh Duffy
- Fred Dunlap
Players from [2] who lack notability.
- John Abadie
- Charlie Ahearn
- Gus Alberts
- Jim Andrews
- Charlie Atherton
- Henry Austin (baseball)
- Frank Bahret
- Al Barker
- Bill Barnes
- Bob Barr (baseball)
- Charlie Bell (baseball)
- Frank Bell (baseball)
- Cy Bentley
- George Bird
- Red Bittman
- Henry Blauvelt
- Jim Brown (baseball)
- Fritz Buelow
- Charlie Cady
- Will Calihan
- Hugh Campbell (baseball)
- Mike Campbell (baseball)
- Chick Carroll
- Pat Carroll (baseball)