About my reviews

edit

I think the Good Article project is one of the best initiatives on Wikipedia, so regardless of the outcome of a review, know that I think you're awesome just for working to bring an article to this point.

In reviews, I try to stick strictly to the criteria and treat the essay What the Good Article Criteria Are Not as a Bible. If I have additional suggestions, I'll try to make clear they're not needed for GA status. I pass about 75% of the articles I review. Out of those that I don't list, the most common reason is that the nominator doesn't return within a week to address the issues involved. I almost always do some minor copyediting for a review, but if I find myself correcting a number of misspellings and grammatical errors, I'll usually send the article back for more work before renomination or put it on hold for a week to see if another copyeditor can be found. If you ever have a question and want me to get back involved on an article I've reviewed, feel free to ping me.

Good Article reviews

edit

Complete

edit
#1-100 (Nov. 2012 - Feb. 2013)

1100

  1. Greed (film)   (2012)
  2. The Avengers (2012 film)  
  3. King David Hotel bombing  
  4. Alben W. Barkley  
  5. Chadian–Libyan conflict  
  6. The Expendables 2  
  7. The Whale (The Office)  
  8. Cory Booker  
  9. Floyd Henry Allport  
  10. Maryam Nawaz  
  11. Sex workers' rights  
  12. Islam: The Untold Story  
  13. William Borah  
  14. Spooks (series 1)  
  15. Fyodor Dostoevsky  
  16. History of Edinburgh Zoo  
  17. Synchrony (The X-Files)  
  18. Laura Secord   (2013)
  19. Sleaford Navigation  
  20. Romanticism  
  21. John Wilson (Puritan)  
  22. Bajkam  
  23. Castles and Town Walls of King Edward in Gwynedd  
  24. Goodman Beaver  
  25. Zennor Head  
  26. Winter: Five Windows on the Season  
  27. Aubrey Huff  
  28. Worlds Apart (Fringe)  
  29. Washington University in St. Louis  
  30. Kony 2012  
  31. Charles H. Constable  
  32. Todd Packer (The Office)  
  33. Croatian Littoral  
  34. Richard Rennison  
  35. Herb Mitchell (actor)  
  36. John Breckinridge (U.S. Attorney General)  
  37. Carolyn Sherif  
  38. Murder of Celine Figard  
  39. Cuckoo  
  40. Levi Lincoln, Sr.  
  41. Jacob's Ladder (film)  
  42. Animal navigation  
  43. Glen H. Taylor  
  44. Barend Joseph Stokvis  
  45. Gary Johnson  
  46. Alexander Lukashenko  
  47. Leon Festinger  
  48. Emotions in virtual communication  
  49. James Scullin  
  50. Simon Wiesenthal  
  51. Andrew Johnson  
  52. Lana Crawford  
  53. The Marriages Between Zones Three, Four and Five  
  54. "China" (The Office)  
  55. Antinomian Controversy  
  56. George S. Patton  
  57. Elbridge Gerry  
  58. XCOM: Enemy Unknown  
  59. "Lessons" (Star Trek: The Next Generation)  
  60. Marcus Ward Lyon, Jr.  
  61. Dwarf (Dungeons & Dragons)  
  62. Paul Michaux  
  63. James Innes (North Carolina)  
  64. Enrico Fermi  
  65. Australian plebiscite, 1916  
  66. Louis Nolan  
  67. SMS Budapest  
  68. Shifang protest  
  69. Customer Loyalty (The Office)  
  70. Willard Hershberger  
  71. Kota Kinabalu  
  72. Lithium (Nirvana song)  
  73. Zong massacre  
  74. Split Agreement  
  75. Capture of USS Chesapeake  
  76. Armenian American  
  77. Argentine–Chilean naval arms race  
  78. South Side, Chicago  
  79. Magnus Carlsen  
  80. Military history of Asian Americans  
  81. Voivode of Transylvania  
  82. Spencer W. Kimball  
  83. Embraer EMB 312 Tucano  
  84. Richard Tomlinson  
  85. Chernobyl disaster  
  86. Duino Elegies  
  87. Crimewave  
  88. Mass Effect 2: Lair of the Shadow Broker  
  89. Loring Air Force Base  
  90. River Rother, East Sussex  
  91. The Man with the Iron Fists  
  92. Christian Science  
  93. Before the Dawn: Recovering the Lost History of Our Ancestors  
  94. Battle of Burton Bridge (1322)  
  95. Mortal Kombat (2011 video game)  
  96. Clinton Romesha  
  97. Audie Murphy  
  98. Mount Jackson (Antarctica)  
  99. Politics of Svalbard  
  100. Ely and Littleport riots of 1816  
#101-200 (Feb. - May 2013 )

101200

  1. Moorish Gibraltar  
  2. Mo Yan  
  3. She Has a Name  
  4. Victoria and Albert Museum  
  5. Shel Silverstein  
  6. Delta County Courthouse  
  7. Portuguese Renaissance  
  8. William Eustis  
  9. Stanley Donen  
  10. Cooke and Wheatstone telegraph  
  11. Letters from an American Farmer  
  12. Omar Derdour  
  13. Gagak Item  
  14. Henry I of England  
  15. Wouldn't Take Nothing for My Journey Now  
  16. Kung Fu Hustle  
  17. Elmer Ernest Southard  
  18. Hallaton Helmet  
  19. César Batiz  
  20. The Long, Hot Summer  
  21. Third Epistle of John  
  22. Wars of the Roses  
  23. Kevin Clash  
  24. Robert of Cricklade  
  25. Gone with the Wind (film)  
  26. James Ferguson (Scottish politician)  
  27. Neither Here Nor There (Fringe)  
  28. Serbia  
  29. Liao Dynasty  
  30. Three-dollar piece  
  31. Matthew, Mark, Luke and John  
  32. North Devon's Biosphere Reserve  
  33. Pope Benedict XVI  
  34. Tylopilus felleus  
  35. Speed 2: Cruise Control (soundtrack)  
  36. Johnny Evers  
  37. Stronger (Sugababes song)  
  38. Trouble (Leona Lewis song)  
  39. The Answer's at the End  
  40. Bockscar  
  41. James Bond in film  
  42. Escape from Tomorrow  
  43. The Amazing Spider-Man (2012 film)  
  44. Passing (novel)  
  45. Boletus luridus  
  46. Couples Discount  
  47. Being Eileen  
  48. Abrahams Commission  
  49. Halo: Cryptum  
  50. Great New York City Fire of 1845  
  51. Fishing Creek (North Branch Susquehanna River)  
  52. Stanisław Staszic  
  53. Wings (Little Mix song)  
  54. Robert Howe (soldier)  
  55. Orion's Belt (film)  
  56. Instant Karma!  
  57. Henry VIII of England  
  58. Rudd Concession  
  59. Orme (horse)  
  60. Nusreta Sivac  
  61. Levi Lincoln, Jr.  
  62. Tim Breslin  
  63. PINK de Thierry  
  64. Romanticism in Scotland  
  65. Teresa Perales  
  66. Toil  
  67. Wildlife (La Dispute album)  
  68. Never Let Me Down  
  69. The Foundation Pit  
  70. Fuck (film)  
  71. George Wilkes  
  72. Goldenheart  
  73. Gertie the Dinosaur  
  74. Texarkana Moonlight Murders  
  75. Miracle at St. Anna  
  76. Turnhalle (Windhoek)  
  77. Barrington Court  
  78. Båtsfjord Airport (1973–1999)  
  79. Bridie Kean  
  80. Zachary Taylor  
  81. River Witham  
  82. Sense and Sensibility (2008 TV miniseries)  
  83. Polka Party!  
  84. Jelena Balšić  
  85. Postcolonial feminism  
  86. Gary Suter  
  87. Monsters, Inc.  
  88. Dario Fo  
  89. Paul Thomas Anderson  
  90. Istiqlal Mosque  
  91. Donghak Peasant Revolution  
  92. Sagtikos State Parkway  
  93. Joe Tinker  
  94. Frank Chance  
  95. Pittsburgh Town  
  96. Arrowhead (Herman Melville House)  
  97. The Wild Bunch  
  98. September 11 attacks  
  99. The Land of Lost Content  

200. Bømla Bridge  

#201-300 (May - Oct. 2013 )

201300

  1. Lie Kim Hok  
  2. Tim Bozon  
  3. 2012 Hawaii Bowl  
  4. JKT48  
  5. Longtail butterfly ray  
  6. Toxoplasma gondii  
  7. Johanna Welin  
  8. Feminist Improvising Group  
  9. Speed flying  
  10. José María Caro Martínez  
  11. MIND MGMT  
  12. Harry Yount  
  13. Skyfall (song)  
  14. Robert Lowell  
  15. Nazi Germany  
  16. Wheel of Fortune (U.S. game show)  
  17. Solomon Butcher  
  18. Jefferson Davis  
  19. Nigel Farage  
  20. Jan Dekert  
  21. Eyeshield 21  
  22. Vladivostok Summit Meeting on Arms Control  
  23. Government in Medieval Scotland  
  24. Flaming Pie  
  25. Far Side Virtual  
  26. The End of the Road  
  27. National Football League  
  28. New Waddell Dam  
  29. Pacer (album)  
  30. Rain in England  
  31. Romeo & Juliet: Sealed with a Kiss  
  32. Goldfrapp  
  33. Art Farmer  
  34. Law School of Beirut  
  35. Castlevania: Lords of Shadow  
  36. Giant Dipper  
  37. Misterioso (Thelonious Monk album)  
  38. Manhunt (series)  
  39. A Thousand Splendid Suns  
  40. The Gammage Cup  
  41. Audi V8  
  42. Jack the Giant Slayer  
  43. New York State Route 111  
  44. Devotions upon Emergent Occasions  
  45. Sea  
  46. Oh Pray My Wings Are Gonna Fit Me Well  
  47. William R. Keating  
  48. 2012 Delhi gang rape case  
  49. Imru' al-Qais  
  50. Petersen Rock Garden  
  51. Louisiana Purchase Exposition dollar  
  52. Elgin, Illinois, Centennial half dollar  
  53. Two-cent piece (United States coin)  
  54. Glenn T. Seaborg  
  55. Twenty-cent piece (United States coin)  
  56. Treasure voyages  
  57. Weldy Walker  
  58. Pennsylvanian (train)  
  59. Jalili dynasty  
  60. Euro banknotes  
  61. Rotnei Clarke  
  62. George McGovern  
  63. Mass Effect 2: Kasumi - Stolen Memory  
  64. The Council (Star Trek: Enterprise)  
  65. And Still I Rise  
  66. Lady of the Forest  
  67. Anna Maria Lenngren  
  68. Charlottesville and Albemarle Railway  
  69. One Day at HorrorLand  
  70. Texas State Highway 168  
  71. Regents of the University of California v. Bakke  
  72. The Swarm (roller coaster)  
  73. 1948 Cleveland Browns season  
  74. Indio Comahue Monument  
  75. Q Who  
  76. Ulster Defence Regiment  
  77. Ara Parseghian  
  78. Something/Anything?  
  79. The Beguiling  
  80. Edward Everett  
  81. Banjica concentration camp  
  82. Father's Day (Doctor Who)  
  83. Valor por Tamaulipas  
  84. Star Trek: The Next Generation (season 2)  
  85. Saradha Group financial scandal  
  86. History of Chincoteague, Virginia  
  87. Partition Sejm  
  88. Horace Gillom  
  89. William Hayden English  
  90. Lotus (Christina Aguilera album)  
  91. The Whistleblower  
  92. Let It Down  
  93. Juan Bielovucic Cavalié  
  94. La Strada  
  95. Death in Paradise (TV series)  
  96. Nina Live!  
  97. Stay Alive (album)  
  98. Renditions of the Soul  
  99. Heaven (Nina Girado album)  

300. Nina (album)  

#301- (October 2013 - ? )

2015

  1. Schmücke dich, o liebe Seele, BWV 180  
  2. Oxford Street  

In progress

edit

To start

Quickfail log

edit

In addition to my full reviews, in late 2013 I began patrolling new nominations for obvious quickfails (outstanding cleanup tags, driveby nominations of unprepared work, etc.). I list these separately to avoid distorting my review total and pass-fail rate.