User:Cenarium/FLR

Pending changes
Interface: Pages with pending edits · Pages under pending changes · Pending changes log ·
Documentation: Main talk · Reviewing guideline · Reviewing talk · Protection policy · Testing · Statistics

2010 Trial and 2012 Implementation

Historical: Trial proposal · Specifics · Reviewing guideline · Metrics · Terminology · Queue · Feedback · Closure · 2012 Implementation
Discussions:

Summary information for editors

Current status - Pending changes (level 1) was re-enabled on December 1st, 2012 by community consensus according to the 2012 RFC.
Logged in users – Logged in users (or users choosing to view pending changes) will see all edits as usual (unless the relevant setting has been changed in their preferences). All edits will still be added to the wiki and inappropriate edits must still be reverted or fixed as usual.
Logged out users – Until checked for obvious vandalism or superseded by appropriate editing, edits by new and unregistered users to "pending changes protected" pages will not be seen by users who are not logged in until approved. Edits by autoconfirmed users are approved automatically at level 1 when the prior revision is approved.
Policy – See the pending changes usage policy and the guideline on reviewing
Reviewer rights – Become a reviewer!.
Support and testing – Test page: Wikipedia:Pending changes/Testing. Bugs: Report them at WT:PC. For more information visit the IRC channel: #wikipedia-en-pc ^connect
Provide feedback and suggestion – Feedback page: Wikipedia talk:Pending changes. Your feedback and suggestions are appreciated.

This page in a nutshell: A two-month trial of flagged protection, an alternative to conventional page protection that administrators can apply in the same circumstances, and of patrolled revisions, a passive improved monitoring system.

This page describes two new features accepted for implementation in a two-month trial, they are based on the concept of flagged revisions. The first feature is flagged protection, which uses flagging as an optional alternative to semi protection and full protection. When a page is protected in this way by an administrator, the latest flagged revision is shown to readers by default. The second feature is patrolled revisions, which uses flagging passively to coordinate the monitoring of articles, but has no effect on the version viewed by readers.

Shortcut

WP:FPPR

Background edit

Flagged revisions were initially developed so that wikis can review contributions by users before allowing their publication. In 2007 and 2008, flagged revisions have been proposed to better handle several issues faced by Wikipedia, such as vandalism and violations of our policy on living people, but the proposed implementations were rejected by the community, essentially for too drastically reducing the ability of anyone to edit Wikipedia. In late 2008 and beginning 2009, more specific implementations were discussed in order to reach a compromise, and finally the joint proposal for flagged protection and patrolled revisions reached consensus for a trial on the English Wikipedia.

Description edit

Those features are principally aimed to address the lack of flexibility of our current protection mechanisms and the relative inefficiency of our basic monitoring tools such as recent changes and watchlists. Flagged protection allows more granularity than the classic page protection system: while the latter prevents any editing, flagged protection allows editing but requires review before changes by new or unregistered users are displayed on the version viewed by readers. Like classic page protection, it can be enabled only by administrators, for a fixed period of time or indefinitely. Patrolled revisions provide a way to review edits similar to Flagged Revisions but without affecting the version viewed by readers, thus it is a passive way to monitor articles much more efficient than recent changes and watchlists which tend to become ineffectual with the huge volume of editing and articles on the English Wikipedia. While recent changes and watchlists display bare edits with no possibility of organization of the reviewing at the individual or community level, patrolled revisions allow users to review changes made to an article since the latest patrolled revision, and patrol new revisions when appropriate; and thus allow to coordinate and optimize the reviewing efforts.

Flagged protection edit

Flagged protection introduces new protection levels which can be used as an alternative to regular semi-protection and full-protection. During the trial, the conditions for using flagged protection are the same as for using semi-protection; they are determined by the protection policy. Autoconfirmation can be turned off if the article meets the requirements for full-protection or if there is active consensus to do so. Disputes should still be handled by full protection^[1]. Classic protection can and should still be used, for example in cases of exceptionally high levels of vandalism, where using flagged protection would be counter-productive. The additional protection levels are shown in the second table:

Currently available protection levels	Unregistered / Non-autoconfirmed	Autoconfirmed	Administrator
Semi-protection	Cannot edit	Can edit; edits are immediately visible
Full protection	Cannot edit		Can edit; edits are immediately visible

Proposed additional protection levels	Unregistered / Non-Autoconfirmed	Autoconfirmed	Reviewer
Flagged protection	Can edit; a new edit is visible to registered users, but not to readers by default until reviewed by a `'reviewer'`	Can edit; a new edit is visible immediately if the previous version is already reviewed; otherwise^[2] not visible to readers by default until reviewed by a `'reviewer'`	Can edit; a new edit is visible immediately if the previous version is already reviewed, otherwise^[2] the reviewer can publish the changes after reviewing pending edits.
Flagged protection (no autoconfirmation)	Can edit; a new edit is visible to registered users, but not to readers by default until confirmed by a `'reviewer'`

Advantages over the current system

Even though their edits are not visible immediately to readers, unregistered and new users can edit semi-flagged protected pages, while they cannot edit semi-protected pages. So this allows constructive changes while disallowing vandalism and other unconstructive changes.
Semi-protection is insufficient in certain cases, especially for articles targeted by persistent vandals or sockpuppets, or subject to extreme BLP violations; these sometimes require full protection. The option to deactivate auto-reviewing for autoconfirmed users who are not reviewers (autoconfirmation) provides a protection level adapted to handle those cases.

Patrolled revisions edit

The aim of patrolled revisions is to coordinate and improve the monitoring of all articles, especially biographies of living people. Reviewers can mark a revision patrolled, which has no effect but only to inform that this revision contains no vandalism, no blp violations, and satisfy certain other requirements defined by a guideline. In particular, this does not affect the revision viewed by unregistered users by default, it's still the latest one (unless the article is flag protected). A new revision by a reviewer is automatically patrolled when the previous version is.

Reviewers have access to a special page listing articles that have never been patrolled and a special page listing pages patrolled at least once with an unpatrolled latest revision. They allow respectively to detect never patrolled pages, that may not have been checked for vandalism, blp violations, etc, and monitor changes to patrolled pages, on which vandalism or blp violations may have been inserted since the latest patrol. Those special pages are filterable by category (for example, Category:Living people). It can also be filtered so that only elements on your watchlist appear, and mentions how many users are watching a page.

Currently, the number of edits to articles and in particular BLPs is so large that we don't have the power to check all of them, we have no way to even coordinate our efforts. This system allows us to monitor changes to articles, in particular BLPs, much more efficiently by comparing new edits to previously patrolled revisions. Even if only one edit of 10 is patrolled, it'll allow to bring potential vandalism and BLP violations to the attention of reviewers and so significantly reduce their general visibility.

Patrolled revisions would also allow checking of edits by autoconfirmed users who are not reviewers to flagged protected pages, as those are generally automatically confirmed when the previous revision is, but would not be automatically patrolled. To avoid work duplication, patrolled revisions are automatically confirmed.

In addition, a special page displays articles with tagged edits that have not been patrolled.

Implementation edit

The Wikimedia foundation has set up a team for the development and implementation of those features. The mediawiki extension FlaggedRevs is the core of the technical implementation for flagged protection; testing is underway at http://flaggedrevs.labs.wikimedia.org/wiki/Main_Page. Patrolled revisions is planed to be developed independently of the FlaggedRevs extension and will likely not be ready for the initial trial.^[3] Since 22 March 2010, weekly updates on the status of the implementation are given^[4] and it might be ready to implement in two or four weeks, as of 30 April, 2010.^[5]

Trial edit

Consensus has been reached for a two-month trial of flagged protection and patrolled revisions after series of discussions and a final poll. At the end of the trial, the Wikipedia community will decide whether to continue using flagged protection, and whether to test alternative configurations of flagged revisions.

Notes edit

^ Initially a full flagged protection level, where flagging was restricted to administrators had been proposed but won't be implemented in the trial for simplicity.
^ ^a ^b This second case should happen much less frequently, as new revisions are continually flagged by reviewers.
^ http://techblog.wikimedia.org/2010/01/flagged-revisions-your-questions-answered/
^ Village pump announcement
^ Flagged protection update