I ardently adhere to the WP GA criteria listed at Wikipedia:Good article criteria or simply GA. I am also committed to Wikipedia:What the Good article criteria are not or simply GACN. I always refer in every GAN review the guidelines given at Wikipedia:Reviewing good articles or simply (the steps) just to be hundred per cent sure about my approach.
Good Article reviews
edit
- none ...
- none ...
- none ...
To start
- To be decided ...
- To be decided ...
I quickfail an article which is very rare due to the following reasons:
- When the article already contains cleanup banners like {{cleanup}}, {{POV}}, or {{unreferenced}}, and {{fact}};
- When the nominator is not motivated enough or is apathetic; and
- When it has glaring copyright issues.
|