The Toshimaen Drowning Incident (Japanese: としまえんの水上設置遊具による溺水事故) refers to a tragic event that occurred on 15th August 2019 at the 'Fluffy Water Land' (ふわふわウォーターランド) attraction in Toshimaen, an amusement park that was then located in Nerima, Tokyo.[1] This attraction featured water-based inflatable play equipment.[2] A young girl, referred to here as 'A', who was wearing a life jacket, was found floating beneath the play equipment and subsequently drowned.[3]
 Toshimaen swimming pool (November 2019). The nearly rectangular pool surrounded by the flowing pool on the right of the photo is the site. (Based on an aerial photograph from the Geospatial Information Authority of Japan's Map and Aerial Photograph Viewing Service, Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism; original photograph has been cropped and processed) | |
| Date | 15 August 2019 |
|---|---|
| Time | Around 14:00 (JST) |
| Location | 'Fluffy Water Land' pool attraction at Toshimaen amusement park, Nerima-ku, Tokyo |
| Coordinates | 35°44'36.8"N 139°38'41.3"E |
| Also known as | Toshimanen swimming pool fatal accident |
| Cause | Lack of lifejackets and supervision |
| Outcome | "A" (8-year-old girl) deaths |
This incident became the subject of an investigation by the Consumer Affairs Agency.[3] It was concluded that the girl had fallen into the water, slipped under the play equipment, and was unable to escape due to the buoyancy of her life jacket.[4]
In response to this incident, the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) established guidelines for the safety of water-based play equipment.[5]
Accident site
edit_cropped.jpg)
.jpg){kind=spacer}
The accident occurred at Toshimaen, which opened in 1926, with the pool opening three years later in 1929.[6] The 'Fluffy Water Land' had been in operation since 2016.[3] The "Fluffy Water Land" was installed in a competitive swimming pool with eight lanes, measuring 50 metres in length, 20 metres in width, and a depth ranging from 1.2 to 1.9 metres. There were areas where someone of person A's height could not touch the bottom.[3][7][8] The "Fluffy Water Land" had more than 10 water-based play equipment, known as air toy types.[8][2] These are professionally referred to as 'air membrane structure toys',[9] which float on the water surface by inflating them with air. They are easy to store when deflated and can be reshaped in various ways, which are their advantages.[2] However, there were no nets or similar installations to prevent entry under the toys.[8] The planning and design of the "Fluffy Water Land" were carried out independently by Toshimaen, and the toys were procured from a manufacturer in China.[10] The toy that person A fell from was large enough for about 15 adults and children to play at once.[11] According to a man quoted by Tokyo Sports, who uses the "Fluffy Water Land" with his children every year, the toys are more than 30 centimetres thick and have a slippery surface, making it impossible for children to climb onto the toys from the water on their own. Even adults would struggle to escape if they ended up under the toys while wearing the life jackets mentioned later.[12]
At the "Fluffy Water Land", users had to be taller than 1.1 metres and were required to wear life jackets provided for drowning prevention and to prevent entry under the toys.[10] The life jackets provided at the "Fluffy Water Land" were solid-structured, using expanded polystyrene for buoyancy, and were shaped like a waistcoat. The waistcoat was worn by putting both arms through and fastening it at the front, with adjustments made accordingly.[13] In addition, users of the "Fluffy Water Land" were verbally asked if they could swim on their own. Many users were also seen wearing armbands, according to eyewitnesses of the accident.[14] At the "Fluffy Water Land", it was not uncommon for people to fall into the water from the toys, and on top of that, there were people who dropped their goggles into the water at a rate of two per hour.[11]
Accident
editAt the time, A was an 8-year-old girl in her third year of primary school, residing in Asaka City, Saitama Prefecture.[7] On the day of the incident, A, along with her father (hereafter referred to as B), mother (hereafter referred to as C), and one-year-old sister (hereafter referred to as D), visited the pool at Toshimaen.[7] A, who was over 1.1 metres tall, was wearing a life jacket.[7] She began using the pool with B around 1 pm.[15] At approximately 1:30 pm, B lost sight of A and asked the lifeguards to search for her. However, the lifeguards merely used a loudspeaker to call out,[16] "Is A here?" and directed B to the lost child centre, without immediately conducting an underwater search. They asked B to wait until 2 pm.[8]
Just before 2 pm, a lifeguard dived into the water to search for A but was unable to find her.[17] At 2 pm, a routine inspection began, during which all pool users were asked to get out of the water.[7] A was found by a lifeguard around 2:10 pm.[7] She was discovered face down under a mat-like play equipment, approximately 2.5 metres long, 5 metres wide, and 30 centimetres thick, still wearing her life jacket.[18] According to pool patrons who witnessed A being pulled out of the water, she was pale and limp when she was rescued, and a person believed to be C was screaming.[17] A was unconscious and in critical condition. According to witnesses, she received cardiopulmonary resuscitation before being transported to the hospital,[14] where her death was confirmed around 4 pm.[7]
At the time of the accident, there were approximately 270 people using the "Fluffy Water Land", and there were seven lifeguards on duty.[7] It was reported that no abnormalities were observed during the routine inspection at noon, which included underwater checks.[7]
Other
editOn the day of the incident, Toshimaen cancelled operations at the "Fluffy Water Land" as well as its evening pool operations (Night Pool), and suspended all pool activities from the following day, 16th August.[7] The pool reopened on 23rd August, but the rental of large inflatable rings was discontinued, and it was decided that the "Fluffy Water Land" would not operate until the end of the pool season in 2019. The "Fluffy Water Land" remained closed in 2020, leading up to the closure of Toshimaen itself on 31st August of the same year.[2]
Litigation
editOn 8 May 2020, the bereaved family members B and C of the deceased A filed a civil lawsuit in the Tokyo District Court, claiming that A's death was due to a lack of thorough safety management. They argued that, according to the guidelines of the Japan Air Play Equipment Safety Promotion Association, there should have been at least one supervisor per play equipment and a total of more than ten, but there were only seven in total.[19] They sought a total of approximately ¥ 75 million (£ 377,600) in damages from Toshimaen, its parent company Seibu Railway, the contractor in charge of surveillance, and the manufacturer and installer of the play equipment. Toshimaen officials attended A's funeral, but did not participate in the condolence visit and did not comply with the out-of-court dispute resolution procedure. In an interview with the Sankei Shimbun, C stated that there had been comments from Toshimaen and others that the accident was unforeseen, and regarding the document received from Toshimaen after the accident, C said, "The content seemed to be blaming each other for the accident, and I didn't feel any sincerity at all," "What do they think of my daughter's life?" and "I didn't feel any sense of apology at all."[4] The pool management company responded to an NHK interview immediately after the accident, stating that they had not anticipated that someone would enter under the play equipment.[20]
The first oral argument took place on 14 September 2020, but all the defendants indicated a willingness to contest the case and asked for the plaintiff's claim to be dismissed.[21] Seibu Railway merely commented, "We offer our condolences again. We will clarify our claims in the lawsuit".[22] Bunshun Online reported that it is certain that the trial will be prolonged, as all four defendant companies are blaming each other for the accident.[23]
On 6 March 2023, a settlement was reached in the Tokyo District Court. The details of the settlement were not disclosed.[24]
References
editSources
edit- ^ CSIC 2020, p. 19.
- ^ a b c d CSIC 2020, p. 9.
- ^ a b c d CSIC 2020, p. 4.
- ^ a b CSIC 2020, pp. 40–41.
- ^ "Guidelines on the Safety of Water Play Equipment" (in Japanese). METI. 25 Dec 2020. Archived from the original on 2 Mar 2024.
- ^ Kamiya, Enka (26 Aug 2020). "The Unknown History of Toshimaen, Bringing Down the Curtain on 94 Years of History: A Local Reporter's Love". The Tokyo Shimbun (in Japanese).
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j "8-Year-Old Girl Dies in Toshimaen Pool Under Floating Play Equipment". The Asahi Shimbun (in Japanese). 15 Aug 2019.
- ^ a b c d "Toshimaen Swimming Pool Fatal Accident, Family of Third-Grade Girl to Sue Management Company". Sankei Shimbun (in Japanese). 7 May 2020.
- ^ Kuribayashi, Hisashi (23 Mar 2021). "What are the Risks and Safety Measures Related to Water-based Air Play Equipment? We asked experts about their opinions based on the 'report' released by the Consumer Safety Investigation Committee". A Notebook for Creating a Future with Zero Marine Accidents (in Japanese). Archived from the original on 10 Aug 2022.
- ^ a b CSIC 2020, p. 17.
- ^ a b CSIC 2020, p. 18.
- ^ "A life jacket can be deadly? Toshimaen Pool pointed out in 3 fatal accidents". Tokyo Sports (in Japanese). 16 Aug 2019.
- ^ CSIC 2020, pp. 10–11.
- ^ a b "An 8-year-old girl drowned in a swimming pool and died in Nerima, Tokyo" (in Japanese). Japan Broadcasting Corporation (NHK). 15 Aug 2019.
- ^ "Dangers Lurking in Water-Based Play Equipment, No Guidelines, 'Toshimaen' Girl Fatal Accident". Mainichi Shimbun (in Japanese). 31 Aug 2019.
- ^ "Girl Dies in Swimming Pool, Missing Shortly After Beginning to Play" (in Japanese). Japan Broadcasting Corporation (NHK). 16 Aug 2019.
- ^ a b "8-Year-Old Girl Dies in "Toshimaen" Swimming Pool ... Blind Spot That Even Wearing Life Jackets Couldn't Prevent Accident" (in Japanese). Fuji Television. 16 Aug 2019.
- ^ "Toshimaen Pool Accident: Danger Lurking in 'Water-Based Play Equipment': Urgent Need to Review Safety and Monitoring System". Sankei Shimbun (in Japanese). 22 Aug 2019.
- ^ "としまえんプール事故 「水上遊具」に潜む危険 安全性、監視体制の見直し急務". 産経ニュース (in Japanese). 産業経済新聞社. 2019-08-22. Archived from the original on 2021年9月15日. Retrieved 2021-09-15.
{{cite news}}: Check date values in:|archivedate=(help) - ^ "プール事故「潜り込み想定せず」". NHKニュース (in Japanese). 日本放送協会. 2019-08-29. Archived from the original on 2019年8月29日.
{{cite news}}: Check date values in:|archivedate=(help) - ^ "としまえん運営会社など争う姿勢 プール事故死訴訟で初弁論". 産経ニュース (in Japanese). 産業経済新聞社. 2020-09-14. Archived from the original on 2021年9月15日. Retrieved 2021-09-15.
{{cite news}}: Check date values in:|archivedate=(help) - ^ 新屋絵理 (2020-09-14). "としまえんプール死亡事故 女児の両親が運営側を提訴". 朝日新聞デジタル (in Japanese). 朝日新聞社. Archived from the original on 2021年9月15日. Retrieved 2021-09-15.
{{cite news}}: Check date values in:|archivedate=(help) - ^ "「としまえん」のプールで小3女児が溺死…責任を押し付け合う"被告4社"の言い分". 文春オンライン (in Japanese). 文藝春秋. 2020-09-27. p. 2. Archived from the original on 2021年9月15日. Retrieved 2021-09-15.
{{cite news}}: Check date values in:|archivedate=(help) - ^ "女児プール死亡事故で和解 19年に「としまえん」で発生". 47NEWS (in Japanese). 共同通信社. 2023-03-06. Archived from the original on 2023年5月21日. Retrieved 2023-05-21.
{{cite news}}: Check date values in:|archivedate=(help)
Written report
edit- Consumer Safety Investigation Committee, ed. (2020-06-19). Accident Cause Investigation Report Based on Article 23, Paragraph 1 of the Consumer Safety Act Drowning Accident Caused by Water-Based Play Equipment (PDF) (in Japanese). Japan: Consumer Affairs Agency. Retrieved 2021-09-15.