Talk:You Can't Read this Book

Latest comment: 10 years ago by 146.90.245.55 in topic Copying Guardian review

Copying Guardian review edit

Much of the "Digital revolution?" section of this article appears to be an almost verbatim copy of parts of this Guardian review with only partial attribution.--146.90.245.55 (talk) 03:03, 22 January 2014 (UTC)Reply

Just found that another paragraph is taken verbatim from this Huffington Post review. Like the earlier example, there is only partial attribution, for part of it quotation marks aren't even used. It seems most of the content of this article is simply copy-pasted verbatim from reviews of the book but this is only made clear in some parts, which is also probably why the article is tagged with tone concerns. I'm going to be bold and remove most of it, it should go without saying it is also highly POV. The review section of this article is not really a NPOV overview of reviews of the book, but rather a highly POV review in itself, which merely draws on other reviews.--146.90.245.55 (talk) 20:24, 22 January 2014 (UTC)Reply