Talk:World Season Calendar
 | This article was nominated for deletion on 10 May 2011. The result of the discussion was redirect to Isaac Asimov#Other writings. |
Tragedy of the Moon edit
Asimov’s book, which is referenced, is a collection of essays; I assume the one in question is The Clock in the Sky. Anyhow, these are probably fictional stories and therefore this calendar would not qualify as a calendar proposal but a fictional calendar. Could someone with access to the source please elaborate? After all stuff like the Three Laws of Robotics are hardly purely fictional. Christoph Päper 15:06, 6 March 2007 (UTC)
- I wrote the original version of this article and included the reference. While Asimov is known for his fiction writing, he also wrote a great deal of nonfiction. The Tragedy of the Moon is a collection of his nonfiction essays. The essay referenced is called "The Week Excuse". It's nonfiction, and is as serious a proposal for calendar reform as any other. I've modified the reference to include the name of the essay. SimpsonDG (talk) 14:04, 13 September 2008 (UTC)
Deletion of Article edit
This article was deleted in May 2011, thus eliminating a useful article from Wikipedia for no apparent reason. To quote from the Wall Street Journal:
The problem of the so-called "deletionists" is totally out of control on Wikipedia. These are, so far as I can tell, completely self-appointed topic police who go from one article to another deleting pretty much anything they don’t like. Now, certainly, if they were making these decisions in topics where they actually had some particular domain expertise or knowledge, I’d say, fine. But that doesn’t appear to be what’s going on. To me, it just looks like a plain ol’ power trip for idiots who know basically nothing about anything except Wikipedia’s rules, which, also as pointed out in the article, are getting to be about as labyrinthine as the IRS code. Bottom line, Wikipedia is falling over of its own weight.
— Nicole Hamilton, Wall Street Journal, 2009