Talk:Willie Dille

Latest comment: 6 years ago by Effeietsanders in topic Strange accusations via fb

Strange accusations via fb

edit

JFTR: That weird video mentioned in the article (but imho should not be linked there) is "archived" at youtube. --Jotzet (talk) 11:14, 11 August 2018 (UTC)Reply

Thanks. Given that it was originally posted on Facebook, I don't think it matters a lot which is linked as reference in the article. It is hard to convey the tone and 'feel' of the video in text in a neutral way. Providing a direct reference is for that reason the most accurate way. I think GeenStijl is a relevant source in this context, despite it being a generally unreliable secondary source. In this case it serves more as an archive - and the odds that it remains available through GeenStijl are probably higher than on YouTube (and in this case, their article seems reasonably free of wrong facts - it aligns more or less with more reliable media outlets). I'll re-add that as source, purely for the video. effeietsanders 01:54, 12 August 2018 (UTC)Reply

Controversial anti-Islam video

edit

The article claimed "In February 2016, Dille shared a video on Facebook where she suggested that the Islam should be exterminated with a nuclear bomb", which gives the false impressions that (1) there was a video of her saying this, and (2) the theme of the video was that Muslim people should be killed with a nuclear bomb. You can see the actual video that she posted on facebook here: https://twitter.com/tapalnargis/status/948327165732540417?lang=en. It is anti-Islam spoof of John Lennon's "Imagine", and the nuclear bomb scene is 5 seconds of the two minute video. It is more accurate to say that she shared a video that suggested Islam was a bad influence and that it would be better if Islam ended. I have edited the article to say this.