Talk:Thunder (Leona Lewis song)/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Azealia911 (talk · contribs) 17:34, 17 October 2015 (UTC)

I'll get to this before the weekend is over Azealia911 _talk 17:34, 17 October 2015 (UTC)

General

• Lewis's is grammatically incorrect in terms of names, Lewis' is the correct presentation.

Lead and infobox

• No need for the dash in "top-thirty"
• Cover needs an alt.
• Nothing on the songs genre you could find?
  • No, unfortunately. I was really surprised at just how few reviews there are.  — Calvin999 13:08, 20 October 2015 (UTC)

Production and release

• Perhaps rename this section 'Background'
• "(on behalf of itself and Gadfly Songs (ASCAP)" needs an extra closing bracket.

Composition

• "Vibe described "Thunder"" → "Vibe described the track"
• "longer/ When" → "longer / When"
• "appeared to be directed her former label boss" makes no sense.

Critical reception and commercial response

• A rather long-winded title, I'd suggest a simple "Reception" and then dividing the section into two paragraphs, one for critical reception and the other for commercial performance, using level-3 headers is your choice.
  • I've renamed it but I'm not making it into two sub-sections, they would be far too short and it's not necessary.  — Calvin999 13:10, 20 October 2015 (UTC)
• "are some of" → "were some of"
• album's → albums

Promotion

• "On 13 August, Lewis" → "On 13 August, she"
• No need for the dash in "mini-set"
• "The started with" makes no sense.
• ""Bleeding Love" followed" needs a comma after Love"
• "to the beginning of there performed in the style" makes no sense.

Formats

• This seems like an odd section title. Formats would mean that the song was released to various platforms, EG a CD single, iTunes single, radio airplay version. However they're all of the same format, perhaps "Versions" would be a better title? Or maybe you can think of a more suitable word yourself.
• I'd replace the # with *, putting them in a numbered list gives off the impression they all originate on a remixes EP.
• Remix shouldn't be capitalized.

Charts

• Columns should probably be sortable given there's five positions.
• Czech Republic and Slovakia also have {{singlechart}} templates, see this as an example.
  • They were originally but they didn't work properly so I changed them. Nothing wrong with manually inputting anyway.  — Calvin999 13:15, 20 October 2015 (UTC)

Release history

• Ref. → {{Abbr|Ref.|Reference}}
• Remix shouldn't be capitalized.
• Nothing on the release of the song elsewhere, EG her home country?
  • It was a US only single, as noted in the lead and background ;-)  — Calvin999 13:17, 20 October 2015 (UTC)
• Either unlink digital download, or link Adult contemporary.
• [[Def Jam Recordings]] → [[Def Jam Recordings|Def Jam]]
• The Tom Swoon remix was released on September 25th, not the 11th.

References

• Some MoS:DASH violations in titles.
• #1 – Is 'inlay cover' meant to be 'liner notes' or 'album booklet'? An inlay is the actual lining of the CD (EG this) strikes me as odd that she'd list all of that info there. Also, [[Def Jam Recordings]] → [[Def Jam Recordings|Def Jam]]

External links

• External link guidelines recommend only one official link, I advise removing the two remix audios.
• The YouTube link contains a MoS:DASH violation.
• This one's silly and just personal preference, but I'd switch the two links and have the official video above a secondary lyric source.

• Status: On-hold for seven days. Azealia911 _talk 20:05, 18 October 2015 (UTC)
  • Done all. Thanks.  — Calvin999 13:23, 20 October 2015 (UTC)

Passing. Azealia911 _talk 17:21, 20 October 2015 (UTC)