Talk:The Gatekeepers (film)

Latest comment: 10 years ago by Zero0000 in topic Excessive quotation from J. P.

Upload

edit

Someone can upload this poster plz. I don't know how to do this... — Preceding unsigned comment added by Vipetthegreat (talkcontribs) 10:53, 1 January 2013 (UTC)Reply

Budget

edit

I restored the budget information. The original information of 1.3 milion euros was confirmed in a conversation I had with one of the producers. However, since it was not cited as requested, I found the one citation in a Hebrew article saying it cost $1.5 million, which is roughly what the producer told me. The Hebrew can be found in the second line of the article cited, in the parentheses: (תקציב של מיליון וחצי דולר). Danny (talk) 04:01, 12 January 2013 (UTC)Reply

Quotes

edit

I restored the two quotes in the film. They are, exactly, as follows (taken from the final draft of the subtitles):

1072 01:31:25,236 --> 01:31:27,636 On the other hand it's a brutal occupation force,

1073 01:31:27,637 --> 01:31:31,337 similar to the Germans in World War II.

1074 01:31:32,338 --> 01:31:34,738 Similar, not identical.

and:

1055 01:29:46,073 --> 01:29:50,973 These moment end up etched deep inside you,

1056 01:29:51,274 --> 01:29:53,674 and when you retire,

1057 01:29:53,875 --> 01:29:56,175 you become a bit of a leftist.

Sources from film reviews forthcoming. Danny (talk) 03:20, 25 February 2013 (UTC)Reply

Excessive quotation from J. P.

edit

The quotation of material from this op-ed is so excessive (about a quarter of the whole op-ed) that it is highly dubious that copyright law is satisfied. For this reason alone, it should be reduced by a factor of two. It is also an abuse of Wikipedia rules (NPOV and WEIGHT) to present the opinions of a political advocacy group, in this case StandWithUs, without saying so. If this section is not greatly reduced and presented correctly quite soon, I am going to take a very sharp knife to it. Zerotalk 07:56, 5 April 2014 (UTC)Reply