Talk:Sean Shibe

Latest comment: 19 days ago by Davidships in topic Removal of Puffery and invalid citation

Removal of Puffery and invalid citation edit

He is frequently referred to as the foremost guitarist of his generation. - Removed this unneccessary puffery which has an inglorious history here.

First added, without citation, attributed to The Scotsman; attribution changed falsely to a source that didn't mention it; then to a misquote of "one of the foremost..." from Shibe's then professional agent and soon tagged. Source replaced by Guardian ref which didn't mention it (tag left in place - so right!) but has malingered here, probably providing the source fulfilling its destiny.

A long quote from an unidentified edition of BBC Radio 3's Record Review also had the same Guardian article falsely attached to it (quote now tagged and Guardian ref removed) - Davidships (talk) 12:26, 6 May 2024 (UTC)Reply