Talk:SM UB-50/GA1

Latest comment: 14 years ago by Miller17CU94 in topic GA Review

GA Review

edit

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Well-written
  • For all numbers listed, whether it be in weight, in distance or in caliber, please use {{Convert}}. There are several places that list items both in English and metric, but others are listed in English units only.
  • Construction section.
    • How can the sub having a cruising range of 9,000 miles yet it only lists 8,500 miles in the Infobox? Which one is correct?
  • For all patrols, list the durations of the patrols, including who was commanding office of the ship during that specific duration?
  • Some questions need to be answered: 1) Were there any casualties aboard the submarine during any of the patrols? 2) What happened to the boat after the war? 3) Who ordered the boat to be broken up? 4) When was it broken up in Swansea?
  • Prose, manual of style, spelling, and grammar are fine.
Factually accurate and verifable
Broad
  • Good job addressing ship's construction and activity during WWI, but misses aftermath of ship after the war. These questions were raised in the well-written section.
Neutral
  • Lists what the ship did during WWI, but does not list ship's aftermath except in the infobox. More information needed please.
Stable
  • No issues. Last edit prior to this review was on June 5, 2010.
Illustrated
  • No issues. All three images shown (including German flag) are valid.
Result
  • Hold. Lot of work, but can be done for GA.

Reviewer: Chris (talk) 18:57, 13 June 2010 (UTC)Reply

After reviewing the adjustments made to this article, this has been failed to not providing all of the information reuqested, mainly in converting all tonnage to include both English and metric. Also, no information was given regarding when the ship was sent to the UK for scrapping. Chris (talk) 15:10, 22 June 2010 (UTC)Reply