Talk:Rule egoism

Latest comment: 3 years ago by 82.198.218.209 in topic How would this work in practice?

How would this work in practice? edit

So *when* would the rule egotist decide on a set of rules to live by? In each situation? Then I would find it better described as regular egotism plus an effort to make it appear rule-based. Only rarely? That seems very implausible. Like deciding at 18 years to live by the rule that people under 25 should always have priority and then living by that rule even when you turn 25. (I mean, rules *kind of* like that exist in society, but it makes no sense to be the only one living by such a rule.)

Also, what kind of rules are allowed? Apparently "I always have priority" is not, because if yes, rule egoism would reduce to regular egoism as there would not be a reason to come up with other rules. This again points to the conclusion that rule egoism is about finding rules to dress your egoism up in. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 82.198.218.209 (talk) 11:24, 2 October 2020 (UTC)Reply