Talk:Nick Robinson (journalist)/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

• Article v GA criteria
  • 1(a) Clarity, concision, spelling and grammar: PASS
  • 1(b) MoS: PASS
  • 2(a) refs / ref layout: PASS
  • 2(b) in-line citations / reliable sources: PASS
  • 2(c) No OR: PASS
  • 3(a) Coverage: PASS
  • 3(b) Focused: PASS / Neutral: PASS / Stable: PASS (JUST) - lots of instability in May and June but seems to have settled now. Two instances of recent unsourced additions have been reverted but these were dealt with.
  • 4: Illustrated: PASS
  • 4(a) images tagged/ licensed: PASS
  • 4(b) image relevance / captions: PASS

Reviewer: bodnotbod (talk) 09:26, 9 September 2010 (UTC)