Talk:Muhammad Ali vs. Oscar Bonavena
 | This article was nominated for deletion on 6 October 2016. The result of the discussion was keep. |
 | This article is rated Start-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Pinging other editors edit
In view of the fact that the main article, and also other Ali related fight articles, have been tagged for deletion i am pinging other editors who have edited Ali related articles, and who have not yet participated in this discussion, with a request to them to give their feedback on the article's deletion page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Muhammad_Ali_vs._Oscar_Bonavena
(If an editor has done editing on multiple articles, he or she is only being pinged once. Also, to save myself some trouble, i am only pinging people who have done editing on the Ali articles in 2016 and 2015. I am *not* pinging any IP editor, not pinging any blocked editor, and not pinging any editor who has already offered a comment in the discussion page.)
1. The following editors have done editing on the main article of Muhammad Ali: The Glory Years: Randy Kryn, Zackmann08
2. The following editors have done editing on the main article of Facing Ali: JLOPO
3. The following editors have done editing on Twelve Rounds to Glory: Stevietheman, Fadesga, Yankees10, Aristophanes68, Coolabahapple
4. The following editors have done editing on The Soul of a Butterfly: See above
5. The following editors have done editing on Muhammad Ali: His Life and Times: See above
6. The following editors have done editing on The Greatest: My Own Story: Bgwhite,GrahamHardy, Neptune's Trident, TahitiBlue Soham321 (talk) 18:58, 6 October 2016 (UTC)
Note on the Torres book edit
Jose Torres was himself a professional boxer and his book 'Sting Like a Bee:The Muhammad Ali Story' has the most complete description of the Ali vs. Bonavena fight i have read so far. Torres begins talking about Bonavena on page 48 of his book, and by the time we are on page 69 we are actually in round 9 of the Ali-Bonavena fight. Unfortunately pages 70-101 of the book are not accessible to me (i am reading the book on google books). So i don't know when exactly Torres stops talking about the Ali-Bonavena fight and the fight's aftermath. Using a conservative estimate, i gave the page numbers as 48-70 when i gave the reference to the book in the main article, but this needs to be corrected in future.Soham321 (talk)