Talk:Mornington Peninsula

Latest comment: 5 years ago by Teratix in topic Continual addition of poorly sourced list

Continual addition of poorly sourced list edit

Mornington2, you're still not getting the message about the need for good sourcing. I've undone the addition of this list twice but there are still many problems with it:

  1. At least six are sourced to Revolvy, a site which reuses Wikipedia content
  2. The heading specifies that the list is only of notable people precisely to stop this sort of indiscriminate addition – there are many entries that aren't bluelinks and shouldn't be included until articles are written
  3. Even the sourced entries have problems – the source for Roger Federer says he briefly stayed in a rental property for the Australian Open – that's not a strong enough connection to be included on a notable persons list

Please go back, look through every entry and check that there is a reliable source that shows the person should be included on the list. – Teratix 10:06, 28 January 2019 (UTC)Reply