Talk:Miss Universe Philippines Accredited Partners

Latest comment: 4 months ago by EdrianJustine in topic Article still problematic

Issues - You can help! edit

If there are certain issues that needs to be addressed, you could go and address to it as well. Don't rely the work much on others.

If you see a problem and wanted to address it, do so. You can help. 2001:4453:696:B100:1453:ACBC:7B3B:4B91 (talk) 11:31, 30 December 2023 (UTC)Reply

Article still problematic edit

Again, to be frank, the article remains to be marred with issues. Specifically:

  • Puffery and Tone: While the article is "formal in tone", it still speaks highly of the program, rather in a neutral tone. Moreover, the text here reads more than a news report rather than encyclopedia (usage of "last" in some of dates may conflict with Wikipedia:RELTIME). Minimize adjectives when unnecessary, especially in the lead, and avoid preceding dates with "last".
  • Excessive/Irrelevant Examples: The program started in 2024, and hence, relevant delegates are only from the 2024 edition and beyond. Any delegates or example before that point bears no relevance to this article's topic, especially when the delegates before 2024 chose a locality to represent, rather than to win a pageant to represent the said locality. Another irrelevant section here is the placement summary and the section that succeeds it; the same reason applies there, with the addition of the inclusion information from the Binibining Pilipinas pageant, which is highly irrelevant in this context, as it is a separate pageant. If the resultant structure creates sections that are relatively short, resort to following the format used on the article List of Miss Universe countries. Wait for the individual pageants to be independently notable to information regarding its heads and formation.
  • Citations: For its length, the article remains short on citations, specially for some dates and names, the latter raising concerns of Wikipedia:DOB.

The issues banner added here weeks ago should have been enough to see some of these issues solved. They do not need further explanation, but they remain prevalent, even if the issue banner was inappropriately removed before they were adequately addressed. The responsibility to solve these issues primarily lies on the frequent editors of the page, so do not expect passing editors to help that much. EdrianJustine (talk) 16:03, 19 January 2024 (UTC)Reply