Talk:List of museum ships/Options

Latest comment: 1 year ago by Knowledgekid87 in topic Option 2

This is a talk page for proposing layouts for new tables that will be used for new "List of museum ships in x" articles.

Idealy

edit
  • Lists of museum ships that are smaller and manageable per WP:SIZE.
  • Lists of ships that are not crowded in data fields (these are overwelming).

Option 1 (using Canada as an example)

edit

Canada

edit
Ship Launched Function Province Museum Coordinates
CSS Acadia[1]
1913
Research vessel Nova Scotia Maritime Museum of the Atlantic 44°38′51.7″N 63°34′15.8″W / 44.647694°N 63.571056°W / 44.647694; -63.571056
CCGS Alexander Henry[2]
1958
Icebreaker Ontario Lakehead Transportation Museum Society 44°13′28.5″N 76°28′56.5″W / 44.224583°N 76.482361°W / 44.224583; -76.482361
RV Ben Franklin[3]
1966
Submersible British Columbia Vancouver Maritime Museum 49°16′39″N 123°08′50″W / 49.277507°N 123.147265°W / 49.277507; -123.147265
CCGS Bradbury[4]
1915
Fisheries patrol vessel Manitoba Marine Museum of Manitoba 50°08′47″N 96°51′54″W / 50.146377°N 96.865109°W / 50.146377; -96.865109
Bras d'Or (R-103)
1957
Ferry Ontario Canada Science and Technology Museum 45°24′12″N 075°37′13″W / 45.40333°N 75.62028°W / 45.40333; -75.62028
HMCS Bras d'Or[5]
1968
Hydrofoil Quebec Musée Maritime du Québec 47°07′45″N 70°22′20″W / 47.129187°N 70.3720934°W / 47.129187; -70.3720934
Canadian National Tug no. 6
1948
Tugboat British Columbia S.S. Sicamous Inland Marine Museum 49°30′09″N 119°36′42″W / 49.502444°N 119.611721°W / 49.502444; -119.611721
CCGS Ernest Lapointe[5]
1940
Icebreaker Quebec Musée Maritime du Québec 47°07′45″N 70°22′20″W / 47.129187°N 70.3720934°W / 47.129187; -70.3720934
HMCS Haida[6]
1942
Destroyer Ontario HMCS Star 43°16′31″N 79°51′19″W / 43.27531°N 79.85538°W / 43.27531; -79.85538
James Whalen[7]
1906
Tugboat Ontario Kaministiquia Riverfront Heritage Park
Joe Simpson[8]
1963
Freighter Manitoba Marine Museum of Manitoba 50°08′47″N 96°51′55″W / 50.1465°N 96.8652°W / 50.1465; -96.8652
SS Keenora[4]
1897
Steamboat Manitoba Marine Museum of Manitoba 50°08′47″N 96°51′55″W / 50.1465°N 96.8652°W / 50.1465; -96.8652
SS Keewatin[9]
1907
Passenger ship Ontario Status unclear 44°44′55″N 79°48′04″W / 44.74868°N 79.80115°W / 44.74868; -79.80115
SS Keno[10]
1922
Sternwheeler Yukon National Historic Site of Canada 64°03′48″N 139°26′06″W / 64.0632°N 139.4350°W / 64.0632; -139.4350
SS Klondike[11]
1937
Sternwheeler Yukon National Historic Site of Canada 60°42′48″N 135°02′51″W / 60.71333°N 135.04750°W / 60.71333; -135.04750
MS Lady Canadian[12]
1944
Fishing vessel Manitoba Marine Museum of Manitoba 50°08′47″N 96°51′55″W / 50.1465°N 96.8652°W / 50.1465; -96.8652
Moyie[13]
1898
Sternwheeler British Columbia National Historic Site of Canada 49°54′42″N 116°54′08″W / 49.9117°N 116.9023°W / 49.9117; -116.9023
Ned Hanlan[14]
1943
Tugboat Ontario Status unclear 43°37′41″N 79°23′22″W / 43.627979°N 79.389402°W / 43.627979; -79.389402
MS Norgoma[15]
1950
Ferry Ontario Status unclear 46°30′30″N 84°20′08″W / 46.508465°N 84.33569°W / 46.508465; -84.33569
Peguis II[8]
1955
Tugboat Manitoba Marine Museum of Manitoba 50°08′47″N 96°51′55″W / 50.1465°N 96.8652°W / 50.1465; -96.8652
Peninsula[16]
1943
Tugboat
Persephone[17]
1965
tugboat British Columbia Awaiting display 49°24′06.4″N 123°30′20.8″W / 49.401778°N 123.505778°W / 49.401778; -123.505778
Radium King[18]
1937
Tugboat Northwest Territories Northern Life Museum 60°00′17″N 111°53′19″W / 60.004827°N 111.888603°W / 60.004827; -111.888603
HMCS Sackville[19]
1941
Corvette Nova Scotia Maritime Museum of the Atlantic 44°38′51.7″N 63°34′15.8″W / 44.647694°N 63.571056°W / 44.647694; -63.571056
SS Sicamous[20]
1914
Sternwheeler British Columbia S.S. Sicamous Restoration Society (local) 49°30′07″N 119°36′40″W / 49.50184°N 119.61099°W / 49.50184; -119.61099
RCMPV St Roch[21]
1928
Schooner British Columbia Vancouver Maritime Museum 49°16′39″N 123°08′50″W / 49.277507°N 123.147265°W / 49.277507; -123.147265
St. André[22]
1956
Schooner Quebec Musée Maritime de Charlevoix
Tilikum[23]
1850
Dugout canoe British Columbia Maritime Museum of British Columbia 48°25′33.26″N 123°22′7.66″W / 48.4259056°N 123.3687944°W / 48.4259056; -123.3687944

Replicas

edit

See also

edit

Notes

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ "Historic Places of Canada". Retrieved 14 September 2016.
  2. ^ "Alexander Henry". Marine Museum of the Great Lakes. Archived from the original on 23 September 2016. Retrieved 14 September 2016.
  3. ^ "The Ben Franklin – Grumman/Piccard PX15 Submersible". NASA. Archived from the original on 16 September 2016. Retrieved 17 September 2016.
  4. ^ a b "Exhibits". Marine Museum of Manitoba. Archived from the original on 2018-01-27. Retrieved 11 February 2018.
  5. ^ a b "Hydro-Québec Park". Musée Maritime du Québec. Archived from the original on 28 August 2010. Retrieved 4 April 2017.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
  6. ^ "HMCS Haida National Historic Site". Parks Canada. Retrieved 19 September 2016.
  7. ^ "JAMES WHALEN TUG". City of Thunder Bay. Archived from the original on 2018-01-20. Retrieved 20 January 2018.
  8. ^ a b "Exhibits 3". Marine Museum of Manitoba. Archived from the original on 2018-02-12. Retrieved 11 February 2018.
  9. ^ "Keewatin Maritime Museum". Keewatin Maritime Museum. Retrieved 21 September 2016.
  10. ^ "S.S. Keno National Historic Site of Canada". Canada's Historic Places. Retrieved 11 February 2018.
  11. ^ "SS Klondike NHS". Parks Canada. Retrieved 21 September 2016.
  12. ^ Cite error: The named reference Exhibits 2 was invoked but never defined (see the help page).
  13. ^ "WELCOME TO THE S.S. MOYIE". KOOTENAY LAKE HISTORICAL SOCIETY. Retrieved 11 February 2018.
  14. ^ "Toronto's iconic tug off to new home". Toronto Sun. Retrieved 25 September 2016.
  15. ^ "History". MS Norgoma. Archived from the original on 12 October 2016. Retrieved 25 September 2016.
  16. ^ "Peninsula undergoes final polish in Marathon, Ont". CBC. 15 November 2018. Retrieved 6 December 2018.
  17. ^ "Beachcomber relics". Sunshine Coat Museum. Retrieved 25 September 2016.
  18. ^ "King of the River". Uphere Magazine. Retrieved 2 October 2016.
  19. ^ "HMCS Sackville". Canadian Navy Memorial Trust. Retrieved 2 October 2016.
  20. ^ "History of the SS Sicamous". SS Sicamous. Archived from the original on 9 October 2016. Retrieved 3 October 2016.
  21. ^ "St Roch National Historic Site". Vancouver Maritime Museum. Retrieved 2 October 2016.
  22. ^ "Musée Maritime de Charlevoix". www.museemaritime.com.
  23. ^ "Tilikum". Maritime Museum of British Columbia. Retrieved 11 February 2018.

Bibliography

edit
  • Ehlers, Hartmut (2004). "The Paraguayan Navy: Past and Present, Part II". Warship International. XLI (2): 173–206. ISSN 0043-0374.
edit


Option 2

edit

Sample rows are the first four alphabetically in big list, and other semi-complicated ones.

Changes made:

  • field "Location" gets street address (possibly) city, state or province, nation
  • "Origin" -> "Nation" and show nations which built, operated, or preserved ship, or had other significant association
  • "Type" -> "Function"
  • Show multiple names of ship when renamed significantly
  • When multiple nations show, first may be the ship's builder and/or it may be first operator of ship.
  • Note just "Museum" is not enough to identify location, as museums have multiple locations or have ships sailing or berthed remotely, besides the fact that coordinates (very specific locations) differ for two ships at same museum building.
Ship Launched Nation Function Location
HNoMS Alta
1953
  United States
  Belgium
  Norway
Minesweeper Royal Norwegian Navy Museum
North Akershus Quay, Oslo, Norway
59°54′33″N 10°44′04″E / 59.90913°N 10.73433°E / 59.90913; 10.73433 (HNoMS Alta)
HNoMS Blink[1]
1965
  Norway Patrol boat Royal Norwegian Navy Museum
Horten, Norway
59°25′34″N 10°29′12″E / 59.426°N 10.48672°E / 59.426; 10.48672 (HNoMS Blink)
BAE Abdón Calderón[2]
1884
  Scotland
  Chile
  Ecuador
Naval ship Museo Naval y Buque Calderón, Parque de la Armada (Navy Park), Guayaquil, Ecuador
2°12′56″S 79°53′14″W / 2.21547°S 79.88729°W / -2.21547; -79.88729 (BAE Abdón Calderón)
Admiral Nevelskoi[3]
1982
  Soviet Union
  Mauritius
Yacht Admiral Nevelskoi Maritime Museum
Avenue Surath, Quatre-Bornes, Mauritius
HNLMS Abraham Crijnssen[4]
1936
  Netherlands Minesweeper Dutch Navy Museum
Den Helder, Netherlands
52°57′50″N 4°46′15″E / 52.96389°N 4.77083°E / 52.96389; 4.77083 (HNLMS Abraham Crijnssen)
USCGC Acacia[5]
1944
  United States USCG seagoing buoy tender SS City of Milwaukee N.H.L. museum
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
44°15′34″N 86°18′54″W / 44.25944°N 86.31500°W / 44.25944; -86.31500 (USCGC Acacia)
INS Af Al Pi Chen[6]
LCT 147
1942
  United Kingdom
  Israel
Landing craft tank Clandestine Immigration and Naval Museum, Haifa, Israel
32°49′48″N 34°58′15″E / 32.83011°N 34.97079°E / 32.83011; 34.97079 (LCT 147)

References

  1. ^ "Naval Museum". Forsvaret Museer. Retrieved 17 September 2016.
  2. ^ "BAE Abdon Calderon Museum". Guayaquil es mi Destino. Retrieved 9 May 2017.
  3. ^ "Admiral Nevelskoi". Shipspotting. Retrieved 9 September 2020.
  4. ^ "HISTORISCHE SCHEPEN". Marinemuseum. Retrieved 14 September 2016.
  5. ^ "SS City of Milwaukee". Carferry. Retrieved 3 October 2016.
  6. ^ "INS Af Al Pi Chen". Historic Naval Ships Association. Retrieved 15 October 2017.

Discussion

edit

I think we can agree on three columns "Ship", "Launched", and "Function. These are the basics needed for describing the ship included on the list, its the location and how to present it which is the sticking point. This is just thinking out loud, I will respond more in a bit. - Knowledgekid87 (talk) 20:21, 6 January 2023 (UTC)Reply

Option 3 ?

edit

Your option here...