Talk:List of hadith books

Latest comment: 4 years ago by Hasan.2526272829 in topic List Rearrangement

[Untitled]

edit

Request to either rethink, add or remove the last part in the first sentence

'The following is a list of Hadīth collections, which are sources that contain the sayings, acts or tacit approvals, validly or invalidly, ascribed to the Islamic prophet, Muhammad by hadithist Sunnis.'

In short: The following is a list of Hadith collections by hadithist Sunnis.

The sentence indicates Sunnis created a list of the Hadith collections.

The word Hadith itself means 'statement' or 'talk', so when I read the full sentence, it seems like only Sunnis reported hadith.

  • Response

Hasan.2526272829 (talk) 07:49, 20 May 2019 (UTC) If you start reading from the start of the page it says List of Hadith Collection and then under sub heading it says Sunni Collection, Shia Collection, Ibadi Collection etc. So it is not evident that page shows only that Hadiths are collected/written by Sunnis only.Reply

List Rearrangement

edit

The creator of this page created Primary Hadith books list but within the list it added secondary books as well. So it has been now separated to better understand the topic. Hasan.2526272829 (talk) 07:49, 20 May 2019 (UTC)Reply

List rearrangement of Shia Hadith books

edit

The list of Shia Hadith books are also arranged in primary and secondary list to better understand the topic. So it should not be changed until have clear reason for reversing the change in talk page. Hasan.2526272829 (talk) 08:22, 19 December 2019 (UTC)Reply