| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Inclusion criteria |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Inclusion criteria
|
| Dominant populations as potentially indigenous |
9 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples#Dominant populations as potentially indigenous
|
| Sorbs (Wends) do not identify themselves as an "indigenous people" |
4 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 1#Sorbs (Wends) do not identify themselves as an "indigenous people"
|
| What should be listed under "Circumpolar North" |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 1#What should be listed under "Circumpolar North"
|
| Are Copts considered a people |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 1#Are Copts considered a people
|
| Are the Jews an indigenous people? |
5 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 1#Are the Jews an indigenous people?
|
| No more Ainu on Sakhalin island |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 1#No more Ainu on Sakhalin island
|
| Indigenous Finns? |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 1#Indigenous Finns?
|
| Tongans: A problematic inclusion |
4 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 1#Tongans: A problematic inclusion
|
| Removal of two sub-lists |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 1#Removal of two sub-lists
|
| Palestinians are indigenous |
8 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 1#Palestinians are indigenous
|
| Request for Comment: Palestinian indigeneity |
70 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 2#Request for Comment: Palestinian indigeneity
|
| Jews - Martinez Cobo |
31 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 2#Jews - Martinez Cobo
|
| Inclusion criteria for Southern Africa |
6 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 2#Inclusion criteria for Southern Africa
|
| East Africa |
3 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 2#East Africa
|
| Terms of reference |
6 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 2#Terms of reference
|
| Zambonji |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 2#Zambonji
|
| Breakdown |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 2#Breakdown
|
| Amero-Liberians |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 2#Amero-Liberians
|
| Proposal for inclusion |
28 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 2#Proposal for inclusion
|
| Samaritans, Jews, Druze, Maronite Christians, Palestinian Christians, Palestinian Arabs, Bedouin... |
6 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 2#Samaritans, Jews, Druze, Maronite Christians, Palestinian Christians, Palestinian Arabs, Bedouin...
|
| Somalis |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Somalis
|
| Aymara/Quechua |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Aymara/Quechua
|
| Assessment comment |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Assessment comment
|
| Where are the Arameans? |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Where are the Arameans?
|
| References for the Inclusion of Palestinians |
6 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#References for the Inclusion of Palestinians
|
| Revised References for the Inclusion of Palestinians |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Revised References for the Inclusion of Palestinians
|
| Removed lie |
10 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Removed lie
|
| Merger proposal |
6 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Merger proposal
|
| Han Chinese as Indigenous? |
6 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Han Chinese as Indigenous?
|
| Full-protected |
5 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Full-protected
|
| Peculiar... |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Peculiar...
|
| Palestinians are included yet the indigenous pre-Zionist Jewish population is not? |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Palestinians are included yet the indigenous pre-Zionist Jewish population is not?
|
| Edit request on 17 February 2012 |
15 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Edit request on 17 February 2012
|
| Inclusion of Iranic peoples in list |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Inclusion of Iranic peoples in list
|
| Internal Contridiction in Article |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Internal Contridiction in Article
|
| Bedouin vs Tribal Arab |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Bedouin vs Tribal Arab
|
| Why are the Palestinians on here? |
4 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Why are the Palestinians on here?
|
| Added White Americans under the same logic for including "Palestinians" |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Added White Americans under the same logic for including "Palestinians"
|
| Are white people not native to anywhere? |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Are white people not native to anywhere?
|
| Why not Irish people |
4 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Why not Irish people
|
| Shouldn't Hebrews/Israelites be on here? |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Shouldn't Hebrews/Israelites be on here?
|
| Why are Kurds and "Bahrainis" listed but not other Iranic peoples? |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Why are Kurds and "Bahrainis" listed but not other Iranic peoples?
|
| Please expand the definition of indigenous peoples |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Please expand the definition of indigenous peoples
|
| Please remove fictional people |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Please remove fictional people
|
| Request to replace "Old Yishuv" with just "Jews" |
9 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Request to replace "Old Yishuv" with just "Jews"
|
| Edit semi-protected |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Edit semi-protected
|
| Minor problem |
3 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Minor problem
|
| I am fixing the page and adding 'Jews', as per EvilDoer's Request, to avoid further 'edit-wars'. |
6 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#I am fixing the page and adding 'Jews', as per EvilDoer's Request, to avoid further 'edit-wars'.
|
| Jewish diaspora |
3 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#Jewish diaspora
|
| RFC: Proposal to exclude Jews and Palestinians |
63 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 3#RFC: Proposal to exclude Jews and Palestinians
|
| RfC: Counter proposal in favor of including Jews and Palestinians, and applying a different definition of "indigenous" |
21 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 4#RfC: Counter proposal in favor of including Jews and Palestinians, and applying a different definition of "indigenous"
|
| Synthesis of references |
26 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 4#Synthesis of references
|
| Notice added under Southwest Asia |
14 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 4#Notice added under Southwest Asia
|
| Unjustified reversion of edits |
3 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 4#Unjustified reversion of edits
|
| Definition of indigenousness |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 4#Definition of indigenousness
|
| WP:OR |
45 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 4#WP:OR
|
| Israelis and Palestinian |
35 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 4#Israelis and Palestinian
|
| Requests for page protection |
4 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 6#Requests for page protection
|
| Include Jews as Indigenous to Western Asia |
60 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 5#Include Jews as Indigenous to Western Asia
|
| A Call to Reason & Neutrality |
5 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 5#A Call to Reason & Neutrality
|
| This page may be protected |
4 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 5#This page may be protected
|
| The case for including Yisrael/Israelites/Hebrews/Jews/Israelis as an indigenous Western Asian group |
4 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 5#The case for including Yisrael/Israelites/Hebrews/Jews/Israelis as an indigenous Western Asian group
|
| Since the discussion at the complaint page has been closed |
20 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 5#Since the discussion at the complaint page has been closed
|
| Modern history, the concept of the "national state", and Palestine |
8 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 5#Modern history, the concept of the "national state", and Palestine
|
| Kurds |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 5#Kurds
|
| The case for excluding Palestinians as an indigenous Western Asian group |
4 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 5#The case for excluding Palestinians as an indigenous Western Asian group
|
| Protected per a complaint at WP:Arbitration enforcement |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 5#Protected per a complaint at WP:Arbitration enforcement
|
| Either include both Jews and Palestinians, or neither |
7 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 6#Either include both Jews and Palestinians, or neither
|
| RfC: Should the Palestinians be included on the list on the basis of tacit UN recognition since at least 2009? |
63 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 6#RfC: Should the Palestinians be included on the list on the basis of tacit UN recognition since at least 2009?
|
| Unreliable source |
20 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 6#Unreliable source
|
| Bot archiving temporarily disabled |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 6#Bot archiving temporarily disabled
|
| Typo - a apart |
4 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 6#Typo - a apart
|
| Remove Israeli Arab conflict tag |
4 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 6#Remove Israeli Arab conflict tag
|
| Iranian peoples |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Iranian peoples
|
| New Zealand, Madagascar, and Iceland |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#New Zealand, Madagascar, and Iceland
|
| Armenians |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Armenians
|
| So many peoples in this list who don't fit the guidelines.... |
22 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#So many peoples in this list who don't fit the guidelines....
|
| Major changes |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Major changes
|
| Northern subarticles |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Northern subarticles
|
| Jews are listed again |
14 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Jews are listed again
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#External links modified
|
| Cross-cultural sample |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Cross-cultural sample
|
| Include extinct peoples? |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Include extinct peoples?
|
| White people |
7 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#White people
|
| World Directory of Minorities and Indigenous Peoples |
2 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#World Directory of Minorities and Indigenous Peoples
|
| Classify both Jews and Palestinians as Indigenous? |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Classify both Jews and Palestinians as Indigenous?
|
| Removing Jews |
49 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Removing Jews
|
| The Welsh are indigenous people of Britain |
6 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#The Welsh are indigenous people of Britain
|
| Europe Section Unsourced |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Europe Section Unsourced
|
| Clean up |
29 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 8#Clean up
|
| Better Wikidata than Wikipedia |
3 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Better Wikidata than Wikipedia
|
| Melanesia and Polynesia |
14 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Melanesia and Polynesia
|
| Collected Definitions of "Indigenous Peoples", for Reference |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples/Archive 7#Collected Definitions of "Indigenous Peoples", for Reference
|
| Convention is to capitalize "Indigenous" when referring to ethnic groups |
4 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples#Convention is to capitalize "Indigenous" when referring to ethnic groups
|
| A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples#A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion
|
| Which national variety of English? |
3 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples#Which national variety of English?
|
| Where's Mali people for instance, the Dogon etcetera? Saharan people |
1 |
Talk:List of Indigenous peoples#Where's Mali people for instance, the Dogon etcetera? Saharan people
|
