Talk:Krasnogvardeysky District, Orenburg Oblast

Amantay

The purpose of the "Notable people" section is to list people strongly associated with the entity the article is about. If a notable person was born, lived, and/or became famous in a particular place, a link to the article about that person would be appropriate in the "Notable people" section about that place. When there is no article covering the place, it may be appropriate to elevate and to include the entry in the article about a division to which that place belongs. However, one needs to be careful to avoid historical anachronisms. Gabdulla Amantay entry would be appropriate in Verkhneilyasovo, Buzuluksky Uyezd, and Samara Governorate articles, but not in Krasnogvardeysky District, Orenburg Oblast article, since this entity was not created until well after Amantay's death. To insist on such inclusion is nearly as absurd as including Yury Dolgoruky in the list of Moscow Oblast's natives.—Ëzhiki (Igels Hérissonovich Ïzhakoff-Amursky) • (yo?); June 5, 2014; 18:18 (UTC)

In Russia, the administrative boundaries so often change

Therefore, the place of birth indicate present in the moment.

Therefore reject incorrectly edit the writer Gabdulla Amantay that is associated with Krasnogvardeysky District.

The village where he was born to be here today in this area.(yo?); June 5, 2014; 18:46 (UTC)

Amantay has nothing to do with the district because he was neither born in the district nor lived there. The district simply did not exist during his lifetime. That the village he was born in is in the district now does not make your edit acceptable, because the purpose of the "Notable people" section is to list people who are notable for their activities in relation to the entity the article is about. By definition, this article cannot contain any people whose notable activities predate the creation of the district.

That aside, note that this is your forth revert in a row, thus putting you in violation of WP:3RR. I have no desire to report you, but I will if you don't self-revert promptly. That our opinions differ is a cause to seek input of a third party, not to pig-headedly revert war as you are doing now.—Ëzhiki (Igels Hérissonovich Ïzhakoff-Amursky) • (yo?); June 5, 2014; 19:20 (UTC)