Talk:Katherine Beck

Latest comment: 18 years ago by Thivierr

note: The following information was gathered after this article was first created, and was considered when deleting it. I have re-copied it here, since it may be of use, in the future in deciding whether to a) create an article, b) create a disambig page and/or c) change the re-direct. So, to avoid the need for re-googling everything from scratch, here it is: --rob 12:26, 16 September 2005 (UTC)Reply

Katherine Beck could be a FAKE edit

There is no proof in the article that she writes for The New Yorker. I realize most contributors are not on their web site, but some link somewhere should exist, which mentions her work. Or, at least a reference to a specific issue, and what she put in it, would be good. Anything verifiable would be helpful. Actually, *any* link which identifies *which* of the several people named "Katherine Beck" is being discussed would be good.

Also, http://www.columbia.edu let's you search for faculty and staff, and she does not appear. This is probably the bigest evidence this is fake.

Here are all potential people I found in Google, who have at times used the *exact* name "Katherine Beck", who I've ruled out:

That's it. Nothing else I see in Google could back up this article. --rob 00:26, 8 September 2005 (UTC)Reply