Talk:Izhar Hunzai
 | This article was nominated for deletion on 2006 August 8. The result of the discussion was no consensus. |
fuddlemark (befuddle me!) 14:42, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
Restoration of Izhar Hunzai content from the Aga Khan Development Network article edit
The discussion on the proposal to delete this article in August, 2006 resulted in no concensus. As a result the bizzare decision was taken to merge the content of this article into the Aga Khan Development Network article. This was an inappropriate solution - essentially dumping the contents of an unwanted article into a context where it had no place. The new Izhar Hunzai section was deleted from its new location and has since been reinstated. This resulted in the discussion cited below. Izhar Hunzai sounds like a great individual, certainly his father is a well known figure in Northern Pakistan. I have no objection to the existance of an article about him (as long as it is properly maintained). However, the content of this article has no place in the Aga Khan Development Network article. If the Izhar Hunzai content is to be retained it should be done here. If not, simply delete it. Please do not dump it inappropriately on other articles. -- Aylahs (talk) 17:18, 1 December 2006 (UTC)
Copied from Talk:Aga Khan Development Network:
- The article on Izhar Hunzai was retained following an AfD here. The balance of opinion was that it should be merged into here. If an editor is unhappy then the answer is a second AfD on which I would abstain because of my involvement thus far. BlueValour 23:06, 30 November 2006 (UTC)
- The inclusion of the Izhar Hunzai section in this article does not make sense. He is one program manager among many in a vast international organization comprising multiple agencies that each run multiple programs. There is nothing remarkable about his personal contribution to the organization that warrants his inclusion in this article. Including a section on his is akin to profiling a particular mid-level employee of Microsoft on their wiki article.
- If, in the wisdom of the wikipedia community, the Izhar Hunzai content is valuable enough to be preserved it should be done elsewhere - perhaps within its own article. Dumping its content inappropriately on this article is not the solution. I am not sure how this is to be resolved within Wikipedia policy / convention, but placing an AfD on this article is unwarranted.
- Accordingly, I am moving the Izhar Hunzai back to its own page and I will place an AfD on that article. I will include a copy of this discussion thread to provide context.
- -- Aylahs (talk) 17:05, 1 December 2006 (UTC)