| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Graph |
13 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#Graph
|
| 2 paras cut |
28 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#2 paras cut
|
| Note to Article Readers |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#Note to Article Readers
|
| why is this not Mann's graph? |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#why is this not Mann's graph?
|
| Hard to reconcile? |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#Hard to reconcile?
|
| Added IPCC Chart |
7 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#Added IPCC Chart
|
| Borehole comments |
24 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#Borehole comments
|
| Graphs |
10 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#Graphs
|
| Citecheck needed |
8 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#Citecheck needed
|
| POV text |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#POV text
|
| A note |
4 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#A note
|
| William, you are doing it again |
24 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#William, you are doing it again
|
| Editorial Question |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#Editorial Question
|
| NRC report |
11 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#NRC report
|
| "US Congress" |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#"US Congress"
|
| Restored essential information about Mann's data withholding |
10 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#Restored essential information about Mann's data withholding
|
| Too much von S? |
8 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#Too much von S?
|
| Exponential growth? |
4 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#Exponential growth?
|
| All in a good cause by Orson Scott Card |
21 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 1#All in a good cause by Orson Scott Card
|
| Raymond, why delete my comment? |
11 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Raymond, why delete my comment?
|
| Breaking news? |
8 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Breaking news?
|
| Re: Breaking News |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Re: Breaking News
|
| General Comment |
12 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#General Comment
|
| Recreated Shape Claim |
4 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Recreated Shape Claim
|
| Revision of Update section |
8 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Revision of Update section
|
| Concerns Over Poor Quality |
4 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Concerns Over Poor Quality
|
| Academy affirms hockey-stick graph |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Academy affirms hockey-stick graph
|
| Error bars |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Error bars
|
| Wahl and Ammann 2006-2008 |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Wahl and Ammann 2006-2008
|
| Ian Joliffe rejects Mann's "decentered PCA" |
9 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Ian Joliffe rejects Mann's "decentered PCA"
|
| Bias |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Bias
|
| Ms. Schakowsky described Mann's seminal paper as:"....this false or inaccurate Dr. Mann study" |
14 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Ms. Schakowsky described Mann's seminal paper as:"....this false or inaccurate Dr. Mann study"
|
| 43 coincidence? |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#43 coincidence?
|
| Regulation of comments |
12 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Regulation of comments
|
| Explanation of Tony Sidaway's revert of an edit by 70.234.173.145 |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Explanation of Tony Sidaway's revert of an edit by 70.234.173.145
|
| "Hockey Stick" now proven not to exist |
34 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#"Hockey Stick" now proven not to exist
|
| Mining Executive |
31 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Mining Executive
|
| Prot |
7 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Prot
|
| Lead addition |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Lead addition
|
| Minor Corrections or Updates |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Minor Corrections or Updates
|
| Explanation of term "hockey stick" |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#Explanation of term "hockey stick"
|
| The "Updates" section |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 2#The "Updates" section
|
| 'Claims' or 'conclusions' |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#'Claims' or 'conclusions'
|
| Intro |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Intro
|
| CRU whistleblower relevant |
19 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#CRU whistleblower relevant
|
| Wegman report addition |
6 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Wegman report addition
|
| NASA Indicates 1934 was the hottest year in North America |
6 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#NASA Indicates 1934 was the hottest year in North America
|
| history missing |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#history missing
|
| Problem with the whole article |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Problem with the whole article
|
| IPCC Chart and the MBH98 reconstruction |
13 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#IPCC Chart and the MBH98 reconstruction
|
| Article probation |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Article probation
|
| National Academy of Sciences report |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#National Academy of Sciences report
|
| Mann testimony |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Mann testimony
|
| Enforcement Request |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Enforcement Request
|
| Wegman report criticisms, WP:PRIMARY, and WP:WEIGHT |
11 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Wegman report criticisms, WP:PRIMARY, and WP:WEIGHT
|
| Richard Muller reaction |
8 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Richard Muller reaction
|
| Editing restrictions? |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Editing restrictions?
|
| A kind offer of assistance moved from the wrong place |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#A kind offer of assistance moved from the wrong place
|
| External links |
7 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#External links
|
| See also link |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#See also link
|
| Divergence of tree-ring proxies from instrumental temperature records |
4 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Divergence of tree-ring proxies from instrumental temperature records
|
| Rv |
10 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Rv
|
| Booker's book |
6 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Booker's book
|
| POV title |
4 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#POV title
|
| Shall we mention the controversy in the intro? |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Shall we mention the controversy in the intro?
|
| New hockey stick graph released |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#New hockey stick graph released
|
| Rv: why |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Rv: why
|
| von S |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#von S
|
| The opening paragraph is incorrect - the hockey stick is not the first quantitive global temperature estimate. |
23 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#The opening paragraph is incorrect - the hockey stick is not the first quantitive global temperature estimate.
|
| Public Domain of CRU documents |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Public Domain of CRU documents
|
| WTF? |
13 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#WTF?
|
| Lost refs, fix please? |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Lost refs, fix please?
|
| Downward trend |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Downward trend
|
| Article issues |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Article issues
|
| Add Cuffey quote, criticism of IPCC use of HS graph |
7 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#Add Cuffey quote, criticism of IPCC use of HS graph
|
| David Hand comments |
77 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 3#David Hand comments
|
| Abuse |
7 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 4#Abuse
|
| Hand |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 4#Hand
|
| This article will likely need a major rewrite ... but not quite yet |
8 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 4#This article will likely need a major rewrite ... but not quite yet
|
| Der Spiegel - Computer using Mann's Method given Random Data, Hockey Stick Graph Produced |
47 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 4#Der Spiegel - Computer using Mann's Method given Random Data, Hockey Stick Graph Produced
|
| RealClimate and Climate Audit |
9 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 4#RealClimate and Climate Audit
|
| ClimateGate emails |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 4#ClimateGate emails
|
| David Hand comments on the hockey stick |
24 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 4#David Hand comments on the hockey stick
|
| New source |
127 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 4#New source
|
| Sourcing previously unsourced text |
26 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Sourcing previously unsourced text
|
| Badly formed reference? |
11 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Badly formed reference?
|
| High level outline |
6 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#High level outline
|
| Less of an Encyclopedia article and more of a report |
0 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Less of an Encyclopedia article and more of a report
|
| Defending the indefensible? |
17 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Defending the indefensible?
|
| Virginia fraud investigation about Michael Mann as a result of the Climategate emails |
7 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Virginia fraud investigation about Michael Mann as a result of the Climategate emails
|
| In contrast, Richard Muller... |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#In contrast, Richard Muller...
|
| McShane and Wyner 2010 |
13 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#McShane and Wyner 2010
|
| Self-published analysis of McShane and Wyner 2010 |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Self-published analysis of McShane and Wyner 2010
|
| Deep Climate and Wegman |
39 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Deep Climate and Wegman
|
| Untrue statement? |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Untrue statement?
|
| Reorganisation |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Reorganisation
|
| Inhofe's name is misspelled |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Inhofe's name is misspelled
|
| scientific consensus |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#scientific consensus
|
| Edit request from 65.78.29.19, 18 April 2011 |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Edit request from 65.78.29.19, 18 April 2011
|
| Edit request from Toliynyk, 2 May 2011 |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Edit request from Toliynyk, 2 May 2011
|
| No controversy |
4 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#No controversy
|
| Mostly good updates, but a few nits. |
6 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Mostly good updates, but a few nits.
|
| Revision of Wegman plagiarism controversy |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Revision of Wegman plagiarism controversy
|
| Some reverts & underlying scientific controversy |
13 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Some reverts & underlying scientific controversy
|
| Restoring some balance in the discussion |
57 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 5#Restoring some balance in the discussion
|
| IPCC TAR hockeystick graph |
27 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 6#IPCC TAR hockeystick graph
|
| Update of MM 2005 section |
17 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 6#Update of MM 2005 section
|
| bias in S&B section |
17 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 6#bias in S&B section
|
| Reorganisation of controversy section |
30 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 6#Reorganisation of controversy section
|
| proposed article structure |
7 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 6#proposed article structure
|
| Edit Request |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 6#Edit Request
|
| Pearce Guardian experiment not RS |
6 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 6#Pearce Guardian experiment not RS
|
| "Origin of the controversy" subsection: comments, questions, recommendations |
17 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 6#"Origin of the controversy" subsection: comments, questions, recommendations
|
| "Some" contrarians |
22 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 6#"Some" contrarians
|
| CRU founded 1971 or 1972? |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 6#CRU founded 1971 or 1972?
|
| Minority denying global warming was a problem |
24 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 6#Minority denying global warming was a problem
|
| RfC: Spencer Weart and 'the dedicated minority who denied global warming was a problem prompty attacked the calculations' |
28 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#RfC: Spencer Weart and 'the dedicated minority who denied global warming was a problem prompty attacked the calculations'
|
| Summary of outstanding POV issues in S&B section |
16 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#Summary of outstanding POV issues in S&B section
|
| RfC: neutral language and reliable sources |
40 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#RfC: neutral language and reliable sources
|
| Tony Sidaway's removal of the POV tag |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#Tony Sidaway's removal of the POV tag
|
| Bending over backwards |
18 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#Bending over backwards
|
| POV in Soon & Baliunas section |
11 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#POV in Soon & Baliunas section
|
| Tone and phrasing |
7 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#Tone and phrasing
|
| statistics |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#statistics
|
| The worry over "neutrality" and "sources" has made this article impossible to grasp by us, common users. |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#The worry over "neutrality" and "sources" has made this article impossible to grasp by us, common users.
|
| McIntyre and McKitrick 2005 |
7 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#McIntyre and McKitrick 2005
|
| Hide the Decline |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#Hide the Decline
|
| Request for comment |
7 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#Request for comment
|
| Clean up talk? |
4 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#Clean up talk?
|
| Climategate 2.0 emails |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#Climategate 2.0 emails
|
| De Freitas qualifiers uncited, again |
25 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 7#De Freitas qualifiers uncited, again
|
| Von Storch' opinion? |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#Von Storch' opinion?
|
| Summary of Controversy |
6 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#Summary of Controversy
|
| NPOV wording |
6 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#NPOV wording
|
| Kyoto and Hockey Stick |
17 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#Kyoto and Hockey Stick
|
| Request for comment |
18 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#Request for comment
|
| Petroleum Institute |
9 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#Petroleum Institute
|
| Kinne on Climate research |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#Kinne on Climate research
|
| please show wp "lock" |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#please show wp "lock"
|
| McShane and Wyner 2010 and the divergence problem |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#McShane and Wyner 2010 and the divergence problem
|
| Plagiarism section too big |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#Plagiarism section too big
|
| Yamal, Briffa and the Hockey Stick |
18 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#Yamal, Briffa and the Hockey Stick
|
| What scientific papers? |
17 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#What scientific papers?
|
| Improve the article by mentioning the Yamal controversy |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#Improve the article by mentioning the Yamal controversy
|
| NRC report |
8 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#NRC report
|
| RC |
4 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#RC
|
| Views out of context |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#Views out of context
|
| Chronological bibliography? |
144 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 8#Chronological bibliography?
|
| Paywalled, but could be of interest |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Paywalled, but could be of interest
|
| Plagiarism charge section; corrections from recent FOIAs |
8 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Plagiarism charge section; corrections from recent FOIAs
|
| McKitrick APEC |
4 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#McKitrick APEC
|
| Relative not absolute temperature |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Relative not absolute temperature
|
| To split? Or not to split? |
14 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#To split? Or not to split?
|
| Controversy source |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Controversy source
|
| Citation tail ends |
6 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Citation tail ends
|
| Many authors in 'citation': use 'coauthors' |
4 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Many authors in 'citation': use 'coauthors'
|
| Minor cleanup of lede |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Minor cleanup of lede
|
| Too long |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Too long
|
| Controversy over Bradley and Jones 1993 |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Controversy over Bradley and Jones 1993
|
| Broken refs |
6 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Broken refs
|
| History of variants of IPCC(1990) Fig 7.1(c), p.202 ... falsely claimed to be that, or even from 1995, plus the Deming tale |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#History of variants of IPCC(1990) Fig 7.1(c), p.202 ... falsely claimed to be that, or even from 1995, plus the Deming tale
|
| Removal of IPCC graphs |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Removal of IPCC graphs
|
| Poor choice for leading chart |
14 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Poor choice for leading chart
|
| The Pollack, Huang & Shen 1998 reconstruction covering the past 500 years gave independent support for this conclusion, which was compared against the independent (extra-tropical, warm-season) tree-ri |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#The Pollack, Huang & Shen 1998 reconstruction covering the past 500 years gave independent support for this conclusion, which was compared against the independent (extra-tropical, warm-season) tree-ri
|
| Proposing minor change in Harv template usage |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Proposing minor change in Harv template usage
|
| Mann claim about outcome of controversy |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Mann claim about outcome of controversy
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 22 June 2014 |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Semi-protected edit request on 22 June 2014
|
| Link to book section re HS controversy |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Link to book section re HS controversy
|
| Regarding Continuing Research |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Regarding Continuing Research
|
| Time to Update the Graph? |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Time to Update the Graph?
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 2 May 2015 |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 9#Semi-protected edit request on 2 May 2015
|
| Published comments regarding McIntyre and McKitrick (2005) are missing from discussion |
22 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 10#Published comments regarding McIntyre and McKitrick (2005) are missing from discussion
|
| respectfully |
5 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 10#respectfully
|
| Climate blogs |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 10#Climate blogs
|
| controversy ? |
13 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 10#controversy ?
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 10#External links modified
|
| Citations screwed up in the rendering |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 10#Citations screwed up in the rendering
|
| Climatic Research Unit email controversy |
2 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 10#Climatic Research Unit email controversy
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 10#External links modified
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy/Archive 10#External links modified
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy#External links modified
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy#External links modified
|
| "Named refs" not an appropriate "fix" for "duplicate refs" |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy#"Named refs" not an appropriate "fix" for "duplicate refs"
|
| External links modified (January 2018) |
0 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy#External links modified (January 2018)
|
| A passerby's comments |
3 |
Talk:Hockey stick controversy#A passerby's comments
|
